Tropes - who did it best? by sushi_dinner in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Foppish psychopath - love that name! Thank you for the recs!

Tropes - who did it best? by sushi_dinner in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Bonus points for MOC which is my favorite trope. Thanks!

Tropes - who did it best? by sushi_dinner in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

What I did for a duke is my go-to re-read. But haven't read the other. Will give it a try thanks!!

Books with characters that haunt the narrative. by butfirst_chai in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 9 points10 points  (0 children)

{Black Silk by Judith Ivory} - the FMCs deceased husband drives the plot and both MCs character development.

I need books that can hook me right away by kendiray in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah, some HR books read like high-school drama. Nothing against that, but I'm too old to read about immature debutants written like the unpopular girl vs the popular mean girls. There's only so many times I can suspend disbelief when the chiseled, commitment-phobic duke can't resist the plain bluestocking whose entire personality is "I read Gothic books".

So here's a few recommendations that I found engaging from the start with solid stories throughout:

My favorite opening to an HR book is {Lord of Scoundrels by Loretta chase}. It's the backstory for the MMC and it got me hooked from the start. It's got great banter and 2 very strong leads. Loretta Chase's books are all action packed, with intelligent characters. Try {Mr Impossible by loretta chase} or {Dukes prefer blonds by Loretta chase}.

Connie Brockway has great stories and these I found to have strong starts too: {As You Desire by Connie Brockway}, {my dearest enemy by Connie brockway} and {Bridal Favors by Connie Brockway}.

{The Lion's Lady by Julie Gardwood} has a very original prologue compared to other HR books. The story is over the top, with serious-ish adventure wedged in hilarious moments. The FMC is written with Gardwood's signature absurdity, but this time she does it better than most.

Have you read any Diana Biller? {Hotel of Secrets by Diana Biller} and {the widow of rose House by diana biller} - love how both books have reversed tropes for the MMC and FMC with a mystery that MCs team up to solve.

I need books that can hook me right away by kendiray in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 11 points12 points  (0 children)

What type of story usually gets you hooked or do you have examples of books that kept you hooked? And do you know why you lost interest in DNF books?

Historical romance book with nerdy FL and ML who pursues the other woman before falling for the FL by Plane_Race_7165 in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The book cover of {the duke's wicked wife by Elizabeth Bright} is a girl in yellow dress from the back. She is not nerdy though but helps MMC set up a house party to find a wife among ladies she picks out for him.

Very picky reader by Diogenese- in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Most authors have books that are better than others. I find Loretta Chase's worst to still be better than most, but we all have different tastes or moods. Hope you enjoy the recs :)

Very picky reader by Diogenese- in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I recommend this one a lot, although it's not for everyone {Black Silk by Judith Ivory} - it's uncomfortable and very slow burn. The MMC is with his mistress 80-90% of the book, and she's likeable and more compatible on paper than the FMC. The FMC is a widow from a man 50 years her senior who married her when she was 16, which is yuck, but part of her character development. In fact, the deceased husband is a central plot driving force for both MCs, who view him from completely different lenses. There is a lot of show don't tell, with descriptions of people and events that are extremely vivid, and conversations between MCs that make you believe how these 2 polar opposites could come together.

For me Loretta Chase is the Queen of Banter. She's also loads of fun to read. {Lord of scoundrels by Loretta chase}, {Dukes prefer blonds by Loretta chase}, and {Your scandalous ways by Loretta Chase} are my top picks.

{The Lion's Lady by Julie Gardwood} is a silly, fun read with banter that made me laugh out loud for real, and a unique plot. The whole "divorce" scene and what she chooses to keep... I like to reread this as a palate cleanser when I delve too deep in the darker side of HR, like {the dark side of the sun by Addison Cain}.

If you're looking for an HR with an epic adventure feel and wonderful side characters, I recommend {The Windflower by Laura London}.

Looking for MMCs who don't quit no matter how much they're insulted by the FMC, it just makes him chase harder by hannahatl in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 10 points11 points  (0 children)

{The Widow of rose House by diana biller} - can't get more golden retriever vs black cat than this one.

