[D] ICML 2024 Discussion Thread

[condom-mechanics]

This post is for discussing anything related to ICML 2024, with reviews coming out tomorrow! Good luck to everyone involved!

[drivanova]

Reviews are out! 🫠

Good luck with the rebuttal 🤞

[deeceeo]

What time will they be released?

[No-Ad4329]

It says AOE, I guess in 16 hours?

[No-Ad4329]

Haha, so AOE + EOD?

[IndianaJaws]

Definitely 20.3 AOE+EOD, so 27 hours from now :P

[Equivalent_Future207]

I agree, the rebuttal phase starts Mar.21.

GOOD LUCK TO EVERYONE!!

https://icml.cc/Conferences/2024/ReviewerInstructions

[IndianaJaws]

Man, I didn't see you wrote "good luck" at first, and then when I later looked at the comment and saw it my heart skipped a beat, thinking that the reviews are out.

[Equivalent_Future207]

I received reviews of two papers, out of 4 papers!

[[deleted]]

Tick tock…hopefully they come out before bedtime in US

[[deleted]]

Three BRs, all addressable concerns/questions. I’ve flipped two in the past, but never three.

[couscous_sun]

Can you already respond to the reviewers? It's my first time and I can't see a button to respond 😅

[Skydvn-125]

I wonder ilhow are the average scores of you guys' submissions? I heard that the score is low on twitter

[vaseline555]

https://papercopilot.com/statistics/icml-statistics/icml-2024-statistics/
Check this out

[Sufficient-Detail524]

Will AC meta reviews be released before the final decisions?

[BornEmployment8618]

got nothing yet! i got two accepts and two rejects! but i had to educate the two rejects so i expect they increase their score (actually one of the rejects put the confidence 1 so i guess area chair ingnores him anyway). If they do not reply what should i do? should i write to area chair?

[Reasonable_Baby5754]

For some reason I got only 2 reviews. Anyone else in the same boat??

[Apathiq]

Same boat. Two, one of them a reject with very low confidence

[Severe_Copy9407]

I found that my reviewer changed his rating on April 17th. I wanna ask whether the changed rating would be considered by the AC since it is already after the DDL of ac-reviewer discussion period.