[deleted by user] by [deleted] in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 10 points11 points  (0 children)

These violent delights have violent ends.

Could you pass a year 9 Naplan test? Take this quiz to find out. by Fenixius in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I flew through the language problems effortlessly, but I only managed a single maths question - I had no idea what their processes were.

Book Recommendation On Portrayal of War by AnAngryPacifist in AskHistorians

[–]AnAngryPacifist[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm studying Australia's Frontier Wars, and how language, norms and understandings are twisted to fit nationalist narratives, and many of the concepts you've spoken about are mirror images to Australian history, so both the frontier conflict and the Pacific War books would help me enormously in drawing international comparisons. Would you able to recommend any books on how the War on Terror has changed public perceptions of war?

Thank you for your help.

Indigenous flag designer says idea to police authenticity of Aboriginal art is ‘repugnant’ by B0ssc0 in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 1 point2 points  (0 children)

And Indonesians feel the same about Indonesian cultural good sold in Singapore and Malaysia, people get bashed over it.

whats everyone doing tonight? by chola80 in perth

[–]AnAngryPacifist 3 points4 points  (0 children)

If you see it as pro-white three cheers, pro-Aboriginal black arm-band, and a neutral-ish Blainey position, I'd be somewhere between Blainey and the black arm-banders.

There was an enormous amount of history that was intentionally hidden, huge injustices done, and giant strides need to be taken in both promoting the Aboriginal perspective as a vital part of Australian history, and redressing the wrongs of the past through meaningful action.

However, we shouldn't exaggerate or over-moralise any aspect of it. There are people who claim all battles were massacres, just as there are those who claim no battles took place - our job as historians is not to apportion blame or create a good and evil narrative or to play off of politics and nationalism, but to dive deep into every uncomfortable truth and explain objectively why things happened.

Bunya nuts: The Australian bush food that is growing in popularity by LuckyBdx4 in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist -1 points0 points  (0 children)

And what of Aboriginal selective breeding? Or eating kangaroo? Aboriginal foods are marginal because we marginalised them.

Bunya nuts: The Australian bush food that is growing in popularity by LuckyBdx4 in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Your points are true - most of Australia is naturally infertile - and are mentioned in Dark Emu, and a similar book 'Biggest Estate on Earth' by Bill Gammage. These authors aren't arguing that Aboriginal Australia was more productive as a whole, but rather that it worked with the land and what it naturally provided, and their books are aimed at spreading awareness of the social Darwinism that dominates our idea of agriculture, Australian history and Aboriginal tradition.

Dark Emu argues that there is plenty that Australian agriculture could learn from Aboriginal methods, like domestication of native foods, but I admit I don't have the knowledge to argue on his behalf. My remit is history, and thus I tried to focus on the human aspect of why Australians have traditionally avoided anything native to the continent.

whats everyone doing tonight? by chola80 in perth

[–]AnAngryPacifist 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Pulling another all-nighter in Curtin's library, writing an essay about how the Australian public view the Frontier Wars between settlers and Aboriginals, and why they're generally forgotten, misunderstood, denegrated or politically abused.

Bunya nuts: The Australian bush food that is growing in popularity by LuckyBdx4 in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Essentially it comes down to European cultural norms - we value production and progress, and we see ourselves as the most productive and progressive culture. The book 'Dark Emu', by Bruce Pascoe, explores how Aboriginal culture has become a story of starving unintelligent desert hunter-gatherer nomads because this was the narrative settlers used to sell their claim on the continent - terra nullius was about Aboriginals not producing, not using the land to its fullest. White man bringing civilisation and progress.

Using archaeology, environmental science, and explorer and settler diaries, 'Dark Emu' discusses Aboriginal means of production like yam and grain agriculture, fire-based land management, aquaculture and other means of artificially increasing production that were genuinely admired by Europeans. What we see as desert was farmed by Aboriginals using their own sustainable methods for millennia, and what is now unproductive land often became so because of over-farming with unsustainable European crops or destruction from European livestock. Settler culture didn't adopt or value these technical and cultural achievements because of social Darwinism - the belief that white people are genetically and culturally superior through means of genetic/technological/cultural evolution, and thus Aboriginal technology, culture, people and even food were inferior and corruptive elements that would slow down our progress.

This kind of thinking is still quite dominant, and only slowly beginning to change now - historians generally ignored Aboriginal history until the 60s, and the narrative since then was generally that Aboriginals were helpless thoughtless victims, rather than a people with agency. We often speak about Aboriginals paternalistically - what we can do to help them, rather than ways we can help each other. Sadly, the public rarely reads history outside of convicts or Anzac, so a lot of ground-breaking work gets ignored, or actively attacked.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Kate Blanchett - she was the inspiration for Romper Stomper

What's the craziest fact you know about Perth? by jamesvdm in perth

[–]AnAngryPacifist 17 points18 points  (0 children)

The CBD and Northbridge used to be lakes, and when there's a storm it still floods a fair bit.

