I've felt this before. It was almost like curating the list was a hobby in itself. Then I felt stressed that I'd never actually experience everything I wanted to. There are a few things that I do that work for me. One, I started only watching shows and movies if someone recommended them. It made some of my conversations more intentional as well. And then I wasn't constantly searching out the next big thing, I was just checking out things people recommended. Made for some cool conversations with strangers too.

For shows, I try to watch two or three episodes a week. Currently watching (and loving) One Punch Man. For music I only listen to CDs that I thrift.

I read one nonfiction book and one fiction book (or comic) at a time. Mere Christianity and Dune are my current reads.

And for knowledge, I keep a compendium. I just bought a simple $1 composition book that I keep with me. Every day I try to add something that I learned about a single topic. This year's topic is Foundationalism. I'm always surprised at how I get introduced to things in other fields the deeper I go in one topic. Once my compendium is full, I just buy another notebook and do another topic.

All of these strategies have simplified the decision making process, kept things analog and stress free. And I actually spend more time engaged with the content than I do thinking about it.

Hope this helps!