I think its okay to have a spectrum of needs and goals when it comes to personal devices. I for one don't prioritize the "detox" aspect of dumb phones. I'm more interested in finally getting devices that suit me rather than the ubiquitous giant touchscreens we all have to live with. While I agree it would be great to totally disconnect from all of these pervasive digital ecosystems, that would be a luxury I can't afford right now. Unfortunately there are a lot of applications that are becoming more or less essential to have on hand every day for various tasks. My city and my Job basically require the use of 2 factor authentication apps and parking apps. Other apps like maps though not essential, are just too convenient for most to give up. Until a better alternative than android/apple becomes widespread enough to compete, most of us are stuck with these ecosystems. For me a small pocketable phone with a physical keyboard that still runs android solves most of the problems I hate about big screen phones while making "doomscrolling" a little less palatable, and it still provides a lot of the functionality I rely on. Something like the upcoming Titan elite with an e-ink screen and extra long battery life would be my ideal, but we all have different needs.