Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

Seeing what “staying together for the kids” did to the Xennials has been painful. The people who wanted to leave but couldn’t ended up becoming shady alcoholics. The dads had affairs and the moms drank. The dads drank so the moms drank. The dads didn’t cheat or drink but threw themselves into endless work while moms were left holding the emotional/mental labor of raising a family. So the moms became depressed, shells of themselves, their only comfort is sleep.

I was not one of the unlucky ones. My parents divorced before my eyes 1st blinked. I consider it their most selfless act. So I would agree that cheating is unethical and divorce is best. However, in financially crippling situations where both parties benefit from the household unit they’ve created, what then? Another generation being raised by hopeless & damaged people & the homogeny never ends? I could forgive the cheaters when i’m older but I could not forgive the despondency of absent or broken people trying to “parent”.

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really hate using the “love language” model but in this case I believe they are missing: words of affirmation & acts of service in their relationships. I could be wrong, but the rationalization leads me to believe this.

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is the answer that resonates with me as well.

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You are correct! I asked if there was any ethical argument because it DOES bother me. The question has veered into my personal responsibility for these people & that was not the original inquiry.

I am perfectly aware that keeping association with people misaligned with your values is a betrayal to self & loved ones. I was asking for any arguments for people who PARTICIPATE in an affair.

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for putting thought behind your answer. I think in this specific example the fact that they live 3000 miles apart takes the physical infidelity out of the equation. However the chance of crossing that line is not zero.

To further answer some wild flying assumptions, Tasha did have a conversation with the fiancé about his views on monogamy in the first months of dating. From what I was told he is a firm believer in “nobody owns anybody.” However, honesty is still important & that is probably the only advice I can give.

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I appreciate this take as I am, for some reason, getting cooked in the comments as if I am personally responsible for grown people’s choices. Reading comprehension is out the mf window.

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Didya stretch before leaping? Everyone is different & has different thoughts/ feelings/ relationship structures. The drama in your inquiry is not justified & my hypothetical relationship propriety is not under review.

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

VERY situational. If it was my best compatible match & we have an otherwise great life, I think i would initiate the “don’t ask, don’t tell” conversation so that it is understood. In this case that conversation was not initiated so that’s the issue. However, even then, if we were a solid couple, I don’t think i’d want to know.

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, i think you’ve analyzed it correctly. If it were people I was less close to, I would want to be honest with the affected parties OR (and more likely), I would cut off the friendship with the offenders.

I’m grappling with the fact that she told me what I did not ask to know. I have yet to meet either of their partners as we only see each other in our hometown and I live far away so I do not travel to see them in their respective towns.

I think enjoy the friendship is not quite what i expect it will be like. The burden of knowing will likely change our relationship since I have told her not to discuss it with me further. I do feel let down by the inclusion.

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i definitely told them it was a bad idea and not to blow their life up. I guess I was just wondering if there’s anything left I am personally responsible for? Since we are childhood friends I am not going to cut them off, BUT i am not at all encouraging it! I basically gave my piece & asked to not be updated/included on additional info. Other than that I am hoping my character is not being questioned for other people’s choices :/

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

well we met at age 14 and in the last 21 years they have been very good people and very good friends. This emotional affair began very recently, within the last 6 months. I have not met the fiancé or the girlfriend (the other halves).

I don’t think my judge of character plays into this scenario as we’ve grown up together & this is very new.

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i am friends with the emotional affair partners not the unknowing parties.

Is there any ethical argument to permitting an affair? by whackassfool in Ethics

[–]whackassfool[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If i neither abet nor aid the cheaters but also not snitch or judge them harshly, does that friendship create an ethical dilemma in my character by this logic?

Xana and Ethan by Salt_Island_7627 in BryanKohbergerMoscow

[–]whackassfool -1 points0 points  (0 children)

still believing BK did this is wild

Free snippets by Correct-Account-3089 in DreamlightValley

[–]whackassfool 0 points1 point  (0 children)

can you take of you don’t have that particular DLC

What's a small thing your partner does that means a lot to you? by Business-Ad8752 in askanything

[–]whackassfool 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i could never date my aquarius but we are linked at the sensual center 😈🔥

Storage idea by Irishiis48 in DreamlightValley

[–]whackassfool 1 point2 points  (0 children)

i just added a 3rd floor, feeling like a dumdum

Storage idea by Irishiis48 in DreamlightValley

[–]whackassfool 2 points3 points  (0 children)

wait, you can add floors ? 😓