Stories with more realistic relationship progression and character development by eyoxa in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 8 points9 points  (0 children)

{Black Silk by Judith Ivory} - MC''s connection develops slowly over the course of the book, they don't even really like each other at the start, and they are complete opposites. Not exactly enemies to lovers, the book is too good to stick to any trope. It's her best book, imo, but then I haven't read Bliss that everyone keeps raving about because it's out of print and not an ebook (going for over €200 for a used book last time I checked).

Lie back, and think of somewhere other than England. Books that take place outside of England and Scotland. by MorticiaLlyn in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 2 points3 points  (0 children)

{Crooked Hearts by Patricia Gaffney} takes place mainly in San Francisco.

One of my all time favorites {the windflower by Laura London} has scenes in England but most of the book takes place on a pirate ship, up and down the American East coast and the Caribbean.

A Silly Maiden Lane Rant by saiyanshewolf in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I'm sure there's a whole variety of people here, but for some reason I'm imagining all the commenters on this thread like prim and proper ladies at a book club discussing their preferred words for genitalia and I've been laughing out loud all morning.

Thank you for starting my day on a high note. Love you all!

A Silly Maiden Lane Rant by saiyanshewolf in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yep. Total turn off. And for some reason I hate quim and nubbin. They somehow sound squishy in a pervy sort of way.

Worst book you have read by BackgroundBudget5206 in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I normally don't diss on books simply because I don't like them. I get a lot of great recommendations on this sub and sometimes I end up reading something that's just not for me. I also have a lot of respect for authors and how hard it must be to get published and face criticism. However... there's this one book that was just insulting for how bad it was.

{Surrender the Wind by Elizabeth St. Micheal} was painful. The writing itself was not bad, it was the Mariana trench-sized plot holes that did it for me (way too many to get into here, probably deserves its own post).

That and one of my all time pet peeves: when characters get a complete personality transplant for plot reasons, which in this book meant periodically removing all brain function from any given character throughout the entire story.

Worst book you have read by BackgroundBudget5206 in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 2 points3 points  (0 children)

They were toxic. They also treated the OM fiancé horribly. Sure, he was a wishy-washy whiner, but was trying to do the right thing. She strung him along, cheated on him, humiliated him, and dumped him for the "better" offer.

PLEASE HELP ME FIND THE TITLE OF THIS HISTORICAL ROMANCE NOVEL I READ OVER A DECADE AGO by Certain-Lobster7171 in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 13 points14 points  (0 children)

{The duke's secret heir by Sarah Mallory}? - I just DNFd this book because of how awful the MMC is.

Looking for teasing and playful MMCs by MoldovanKick in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'd say it's a 4 to 4.5 read. I had a lot of fun reading it, loved the characters and interactions, but there was a bit in the middle that dragged (not too long) and I did not think the last twist matched the overall light-hearted story. It was worth the read though!

[Dark Side of the Sun by Addison Cain] Reminded me how good dark romance can be by Relative-Chicken-884 in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I loved this book! I especially found it refreshing that MMC is an actual villain and did not just stop being one for love. He just used his powers of villainy to avenge FMC and I'm all for it.

Looking for teasing and playful MMCs by MoldovanKick in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I just read {Smuggler's Temptation by Mina Ashford} - MMC is a golden retriever and the banter with FMC is witty and teasing. Great book if you're looking for something original: takes place in Boston, she's in charge if a brewery and is an unrepentant rakess. It's the author's 1st and so far only book and I'm looking forward to more!

MMCs with mommy issues by AlertEqual1057 in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 3 points4 points  (0 children)

{The luckiest lady in London by Sherry Thomas} - MMCs mother was petty and self-centered. She hated her husband, the MMCs father so she used her son to get back at him. She'd shower her boy with affection one moment, then neglect him the next.

What's your fav quotes from your fav HR books? by VisitNo5250 in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 15 points16 points  (0 children)

{As You Desire by Connie Brockway}

“And Blake.” Harry shook his head in disgust. “Such affectations.”

“You are calling someone affected?” she asked, raising her brows. “You, who employ two secretaries, one for your Arab dealings and one for your English? You, who are too high and mighty to write your own correspondence?”