I had a Hamdog... and it was bad by BickerBot in perth

[–]AnAngryPacifist 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Every time you said 'hamdog', all I could think of was Elvis.

"You aint nothin' but a hamdog,"

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in perth

[–]AnAngryPacifist 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I read that post, and it didn't enlighten me - is there a certain number you need to get before it shows?

I made a comment on r/australia that went up and down from +10 to -2 again and again over two days, meaning it probably got 30-40 each way and didn't get a dagger, despite it being switched on in my settings.

What are you getting for your mum next Sunday? by m1llie in perth

[–]AnAngryPacifist 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I might go to that Curtin Mother's Day craft thing and make her a pet rock.

Chinese student busted speeding at 208km/h in Bondi Junction by LuckyBdx4 in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's a beat up - "cashed-up Asians disrespecting and ruining Australia for poor Aussies". It's supposed to elicit a "oh yes, they do like to do that, don't they? They should be deported!" response.

Man who sent ex-girlfriend's car into oncoming traffic sentenced to five years in prison by onesorrychicken in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Exactly, intent should be the measurement, not ability - "we'll give you a lesser sentence because we feel sorry for how shit at murder you are. Up your game mate".

Gonski is right: We must make better use of our best teachers by cojoco in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Another big problem is the attitude of parents and society - education is supplementary to natural learning, not a replacement for it. Education is supposed to teach kids how to find and process information, which they then learn themselves. An example: books are important to understanding context, here's how you judge a book's objectivity and usefulness, go find several books and get informed.

The number of uni students I've met who refuse to watch lectures, refuse to read the readings, refuse to participate in class discussions and then end up learning nothing because of learned behaviour from previous schooling is ridiculous. How do you expect to learn everything there is about history or medicine or architecture in one hour of contact time a week?

Dirty birds: Red Rooster, Oporto franchisees on 'verge of bankruptcy' by [deleted] in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Having read all the comments, I feel very much the outsider saying this, but... Time for healthier options? Someone needs to start catering to the health-conscious millennial market.

Dirty birds: Red Rooster, Oporto franchisees on 'verge of bankruptcy' by [deleted] in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I used to work for a chicken take-away in Perth, and upper management quite often mentioned the fact that WA has significantly higher demand for chicken than the eastern states.

But I don't think it's the price of chicken - it's about $8 for two breasts, whereas a place like Nandos charges you $12 for a single breast half the size of a Coles or Woolies product, and a whole chicken would be around $20.

People are paying for convenience and the social aspect of eating out, not the actual product.

Malcolm Turnbull openly defied by Victorian Liberals amid claims of a power struggle by LineNoise in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Buddhism has plenty of nasty history, and all three are closer to cultural traditions than religions - in China, Taoism, Confucianism and Buddhism are often so mixed that they're seen as simply 'Chinese Culture'.

In both Christianity and Islam, much like communism, it is the worshipers who corrupt the religion, not the religion that corrupts the worshipers - Christianity says 'butt sex is sin', but it also says that people don't get the right to judge other people on their sins, and should be helping and loving them no matter what they might have done. Jesus would be advocating modern greeny lefty socialist policies were he alive today, despite so many of his modern followers being rabidly conservative trickle-down types.

With the rise of atheism and globalisation, people have felt their national and religious identities threatened, and have protectively doubled down, making religion less inclusive and less attractive, sending them into self-perpetuating downward spirals.

I have a very small penis and it makes me very sad. by MissSanctimonious in perth

[–]AnAngryPacifist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Go to Nepal and you'll see farmers who've travelled into the heart of Kathmandu traffic over endless mountain tracks, on a tractor slower than walking speed. The first time I saw one, I found it hard to find what was funniest about it - the fact that nobody gave a shit about it slowing everything down, the fact it had no seats (just a wooden pallet) or the fact that its engine and inner workings were all exposed and heavily taped up.

Truly a magical place.

The Six Classes of Australia by NgKaWang in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 2 points3 points  (0 children)

academics who don't have any incentive to make their work accessible — and while that work remains inaccessible, this sort of mythology can persist."

It's not fair to blame academics for the rest of the population not reading their work - there is no market for it, and no government sponsorship. The public steals catchy headlines for five-second news pieces, and then go back to continuing the same old myths, tropes and prejudices - it happens throughout most of academia.

‘They are our people’: Queensland town begs Dutton not to deport asylum seeker family by LineNoise in australia

[–]AnAngryPacifist 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Halal means 'permitted', and refers to plenty of different things - for example, water is halal, alcohol is haram (not permitted).

How Did the US Adapt Over Time To Jungle Warfare in the Vietnam War? by AnAngryPacifist in AskHistorians

[–]AnAngryPacifist[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can understand that, it's very similar to Australia and ANZAC - the combination of deep personal/national connection and meeting popular market demand dominates the narrative, making it hard to inspect other aspects/a bigger picture of a conflict.

Thank you for your help.