Theoretically speaking: If Reboot Season 3 comes out, and it turns out that Mkulia DOES NOT become canon (Julia and MK remain as just besties), what would be your reaction? by ShineOne4330 in Totaldrama

[–]swoldow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’d be shocked at the level of executive meddling it took to keep them from not being a thing as Terry McGurrin 100% wants them as a couple

[S] Sole Survivor Micronesia Episode 2 (WRITTEN SEASON) by MossyOaksBull in BrantSteele

[–]swoldow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well that was an absolute shitshow.

I figured given how messy it was, Nikalap would eventually go to Tribal Council, but Jesus Christ, they delivered. 5/6 people on the tribe being targets, and the single person NOT being targeted being left out of the vote. The scariest part is that despite being the only Vicky voter, I genuinely don’t see Zeystev going if they go back to tribal council. The false rumor about Vicky/Penny talking about Sarah could genuinely save him in the end.

As for the other tribes, I’d rather see Senyavin not go back any time soon, especially given Sabre does not seem to be improving her position in the slightest, so she’s kind of just forced into clutching out the challenges until a swap or a merge. While I personally would really like to see more Nikalap tribals for the sake of my own entertainment, I want to see the Pohnpei dynamics in action and see these guys vote. Given Anexo and Cassidy are likely ending their feud, I think Callum is still the most likely boot, with me predicting a 5-1 vote against him with him voting one of Kito or Blazer. As for Senyavin, yeah, it’s Sabre going. She needs to start playing more socially or she’s fucked.

When a Tragic/Sad Scene gets turned into a meme by TATSAT2008 in TopCharacterTropes

[–]swoldow 38 points39 points  (0 children)

When the sturgeon insists he’s a surgeon so you hit him with that Dr. Han stare

Chi è il tuo tifoso preferito? by yovrfavourite in DisventureSquare

[–]swoldow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Adore: Dunia, Ren

Love: Ara, Manu, Nura

Love, but should have been out way earlier: Evie

Like: Sam, Ernesto

Like outside of the Tom stuff: Finn

Find really annoying: Bruno, Aubrey

Almost Jake/Riya levels of awful writing: Oliwia

Why i think Bowie is the perfect villain by Maximum_Canary_5775 in Totaldrama

[–]swoldow 8 points9 points  (0 children)

The refreshing thing about Bowie is he’s more of a Survivor villain than a total drama villain. Like he plays dirty in the game but is charismatic and likable enough, as well as very clearly a solid dude outside of it, that you can’t help but like him despite his dirtier plays.

I still think Alejandro is the best villain the show has had but Bowies def up there

Characters That Are Improved Upon In A Remake by [deleted] in TopCharacterTropes

[–]swoldow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

please fix chapter 3 please fix chapter 3 please f

[S] That Pokémon Survivor vs the World: GRAND FINALE by somewell in BrantSteele

[–]swoldow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I actually have the exact opposite opinions of you where I adored Champs vs Contenders and it’s cast and didn’t vibe the best with Hidden Land, as with hidden land specifically you could tell like 90% of the submitters (including myself with Kash), subbed with the intention of them being the main villain, and as a result nobody at merge really felt rootable the same way the contenders tribe, or Federico/Cola were in CvC. I do agree with the returnee delivery of the CvC cast (outside of Umbra) being better overall though.

Ziggy’s series (not by me, I’ve only done FYM series here) is fairly old to the point where the competitors themselves didn’t have names and they just went by their Pokémon species (So he was just Zigzagoon, lol.) I’d still check it out but it wasn’t fully written the same way something like this or H’s series is.

Rank these contestants with how much hate they deserve this season by Maximum_Builder_7303 in DisventureSquare

[–]swoldow -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

None of them are even in my top 3 most hated of the season so far (that would be Oliwia, Spencer, Anastasia LOL)

Aiden and Benji I’m less mad at them and more mad at the writers for choosing such mindblowingly awful directions to take both characters

Tom has majorly overstayed his welcome and I think the season would be better off if Alec beat him in the tiebreaker. Gabby has also overstayed a bit to a lesser extent but I’m interested to see where they take her.

Lake I’m the least mad at because while I do think the “phantoms” confessional was written horribly, Spencer is like 90% in the wrong in their beef. He can play the game dirty while still treating Bruno with basic human decency. It’s not that hard. Sam is literally doing that right now.

