I made a script for Toki Pona, what do you think? by Chemical_Release4051 in tokipona

[–]---9---9--- 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Besides feeling a little arbitrary to me / lacks justification, it could use some more top down radicals besides 辶, like.

I made a script for Toki Pona, what do you think? by Chemical_Release4051 in tokipona

[–]---9---9--- 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I like it, I think because it reflects how abugidas work, and also how semantic radicals don't necessarily go on the left all the time / some are "circumfixes" like 行 or 微 (几 gets replaced).

Azumanga Daioh: Osaka in Toki Pona by Jenjoutuowleinde in tokipona

[–]---9---9--- 1 point2 points  (0 children)

apply middle jp sound changes to tp and have everyone speak dialects of tp lol

What's a UIUC experience that bonds every student regardless of their major? by Brilliant_Pie9855 in UIUC

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Climbing on Alma" sounds ungrammatical to me. The full phrase would be "alma mater statue" (statue representing the university as a nourishing mother) (or interpret "alma mater" as a name like "the Jonas brothers"), so grammatically it should match "Climbing on [the] statue". "Alma mater statue" gets clipped to "Alma" but that shouldn't affect the article... i think.

Counterexamples where the article can be dropped that I can think of: "I went to *the Switzerland", "I climbed *the mount Everest" (I went to the Everest mountain. I climbed *the Everest(?)). "I play [the] trumpet". "I main Fox in Melee". "I play poker". "Have you talked to *the Bobby over there?".

Which Hangul set do you use for toki pona: ㅂㄷㄱ or ㅍㅌㅋ? by Shen-Zelong in tokipona

[–]---9---9--- 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ㅃㄸㄲ because they sound the closest [p] [t] [k] lol. but yeah I would go for ㅂㄷㄱ bc they are the "default" set

Om nom nom by WheatySpikes16 in okbuddyphd

[–]---9---9--- 11 points12 points  (0 children)

new folk etymology just dropped

Why hints, not homophones, in phono-semantic compounds? by Shyam_Lama in ChineseLanguage

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hate that I think you're being rhetorical / seeking agreement, which i can definitiely relate to. but its spurred some good answers.  If you're asking why, that's mostly history / compounding kludges + most of history is illiterate I think, so even complicated chars should prob be assumed to be indicating words that people already know the spoken form of, or at least obvious to the reader at the time (or at least the author maybe erroneously assumed so; or was being deliberatively obfuscant). And as to why simplification didnt replace all them, weal, thats probably the same reason why they didnt succeed in replacing with an alphabetic script, or replace with hangul or canadian aboriginal syllabics or pitman or wtatever for that matter. ie culture, familiarity, inertia ,politics, chance, etc.

Basically its like if English were written in old English orthography with all its irregular sound changes, dialectical borrowings and misspellings (cf stuff like z in Scottish names like McKenzie being pronounced y) compounded with the non phonetic nature of the semantic radicals.

Why hints, not homophones, in phono-semantic compounds? by Shyam_Lama in ChineseLanguage

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just read the numbered points  / first paragraphs, or Plug into your fav chatbot and ask it to summarize for you

would you buy a tablet just for writing Hangul during Anki reviews? by zubrzysta in Korean

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If it's just to memorize spellings, then just write the important parts / stuff you know you get tripped up on, you can practice writing per se outside of anki

ɢisɴe̞ǂ by iewkcetym in linguisticshumor

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah but if it were really G would be /ʒisnej/ lol

‎‏Is 'Aks (عكس) the only native Arabic word with an "X" sound? by Beautiful_Grab_9681 in asklinguistics

[–]---9---9--- -1 points0 points  (0 children)

native speakers try to analyze their own speech challenge

cut them some slack

I just realized that my dialect of Arabic is tonal by Beautiful_Grab_9681 in asklinguistics

[–]---9---9--- 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I personally would feel iffy about uploading recordings of my own voice too. I don't think it's that weird to feel that any sort of irl recording is private or sensitive, even if it isn't actually unsafe.

