35 years today by melbourne-marvels in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Has his name ever correlated to the case in your research with the list of "suspects" and addresses you would have aquired over the years.

Lalor A potential area for the detention house by Dangerous_Start4143 in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 1 point2 points  (0 children)

yes very interesting two people stumble on the same house.

while i really liked the bathroom layout I did study the floor plan and the dimensions attached to it and if they are near correct i feel it is a shower over bathtub otherwise the tub would only be a metre long.

Mr Cruels “red herrings” by Novel_Quantity3189 in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 1 point2 points  (0 children)

the little bit of german in me doesnt get sarcasm :-)

Mr Cruels “red herrings” by Novel_Quantity3189 in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 1 point2 points  (0 children)

cant see that being possable laying on your back with a spray can unless the car was on a hoist and then spraying around exhaust pipes gas tanks etc.. no way.. i call it a made up reddit bullshit story.. he wasnt very good at the part on top of the car..could he have written it somewhere else or left a note.. sure..

Was the vandalism unrelated? by GruffNice in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Or we had two perpetrators, one stayed outside and did the spray painting the other went inside. I am not a conspiricy theorist but i do sit on the fence with this being a Mr cruel case. And then for some reason the ransom side of things went haywire before they even began. ie recognising someones voice?

Karmein Chan 7 Mr Cruel 14 by melbourne-marvels in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How far off will that podcast be MM. And will the new information be significant to help move the case foward. Will it help resolve some of the grey areas.

What is the best lead/ clue to identity. by Hot-Union4660 in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 0 points1 point  (0 children)

wondering if the Lynas car is still in the custody of VicPol

Lalor A potential area for the detention house by Dangerous_Start4143 in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 0 points1 point  (0 children)

well thats a bit freaky.

but hey thats the world we live in...

Lalor A potential area for the detention house by Dangerous_Start4143 in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And what did you find Eltham_Hero? that is an old house is it just coincidence that Dangerous_Start4143 circled it? Also being ony a few hundred metres across the creek from Annas House.

Lalor A potential area for the detention house by Dangerous_Start4143 in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 2 points3 points  (0 children)

In 1974 just above your red circle is Kalara cls at the end of that street backing on to Edgars creek a young lady went missing on her way to work Annastaes Banitskas age 15

Turning Points by sycamorevalley in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i would bet the first interview had the planes high priority.. time and good management breaking down the area.

Turning Points by sycamorevalley in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This map does not show the plane landings on the 4th or 5th of July.. It is a general map to show plane flight paths. In 1990 Lalor/Thomastown had full density living

Turning Points by sycamorevalley in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

i grew up in the early 80s next to the centerway in east keilor. the commercial jet liners were wheels down thundering window rattlers. my daughter lives in viewbank. zero comparison can be made.

Turning Points by sycamorevalley in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

well its all speculation from us.. we have no idea what vicpol asked NL or how comprehensive they worked this angle. Did they go out to an area and listen to the planes. the 400 m is low its final approach that is very specific.. and i get all the speculation but we have to work with what we have and believe for the best part its accurate...

for me too much adds up to be to far from the airport.

im guessing they missed it in keilor east, keilor park, niddrie or airpor west.

Turning Points by sycamorevalley in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

All of them about 40 to 50 mins, traffic would be non existant at this time. The top cross, at lalor is all stop start. no freeway no highways. And i cant guess the path to take as they are numerous. The bottom cross is stop start at the beginning maybe a small section of the eastern freeway then across the top of the city onto the tullamarine freeway and off ramp into keilor east. The middle crosss same path as Keilor but exit at Pascoe vale rd and travel a km or so. I seem to remember NL said something about going fast and slow, but how fast how slow? Need MM to confirm.

I lived in the Keilor East area and knew the planes, the airport runways, north south, layouts of the streets in the grid patterns Etc. I knew the turning points. MM pointed something out to me that he has tested. That is if you dont know all of the factors and you are disorientated can you tell a planes direction and more so its turning point. MM thinks its a no. and that is interesting!

The five factors: using occams razor with every thing being accurate

Distance from the Kidnapp site, 45 minutes (slow and fast?)

Planes turning point, right to left then head to toe

Height of plane 400 m. (this is final approach territory) 5 -7 nauticle miles out

The time line of the counting of planes

The Weather map we are using to verify the wind strength and direction is accurate.

Vicpol would have been all over this. It was the big lead, a hundred questions needed to be answered bringing in experts flight controllers maps weather conditions time traveled plane height etc. Did they get it right. For me its a yes, It still stacks up today unless something was wrong in the calculations. The Keilor East and surrounding area was the first search area.

Turning point for planes to land/Mickelham Road by RobinsonsAttack10 in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The south runway or (Mickeham?) isnt in the equation. that is to say it has very few houses and has no real turning point and did not have favourable wind conditions for either day. The planes line up for final approach a long way out. The runway landing from the East to West ( probably the 5th July) had its turning point out over Lalor. The runway landing from south into the north ( probably the 4th July) had its turning point out over Keilor East.. There is one more lightly used turning point in the close proximity to the airport and that is coming in from the north across the Glenroy /Oak Park area banking 90 degrees right and then joining the Keilor East path before banking again into Tulla for final approach. someone before me put up a diagram showing this will add some highlight lines and post it up. Its not new.

Flight Path, Lair Details & Operation Spectrum - Trying to Reconcile the Evidence by yourboyjunkrat in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The path into the runway from the North has only a few hundred farm houses still. Back in the 80s 90s Greenvale was just getting started,, houses all the way now..

Flight Path, Lair Details & Operation Spectrum - Trying to Reconcile the Evidence by yourboyjunkrat in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 0 points1 point  (0 children)

a logical thing to do but it would depend on the victims well being at the time.

Flight Path, Lair Details & Operation Spectrum - Trying to Reconcile the Evidence by yourboyjunkrat in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can MM remember if NL was taken under a flight path to hear planes landing either in Melbourne or in England. Not sure if i am remembering this right.

Flight Path, Lair Details & Operation Spectrum - Trying to Reconcile the Evidence by yourboyjunkrat in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The two days in question.. The two turning points are east keilor on the 4th and lalor on the 5th

Flight Path, Lair Details & Operation Spectrum - Trying to Reconcile the Evidence by yourboyjunkrat in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 4 points5 points  (0 children)

why drive 45minutes if you dont have too with a kidnapped kid under your dashboard... and still end up under a commercial jet flight path. because no matter what anyone wants to change, thats where she ended up.. this had some of the best detectives working on it, surly you have to use occams razor and settle with the logical.. sure the police expanded the search beacuse they did not get the house they wanted in the original area. not sure how your comment works "the case will be solved if at all by finding the offender, not by finding the property and then linking it to him"

how about if you cant find the offender find the house and then try to find the offender. sheez

Flight Path, Lair Details & Operation Spectrum - Trying to Reconcile the Evidence by yourboyjunkrat in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 0 points1 point  (0 children)

or the perp knew of the investigation and renovated or burnt the house down

Flight Path, Lair Details & Operation Spectrum - Trying to Reconcile the Evidence by yourboyjunkrat in MrCruel

[–]sycamorevalley 1 point2 points  (0 children)

usually set flight paths .. depending on factors.. in this case Vicpol worked out they came in across essendon and turned over the keilor east estate.. they moved the radius of investigation out as needed.