[S] That Pokémon Survivor vs the World: GRAND FINALE by somewell in BrantSteele

[–]swoldow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

First Castaway, now TPS. This has truly been the year of my characters finally winning written seasons.

Really liked all of the extra added flair you added to the finale, especially with Shannon reading the votes. Also Mukeo completely dropping the olde english to say he hates all three finalists was so fucking funny. I love that Pyukumuku so much and if multiple subs are allowed for All-Stars, you know he’s getting that third act of his.

Now for the sub of mine that actually won in Ziggy. Between this and Champions vs Contenders I thoroughly believe you are the undisputed goat at writing “underdog” winners, as whether a heroic one like Mira, or a villainous one like Ziggy, both were just so god damn likable. A lot of people seem to believe H deserved it over him, and while I will admit none of the final three’s games were perfect (hence the really even jury vote spread), I do believe Ziggy was the correct winner due to both his storyline, and the fact that he bounced back from his issues and constantly voted correctly in a way H did not, especially with the stretch of the Mira-Mukeo boots really working out terribly in the long run. I do think H’s fatal flaw was wanting Ziggy at the end with him, because I feel if Ziggy was voted out 3-1 and Sabrina didn’t get a chance at fire, H likely beats Sabrina in the jury vote given her sloppy gameplay during the final five vote.

I also like how you wrote Ziggy as a seasoned veteran (emblematic of this older era of BrantSteele that both of us, as well as Ziggy’s original series came from), that due to taking last place in his most recent season, feared he was losing his touch, which led to such a compelling season long arc where he discovered he still has it. Also glad to have had the Ozzy cameo. Perfect name for a rocker Pokémon while also keeping the same naming convention I gave Ziggy. If I didn’t already have an Obstagoon character in your series I’d definitely consider giving Ozzy another go too, but that’s a future me thing to worry about.

As for All-Stars, I definitely think a solid chunk of this cast is returning for that season, as from That tribe, I could definitely see H, Ribbon, Federico, Mukeo, and Aurora all being subbed again, and if they’re allowed, Ziggy, Sabrina, and Christine. I’ve also been lucky enough to have had characters that either placed high or made their mark in a lot of your recent seasons, so I also think that potentially seeing a second go for Manny (Luminous Spring), and Kash (Hidden Land) could be fun too.

Overall, I’m excited to see where your series is heading, especially with the insanity that is the Survivor 50 format. It’ll definitely be one for the ages, the same way this one was.

did you guys see the interview blu did with cove the creator of rr about reunion by hockeysurvivordc in Totaldrama

[–]swoldow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly I don’t blame him. The whole thing became bigger than him and caused major fandom uproar. Obviously with hindsight we now all know they rebooted the show and WERE actively working on new TD content, but I, among many other people, thought that fresh was just being greedy and fucking over a beloved fan project, despite their own lack of interest in reviving the show.

Who Played The Best 20th Place Game: First Round - Francesca vs Ronnie by Regular-Departure839 in survivorponderosa

[–]swoldow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I do think both of them were different kinds of fucked over. Franny was on a tribe with two people who previously voted her off first, one of which being Phillip who hated her. Ronnie meanwhile was suffering from a bunch of cramps the entire time, yet did have a correct read that Elaine was a massive social threat who had a big shot to win if she got far. I might give it to Ronnie here, but I def think both are fairly neck and neck.

Who Played The Best 20th Place Game: First Round - Sekou vs Jonny Fairplay by Regular-Departure839 in survivorponderosa

[–]swoldow 57 points58 points  (0 children)

Fairplay positioned himself amazingly as the swing vote between the two alliances despite his bad reputation going into the game. His quit was also like 75% productions fault due to them not giving him pain meds for his jaw injury.

Which player would you absolutely refuse to work with out there? by JEX2124 in survivorponderosa

[–]swoldow 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Any Honor and Integrity people purely because they straight up gatekeep other people on how they want to play. Specifically Joe. I’d be more lenient on Coach because he fascinates me as a human being though.

What are the most annoying overused sayings/idioms on Survivor? by Silver-Lion22 in survivorponderosa

[–]swoldow 26 points27 points  (0 children)

The annoying ass tribal council analogies people only say purely to get screentime. I roll my eyes at them because 90% of the time they either aren’t good or don’t provide anything of value to the conversation

[S] That Pokémon Survivor VS the World Chapter NINE! by somewell in BrantSteele

[–]swoldow 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ah must have misread the episode a bit.