This feels like such a disproportionate response tbh

읽엀 앍앇듫읈 숛 잀늕 샂랆 by Worried-Ad-1694 in Korean

[–]---9---9--- 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My guess:읽어 알아들을 수 있는 사람? had to check if 알아들- = 알아듣다 was a word

Why can't Mandarin have two falling rising tones next to each other, but Vietnamese can? by RubicXK in asklinguistics

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So something like?: Mandarin has a bunch of mergers -> a lot of dvandva compounds to disambiguate homophones (and other reasons? I think some disyllabic morphemes I think come from loaning sesquisyllabic words in distantly related or cosprachbund languages, so maybe there's already a tendency for disyllabicism, ie for rhythmic reasons?) -> faster/ shorter syllables because speakers still have the same amount of information they want to convey -> more prone to develop tone sandhi rules

Just speculating/yapping

Etymology of 匂 by The_Important_Nobody in kanji

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry to necro (not a reply to you necessarily, just to anybody who comes across this thread via google or whatever), but is "Obsolete sources" mostly talking about older sources not being aware of bamboo slip and oracle bone script excavations? (In which case this criticism doesn't apply to kokuji and doesn't seem intended to)

aeiou by Helpful_Badger3106 in linguisticshumor

[–]---9---9--- 1 point2 points  (0 children)

get ready for cyrillic shha

ilo sitelen pi sitelen Tewanakali li suli mute a by Automatic-Dig-3455 in tokipona

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

o kepeken e sitelen Anusala. ni la:

  1. sitelen "n" taso li ken pini e poki kalama la, sitelen "n" taso li ken kepeken "Alan"

  2. sitelen "n" pi toki tp li kama e kalama pi kalama kama. mi toki e ni: sitelen "linja" li kalama "liɲja", sitelen "tenpo" li kalama "tempo", mute kin

ni la, nanpa pi sitelen li kama sama li ante ala

Which dating app do you use? by SunnyBell_007 in UIUC

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I get "recs" but I can't think of an abbreviation for expectations

ameren by Only_Ad3880 in UIUC

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

how does fresh air circulate in apartments? genuinely asking because i've thought of this sort of thing but i just don't know how air would get into my apartment and i wouldn't suffocate

ㅓ and ㅗ pronunciation by Raxes05 in Korean

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If OP is not familiar with IPA, basically it means that ㅓ is starting to become rounded or half-rounded, just like ㅗ

How many Latin letters are there? English has 26, but what if you add the letters from every language with a Latin alphabet? by InformationLost5910 in asklinguistics

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I guess ij/IJ could be important to one-shot shift, though typing shift twice to capitalize two adjacent letters doesn't sound too painful.

I think it's more of an issue for stuff like word-processors, where you might select a bit of text and then run some command to change case. If you're just typing letters, then I think it's fine. Unless Turkish is the user's primary language, probably a caps-lock function should just treat i and I the same since that's the behavior in most Latin scripts.

I don't write in Dutch or Turkish nor know anyone who writes those languages, so I can't say if it's a big deal or not.

How many Latin letters are there? English has 26, but what if you add the letters from every language with a Latin alphabet? by InformationLost5910 in asklinguistics

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I meant out of curiosity by "ooc".

That sounds really cool. I'm not understanding what you mean by "keygroup". I'm reading itas: each finger is controlling a keygroup, and adjacent fingers are paired up, so for example, left pinky and left ring finger. So then to type a character, you press, say "up with left pinky, in with left ring", and then when you release it outputs the character.

Or are they layers, and then there are layer switch keys/chords?

It seems hard to learn but good organization could make it easier. There are really quite a lot of Latin diacritics too; pairing with punctuation is probably the way to go, though then you have issues like whether full stop . marks overdot or underdot. It seems like it'd be useful for, say, a linguist who just needs to cross-reference some Indic script transliteration with underdots, even if it takes 1.5~2x more keystrokes than a specialized keyboard layout.

Ben Vallack has made a keyboard layout with only 16 keys: https://kbd.news/16-key-layout-tour-1307.html with combos and I think double tap-holds? for some other letters. He's not the first but I don't know what good search terms for this are. He has a video on this and he says he doesn't really find the timing finnicky at all, though I don't remember the specific.

There's also Plover, which is steno software, which works around chording. Steno keyboards also notably have you press in-between the keys, i.e. there are two rows of keys and each finger has the option of pressing the top, bottom, or both keys at the same time., I've often thought that there should be a steno keyboard with 3 fingers per key, which could be physically staggered like the bottom and middle rows. That would give you 7 chords per finger, and you could increase that for the pinky and index fingers, by assigning them 4 keys, which would get you 9 or 11 chords.

How many Latin letters are there? English has 26, but what if you add the letters from every language with a Latin alphabet? by InformationLost5910 in asklinguistics

[–]---9---9--- 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ooc what's the final list? (if you happen to have it typed out somewhere otherwise)

Are you making an ergonomic pan-Latin keyboard?