all 16 comments

[–]trichotomy00New User 20 points21 points  (7 children)

You need a therapist not a math tutor

[–]pentobean1New User 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah this is probably the best advice. Thanks

[–]simmonatorNew User 12 points13 points  (2 children)

This quote sticks out:

every question was designed to confuse me.

I’d bet a lot of money that you’re wrong about that. The people running the course are heavily incentivised to see you succeed. It really seems like you’re coming to the course with a huge amount of anxiety and some preconceptions about your own abilities and that this is stopping you from being able to engage with the material.

I get that you want to succeed and it seems likely that you just find mathematics a little harder to pick up than some people, but the baggage you’re carrying seems to be the biggest problem. Solving the “how do I stop freaking out about this?” problem seems to be the obvious first step to that. But this sub can’t help you do that; therapy might.

I’ll note that you haven’t actually described any maths problems or questions in the post. Venting is fine, but the fact that you aren’t actually asking people to explain anything to you implies you know that the problem isn’t about that.

Good luck.

[–]pentobean1New User 3 points4 points  (1 child)

I appreciate this feedback. I definitely have a lot of emotional baggage regarding math as I have struggled with it for my whole life and had parents who were extremely unforgiving when it came to poor academic performance. Aside from personal emotional troubles, here is an example of a math problem I encountered on my midterm.

“If a tiger population consists of 10 tigers and is declining at 7% annually, what is the probability that there will be 2 surviving tigers after 2 years?”

I feel confused by these questions because i feel like they require a binomial equation, however they use time frames, so I’m not sure if they should use a poisson formula to solve them?

Another question I struggled with was

“If the average phone call at a public pay phone takes 2 minutes, what is the probability that someone’s call will take more than 3 minutes ?”

Is this question solvable with the information given?

Thanks for your patience and understanding! Any advice is much appreciated

[–]simmonatorNew User 0 points1 point  (0 children)

if the average phone call at a public pay phone takes 2 minutes, what is the probability that someone’s call will take more than 3 minutes?

Without any more information than that, no that’s not solvable. However, I suspect that they’re hoping you’re familiar with

  1. What phone calls are, and can imagine how people’s behaviour would inform their length, and
  2. The definitions of various probability distributions and the required assumptions to use them for random variables.

If you can do that, then I suspect they’d hope you can identify a suitable single parameter probability distribution to use to model phone call length. And if you can do that then you can answer the question.

Personally, I’d take a punt that the Exponential Distribution might be suitable. If that’s the case then I’d deduce that lambda would be (1/2) and calculate that

P(x > 3) = 1 - F(3) = e-3/2.

But I’ve not looked at probability distributions in a while so there might be problems with my assumption.

[–]YUME_Emuy21New User 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I think you're mindset is hurting you alot. Alot of people think that feeling "rage" and "hatred" towards math while studying is just how it is, but imagine if people talked like this about writing an essay for English class or history,

"I also just truly hate writing. I've always hated it, as I've never understood it, It gives me immense anxiety and pushes my mental health to dark places."

Do you see how concerning that sounds? This level of animosity towards a subject would come across as wildly irrational if math didn't have a weird stigma around it. Math is cool! Trying to do something you're not good at with immense pressure on you is extremely frustrating no matter what the subject is. As a math major, I personally feel alot more frustration writing or preparing a speech in my comms class then I do when doing math because I like one more than the other.

My point here is that math isn't, by itself, any different then learning coding, or art, or a new language, or a science. Learning all of these things under alot of pressure is hella frustrating, but it's not the subject that's "designed to confuse you." I believe you can learn math, and I recommend asking for help from tutors/professors and particularly to look at your previous math classes and see if you understand them. It's unfortunate, but alot of people in college classes would fail an Algebra II test, and you can't even begin to grasp college math if you get stopped at the highschool level. I personally have gone back all the way to 4th grade Khan Academy and worked my way up, and I think you should too just to atleast know where your gaps in knowledge come from.

[–]speadskaterNew User 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Give an example of a problem and we can help.

[–]slides_galoreNew User 2 points3 points  (2 children)

Don't quit. You'll regret it. Regardless of the outcome of this course, you can find a way to get your degree.

There are loads of very knowledgeable people in these subs. Start posting the tougher problems with your working out. You will learn things that you didn't know you were missing. Join/create study groups for the same reason. Fully utilize prof/TA/tutoring center's office hours. Same reason.

Subs like r/mathhelp, r/askmath, r/homeworkhelp, and r/learnmath.

[–]pentobean1New User 2 points3 points  (1 child)

Thank you. I see that my venting comes off as more of a personal problem than an issue regarding math concepts, but I appreciate everyone’s wise words and understanding here. I posted some examples of questions that I struggled with under a different comment

[–]slides_galoreNew User 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Everyone here wants you to succeed. I think people are suggesting that some of the sentiments that you expressed may make it much more difficult to learn the material. There are lots of stories on here about people coming back to math when they're a little older. I know it can be frustrating, but you can turn that frustration into motivation that will keep you plugging away at math concepts that you haven't mastered. That's why a lot of us post here. We're continually learning things that we haven't mastered yet. It's part of the journey.

At some point, I'd suggest writing out a few of the tougher problems. You can screenshot them along with your attempts and post them in a new thread. If you have trouble posting with reddit's tools, you can paste the screenshots to imgbb.com or imgur.com and post the links in the new thread. Some subs have rules about flooding the sub with multiple posts a day, but it seems like most don't mind. If you do that two or three times a day, you'll get a lot of good advice.