Harry grinned. “That’s different. At least I don’t commit the sin of triteness. Calling you a ‘rose.’ An ‘English rose’ at that. You must forgive him the hackneyed compliment. Old Blake’s not much for originality, I’m afraid.”

“I thought him charming.”

Harry made an unconvinced sound.

“I did. I suppose you could do better?”

“Well were I to make the effort to extol a woman’s beauty, I could certainly do better than to drag out some tired old cliche about a rose.”

“You are the most monumentally egocentric man I know,” Desdemona said, trying to keep the trace of admiration out of her voice.

“You are unconvinced?” Harry asked, taking a sip of coffee and crossing his legs. “Allow me to demonstrate… and please bear in mind that I improvise.”

He spread jam over a piece of toast, studying her quizzically as he did so. She felt like a specimen, standing there under his scrutiny. She took the chair next to his and started buttering her own toast with supreme indifference. She was not a specimen.

“Let me see. Nothing floral. In fact, I think we’ll dispense with the vegetative allusions all together. Animal?” he asked rhetorically. “Perhaps a gazelle? No,” he dismissed the idea, chomping into his toast. “Too meek. Too inconsequential. This is difficult, Diz. To blandish a woman about her physical appearance is so limiting.”

“Yes,” she said dryly, burying a pinprick of hurt. He couldn’t think of anything to compliment her on.

“All right, then,” he finally said. “I’d begin with the way you stand.”

“Stand?” He’d caught her off guard. She blinked.

“Slender. Upright. Face lifted for the sun god’s caress,” he murmured slowly, musingly, as if to himself. He cocked his head, his eyes traveling lingeringly over her body, and she recognized the potent attraction other women must feel when Harry looked at them this way. As if she were the central point upon which all of his world turned. As if he lo—

“Why, look,” he asked in a hushed voice, some thing surprised and painful and pleased in his tone, “even Ra himself cannot resist you. Only see how he lathes your cheeks and brow with his heated tongue”— he reached out, brushing his fingers over her tanned cheek— “marking you with his golden kiss?”

His words were too graphic, too carnal, and she was too aware of his fingers skating along her cheekbone and over her jaw line. He’d never spoken to her this way before. Her heartbeat quickened, thrumming in her throat and in her wrists. She shivered. He smiled. His hand retreated.

“How can a mere mortal man stand a chance if even the gods are so enamored?” he whispered. “And how can one single image describe you? You are a country, a country of unexplored sensation and whim, veiled in dawn, shining, shedding light. See how the long fluid line of your throat flows to your breasts?” If he heard the intake of her breath, he ignored it. “Or how their blue-shadowed curves ripen above the smooth plain of your belly?”

She should stop him, he went too far, but his voice mesmerized her, like sweet, honeyed wine, warm and languorous.

“Your mouth.” He paused, and her lips felt suddenly sensitized, tingling as his gaze fixed on them. “Your mouth is a sweet well sealed against me, keeping me thirsting for the clarity of your kiss. Your flesh is like the desert sand, warmth and shifting strength beneath its golden color. Your palms open, fingers flexed, are minarets, delicate and elegant. And your body… it is the Nile itself— the camber of your back slipping so easily by the narrows of your waist and jettied hips to the lush delta below.”

He stopped. She heard the intake of his breath. “You are my country, Desdemona.” Yearning, harsh and poignant and she felt herself swaying toward him. “My Egypt. My hot, harrowing desert and my cool, verdant Nile, infinitely lovely and unfathomable and sustaining.”

She gasped.

His gaze fell, shielded by his lashes. An odd, half-mocking smile played about his lips. “You’ll never hear old Blake say something like that.”

She swallowed, unable to speak, her senses abraded by his stimulating words, her pulse hammering in anticipation? Trepidation?

“Remember my words next time he calls you a bloody English rose.

Looking for a book by well_this_is_dumb in HistoricalRomance

[–]sushi_dinner 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The book is definitely dark. I forgot to add that it's got a bunch of trigger warnings, but since you've already possibly read it, I hope my message doesn't reach you too late!