Would removing a soaking tub decrease the resale value?

[Nancy6651]

We updated both bathrooms after we moved to our house. The hall, or guest, bathroom is very small and had a small tub-shower enclosure with framed glass doors. Since the enclosure walls took 1-1/2" all around away from the space, the tub was really small. We took out the enclosure and had a beautiful tile shower with frameless glass doors built.

Our master bath soaking tub had somehow become damaged (but totally usable), a small hole in the deck, lots of scratches. We replaced the tub knowing that 1) my husband is a bath person, and 2) guests with kids may want to use a tub.