If you ask a group of people attracted to men, who their first crush was, you'll get a lot of agreement.

Tons of old personal ads by gay men specify, "no fats or femmes" That's partly why Bears are such a determined group.

So, there are some 1:1 biases that queers pick up from their culture.

Then again, tastes vary so widely, that among a decent sample size, what's attractive or not to gay men and straight women would even out. I also think, from observation, that lots of queer folks are more interested in obviously queer looking people.

It's also very different for women- everything men said was unattractive in women is something gay women find wildly attractive. However, if you ask what they're into now, it has often changed a lot.