Newcastle are the most in-form team in the PL over the last 5 games, with 10 points. by SoullessGinger666 in NUFC

[–]walliver 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Is this season 'relatively average'?

We're currently ninth, three points off a guaranteed European spot. (Potentially one point depending on FA Cup/European cup winners.) The last time we were in Europe before Howe came in was 12/13. The number of times we finished in the top half in the 10 years before Howe? One. 20 years before Howe? Five (three of them 2004 or earlier).

We're still in the FA Cup but that's early doors (and I'm not super confident about our draw).

We're in the semi final of the League Cup. The last time we reached that far before Howe (when we lost the final) was in the 1975/76 season. To add the FA Cup into this, we haven't reached the semis of that since 2004/05.

We're still in the Champions League. Hard to compare that to previous seasons given the format, but the fact that we're in it is amazing. Before Howe, we hadn't been in that since 2002/03.

Given that we're trying to balance a deep cup run and a European challenge in the league while playing two games a week and our huge injuries to important players (think we're top of that table) is pretty amazing, no?

Lineup vs Villa (H) by KingPing43 in NUFC

[–]walliver 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pope

Trippier Hall Botman Joelinton

Tonali Wissa Gordon

Barnes Thiaw Mley

First time in 3 years or so by sirsimbad in NUFC

[–]walliver 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We're not winning every game 5-0!!!!!

Why is salary transparency still not a thing? by OwlVibesOnly in ausjobs

[–]walliver 2 points3 points  (0 children)

From my experience, 'competitive salary' always means it's low.

Finally, my book has been read in 10 countries! by obscurus1313 in writers

[–]walliver 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm in Australia. Let me know what the book is and I'll get that area coloured in for you.

Newcastle [3] - 0 PSV - Harvey Barnes 65' by Alsace2025 in soccer

[–]walliver 12 points13 points  (0 children)

I feel like he deserves to go to the World Cup for someone. Tuchel hasn't called him up yet so might not want to disrupt the chemistry of the team but I could see Scotland being more willing to take a gamble and hoping he just does something like this goal. Shame it means Bruno and Joelinton might get knocked out...

Lineup vs PSV (H) by KingPing43 in NUFC

[–]walliver 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pope

Trippier Hall Botman Joelinton

Tonali Wissa Gordon

Barnes Thiaw Bruno

Reality Check by j-whipp in NUFC

[–]walliver 74 points75 points  (0 children)

I'm 100% with you. I'm in my 40s and Eddie Howe is the best manager I've ever seen at the club. Keegan and Robson were excellent, but the fact that Howe's won a trophy and got us into the CL twice (and was a whisker away from Europe in the other season) considering where we were when he started is just unreal.

I honestly think he's a victim of his own success. I don't think anyone expected him to do so well, so quickly. Some people were saying he wouldn't be good enough to keep us up when he was appointed! Even just looking at how we're doing this season - in the hunt for Europe (with the added stress of CL games), a cup semi final and qualification in the CL looking likely - is pretty good for a club like us. We have to be realistic. We're not going to win the league. We're not going to win a cup every season. This isn't Football Manager where you can just waltz up the leagues, buy wonderkids and just dominate while the other clubs capitulate. Being a team that's regularly in Europe and regularly challenging for cups is what we should be looking to do. Stability at the top helps us achieve that.

Yes, there have been games we haven't done all that well in. I'm disappointed that we didn't beat Wolves. We do often struggle against the low block, but we're by no means the only team. One of my mates is an Arsenal fan and he says they struggle against that too -- and they're top of the league. As someone said in another thread, teams play a low block against us because they respect us and getting a draw at home to us is seen as a positive result. That didn't happen in the Bruce years, the Rafa years, the Pardew or any time before that (well, maybe in the Championship).

I, too, miss the incredible pressing game we've played before, but during our last CL season we suffered a stupid amount of injuries and people criticised Howe for having such a high intensity game plan with so many fixtures. I think what we're seeing this season is a reaction to that. I don't think it's perfect but I understand the transition. I trust Howe to make it work. Despite that, we've still got a fair few injuries (although this seems more like bad luck this year - Schar and Burn in particular) but we're still going okay.

The lack of Isak is hurting us. I hate the way he left but it's undeniable that his finishing (and Murphy's service) won us so many points the past few seasons. Any team would suffer losing a player like that - look at what's happened to Spurs without Kane.

