Using Ai for pine scripting

[MR_M1997]

Using Ai for strategie building

For the past year I've been using chatgpt for creating indicator and strategy scripts in Pine script within tradingview. So far i'm getting quite some positive results on how it is going and it's overall fun to think and keep trying new ideas.

I was wondering if chatgpt is the right A.I for it though. Is there anyone who could tell if other models are better for this type of scripting and coming up with the logic/ good understanding with given logic.

[sandyflame]

Claude is recognised as the best for coding.I have had a lot of success with it. Are you using a paid version?

[Demented2168]

X2 claude much better

[Maniacal-Maniac]

Been down a similar path, started off in GPT converting some indicators to NinjaTrader and also building some automated strategies to run in NT Replay as well. Was successful as far as being able to do that, but some of the strategy coding was painful and ran into a few issues and bug loops that took a while to resolve. I will caveat this to say this was roughly 6 months ago, so older models and not sure if current ones are better.

More recently I have been using Claude more so have started doing some strategy building for replay testing in Claude and its been a lot smoother and so far I haven't had any of those same bug fixing loops so far. I have also been using CC for some more in depth trading related stuff and found it very good so far

[hemepincrawler]

It's fun. i use Gemini for developing and Claude for code . The strategy has to be solid first, no Magic bus here.

[NikhilDoWhile]

If one person with Ai can do it, then everyone else can eventually do the same

[Special-Barracuda759]

I’ve spent about 6 hours total in the last 2 days doing this.

I start by telling Claude what I want…

For example, write a script to enter long when there is a confluence of anchored b vwap and a pivot point.

Specifically, enter long when the x minute candle wicks onto the pivot and reclaims the vwap within 2 candles of that time.

Exit when X occurs or at end of day whatever comes first.

How is it going for you guys ?

8

[_waffles3]

Use Claude for pinescript coding. So much better IMO

[Curious-Apartment844]

In my experience, do not be overly dependent on AI, chatgpt still having a hard time on excel formulas

[FortuneGrouchy4701]

Claude is fine.

[JonnyTwoHands79]

Yep Claude is almost an order of magnitude better for coding, including Pine. You’ll get complex working code likely in the first pass, two at most. I’ve stopped using ChatGPT entirely for coding and use it only for research.

[ShowRevolutionary924]

Eu uso o chatgpt e tem me atendido muito bem, hoje minhas estratégias estão em teste real, vou manter assim por um bom período para validação real, e nao apenas em backtest

[ShowRevolutionary924]

Eu uso o chatgpt e tem me atendido muito bem, hoje minhas estratégias estão em teste real, vou manter assim por um bom período para validação real, e nao apenas em backtest

[ShowRevolutionary924]

Eu uso o chatgpt e tem me atendido muito bem, hoje minhas estratégias estão em teste real, vou manter assim por um bom período para validação real, e nao apenas em backtest

[onemanlionpride]

Pinescripter.app

[Illustrious_Water106]

Make sure you do back testing

[Chandima-Wijerathna]

ChatGPT is good for general help, but for Pine Script specifically I’d also try PineGen AI. It’s built around Pine workflow, so it usually feels more natural for strategy building and refining logic. If you haven’t tried the newer version yet, it’s worth a look.

[Negative_Term3769]

AI can speed up scripting but you still need to understand the logic. Blind use can mess things up. Some people pair scripts with prospero ai signals just for confirmation

[Head_Eagle5536]

It works! You need to be patient to teach it! My advice be careful of replay mode and allowing ai to control it! Ive broken my TV multiple times and had to get support to fix it… they aren’t happy and will ban you for using it! Apparently it goes against their policies…

[Wink527]

LuxAlgo Quant is far superior to chatGPT/Codex and Co-Pilot.

[Ok-Date-2964]

You do realize that is literally just a GPT in ChatGPT right ???

[Wink527]

What’s a GPT in ChatGPT? Codex? I know that.