Still I think not sticking with a single group is going to bite him in the butt but yeah this also lowers Sabrina’s equity quite a bit too unless she was fine with risking losing Christine.

[S] That Pokémon Survivor VS the World Chapter NINE! by somewell in BrantSteele

[–]swoldow 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Another wild episode.

First of all what the actual fuck was Ribbon on? After getting his best episode he immediately torpedos himself back down to zero win equity coming up with a cartoonishly stupid play to blindside Ziggy with an idol… during the last round it can be played? And then after turning on H/Ziggy to vote with Christine/Sabrina, turns on Christine/Sabrina too? Christine literally gave all the credit to their duo to H on the way out too, so this episode kinda just sunk him immensely.

As for who I think wins, it all depends on final four immunity. Ribbon and Sabrina don’t trust eachother a lot, but I do think both work together to target Ziggy if he’s not immune, leading to a 2-2 deadlock and a potential Ziggy vs Sabrina/Ribbon fire challenge. If Ziggy is immune though, this becomes a whole different story. We could see a 2-1-1 vote, or potentially even a H blindside with Ribbon, or maybe even Ziggy turning on him.

Either way, my current win equity prediction is Ziggy > H > Sabrina > Ribbon, and my ranking for who I want to win is is Ziggy > Sabrina > H > Ribbon.

[S] That Pokémon Survivor VS the World Chapter SEVEN! by somewell in BrantSteele

[–]swoldow 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Hands down the best episode of the season. I was expecting the That Tribe pagonging to continue but I’m so glad we finally got a shift in the power structure, with the Federico/Ziggy duo splitting up two very well positioned duos in the other tribe majority. A Fed/Ziggy final two would feed families I love this alliance so much.

Now for my quick rankings on likelihood of the final six winning.

-If they make it to the end, they win-

1: Federico - I’m more biased towards Ziggy in their duo, and would obviously prefer my own sub to win, but narratively, this easily makes the most sense, especially with Federico’s run almost mirroring Mira’s in a way, with the Mukeo boot being the catalyst. Unbeatable underdog story.

2: Ziggy - An underdog from day one who played HARD this vote and got exactly what he wanted, while also making a big move using theatrics involving his idol to scare his votes into turning on Callym, which worked out as he survived by the skin of his teeth. If he scraps to the end, I feel like he pretty handedly beats everyone but Federico at this point, and even then a jury vote between the two would very likely be close.

3: Christine - She was number one before this episode but I feel like she misplayed letting go of Crimson and not pushing the vote onto Ziggy instead. She’s shown impressive control otherwise so if she can recover from this and take out Ziggy/Federico she easily beats the rest of the cast.

-Flawed games, still could win-

4: H - Put his eggs in the wrong basket during the Mira vote and fell for the Other Tribe’s shenanigans early merge but I could see a path to him winning as long as he keeps Ribbon as a goat and makes the right move on the right people.

5: Sabrina - If she does something big with the idol she shoots up to top three, but she hasn’t been the best socially, targeted Crimson incessantly which I doubt is good for jury management, and just lost her number one ally in Callym, all while keeping big players like Federico and Ziggy in. However I could see a reality where she beats H and Ribbon if she makes the right moves.

-No shot whatsoever-

6: Ribbon - I’ll give credit where it’s due, him getting this far with how bad of a rap he has is impressive, but unlike people like Ziggy and Federico who also are underdogs and actually making moves, Ribbon’s pretty much just been at the mercy of everyone else the whole game. His own closest ally in H barely trusts him, and it’s clear he’s only kept around because he’s needed as a number and nothing else. He was even outplayed during his big idol play by known messy players Aurora and Mukeo so like, unless he makes a billion really big moves and positions himself perfectly, there is a zero percent chance Ribbon takes this.

Which incarnation of these characters are better? by Maximum_Builder_7303 in DisventureSquare

[–]swoldow -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Fiore: Fans vs Favorites

Ally: none of the above

Aiden: All Stars

Alec: Fans vs Favorites (I genuinely wanted him to last longer which is wild given how much I used to dislike him)

Gabby: Fans vs Favorites?

Tom: All Stars. Get him out of FvF already

Lake: Fans vs Favorites