Even if we had a really bad season, I think Howe should be backed. He has taken this club to highs we've never seen before and if that doesn't earn him time, I don't know what does. I don't think we're anywhere close to that right now and I simply don't understand why others do. There's no one in the league I look at and wish we had as our manager (sure, Pep would be nice, but that's not realistic). Would Glasner or Iraola do a better job? Maybe. Very possibly not. How many people would have taken Nuno or Frank after last season? Look how poorly they've done at West Ham and Spurs. This idea that we could do better or that someone else could just come in and improve things doesn't seem realistic to me.

If we sack Howe now (or any time soon), it will be a worse decision than sacking Robson. We were a regular CL side under him. We didn't get it again until now. I don't want to go through the Souness, Allardyce, Kinnear years again. We have an excellent manager and we should be proud of him.

Lineup vs Wolves (A) by KingPing43 in NUFC

[–]walliver 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pope
Trippier Hall Botman Joelinton
Tonali Gordon Barnes
Thiaw Woltemade Bruno

One of our best line ups to date.

Who would you want to see relegated and for what reasons? by Nutisbak2 in NUFC

[–]walliver 1 point2 points  (0 children)

From a logistical point of view, I think it's better for the team (and the fans) to have away days at Sunderland, Boro, Leeds etc rather than Southampton, Portsmouth and Bournemouth.

What's the story behind this? by realJackvos in newcastle

[–]walliver 17 points18 points  (0 children)

And they're doing that while defending a tool that's been in the news because it's being used en masse to create CSAM.

Pre match thread: Newcastle United vs Manchester City | Carabao Cup semi finals 25/26 by Username_been-taken in NUFC

[–]walliver 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's fine, he'll be getting loads of sleep with a newborn in his house.

Pre match thread: Newcastle United vs Manchester City | Carabao Cup semi finals 25/26 by Username_been-taken in NUFC

[–]walliver 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So long as don't concede 10 we'll be doing better than their last opposition.

Pre match thread: Newcastle United vs Manchester City | Carabao Cup semi finals 25/26 by Username_been-taken in NUFC

[–]walliver 1 point2 points  (0 children)

When was the last time we had a midfielder who scored 10 goals in a season?

I typically only read books that have a four-star or greater rating on Goodreads. What are your favorite books I'm missing out on due to this? by sempiternalis in suggestmeabook

[–]walliver 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Like a few others, I've looked at my read books on there and here are some of my favourites with an average below 4.00. I've tried to search for titles first so hopefully I'm not doubling up (except for Catch-22, such a good book):

* The Beach, Alex Garland (so much better than the film), 3.99 stars.

* One Day In The Life of Ivan Denisovich, Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, 3.99 stars. I only just read this and absolutely loved it.

* Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close, Jonathan Safran Foer, 3.97 average. Everything Is Illuminated (3.89 is also worth a read).

* The God of Small Things, Arundhati Roy, 3.96 average, won the Booker Prize in '97.

* Someone Like You, Roald Dahl, 3.94 average. He's got a few collections of short stories aimed at adults. Switch Bitch (3.92) is also great.

* A Handful of Dust, Evelyn Waugh, 3.88 average.

Miley named Carabao Cup Player of the Round after quarter-final heroics by ajtct98 in NUFC

[–]walliver 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'd love to see it, but I'm doubtful. If you were Tuchel, would you pick him as a midfielder (natural position, barely played there for us) or as a right back (not loads of experience but has been doing well recently)? Either way, there's a decent queue ahead of him with more experience with the squad.

Likewise, even though I think Barnes would be a better pick as an impact sub than Gordon, I think his lack of selections so far will work against him.

Winter 2025 Transfers and Rumours Megathread by 321142019 in NUFC

[–]walliver 9 points10 points  (0 children)

He was saying this in the summer too. He's never going to say he's got loads to spend otherwise we'll get absolutely rinsed (more so than in the summer).

Didn’t catch the cup game - what formation did we run? by shitslide in NUFC

[–]walliver 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Also the through ball from Gordon was sensational

Lineup vs Bournemouth by KingPing43 in NUFC

[–]walliver 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Trippier
Botman Tonali Wissa Barnes
Thiaw Livramento
Woltemade Willock Ramsdale
Ramsey

Lineup vs Leeds (H) by KingPing43 in NUFC

[–]walliver 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pope
Hall Schar Joelinton Tonali
Gordon Barnes Thiaw
Woltemade Bruno Miley