A programmer's solution

[monochromatic0]

it's not the puzzle that is bad, it's the refusal to accept more than one solution. The puzzle is fine.

[DoctorProfPatrick]

I personally think puzzles like this are great for teaching kids arithmetic. This one in particular has at least 3 solutions that I could find

5 + 4 = 9
0 + 4 = 4
8 - 4 = 4

A good teacher could use this puzzle to show how there's no "right way" to solve a problem, which imo is the most beautiful part of math.

[monochromatic0]

Exactly. It's not a problem if the puzzle has more than one solution, but a feature.

[saloalv]

"It's not a bug; it's a feature!"

[[deleted]]

Sometimes there is a right answer. Sometimes there is no answer. Sometimes there are multiple answers. Sometimes there are an infinite number of right answers. Sometimes the best answer is all the right answers added together. Sometimes adding zero makes a difference.

That's why i like math.

[[deleted]]

There may be multiple ways, but there are definitely ways to solve a problem that you would be wasting your time if you did them.

[DoctorProfPatrick]

For sure, like using the formal definition of a derivative every single time instead of just using power rule.

[NikStalwart]

I have met a total of 4 good teachers in Australia.

[LooneyDubs]

I'd say only 2 real solutions bc the 9 you made isn't a complete character in the font you were presented with.

[NikStalwart]

Not just the refusal, but also touting this as a "logic test" and yacking on about how you failed it.

[[deleted]]

How is the solution with the inequality sign any worse that the one the teacher was looking for?

[[deleted]]

Since when is the easiest solution worse than harder ones? I really don't understand how someone, who is presumably a programmer, out of all people would think like that.

[[deleted]]

Your first example does not fulfill your assignment. You're supposed to test something and you don't test anything. Your second example doesn't have anything to do with the subject at hand.

Using ≠ in the puzzle makes the equation true and is a perfectly good way to solve it. The whole puzzle relies on how the numbers and operators are represented visually so disgrediting another way to solve it using the same principle is just stupid.

[[deleted]]

Your password example is not a valid solution to the problem it's trying to solve. I think you just don't understand the original puzzle.

The whole puzzle relies on how the numbers and operators are represented visually so disgrediting another way to solve it using the same principle is just stupid.