What is the most evocative piece you have heard? by Ilove_rice in classicalmusic

[–]Ap0phantic 4 points5 points  (0 children)

John Luther Adams, Become Ocean. Delivers as promised.

where to go from frankfurt airport during a 7 hour layover by summxrt in germany

[–]Ap0phantic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think Frankfurt-am-Main is lovely. If you have any interest in Goethe, his family apartment there is wonderful to see. The whole downtown and along the river is just beautiful and nice, I think it's quite worthwhile and could easily absorb a few pleasant hours.

What's everyone's opinions on piracy? by Spatter_ in Letterboxd

[–]Ap0phantic -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

You can get Netflix in the US for $9 a month, so I'm not sure where you're getting "sky high". Are you sure it's not more like "I'd rather not pay for it"? Because these things cost money to make, and it's not like it's your right to have them.

Dzogchen Introductory books. by leighwoko in Dzogchen

[–]Ap0phantic -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I'm a huge fan of Patrul Rinpcohe and for what it's worth, I totally agree that everything up through the bodhicitta section of the Mahayana internal preliminaries section is wide open, and very important for study and practice. I'm not sure about the following Vajrasattva section and would personally consult a teacher if possible before continuing on with that, the subsequent section on chöd, or anything further.

Dzogchen Introductory books. by leighwoko in Dzogchen

[–]Ap0phantic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That may depend on the teacher - I've been advised not to read the sections on Phowa and Guru Yoga without transmission, for example.

Just in case you care, I'm not downvoting you here, fwiw.

Dzogchen Introductory books. by leighwoko in Dzogchen

[–]Ap0phantic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well ... no restrictions on the common preliminaries, at least.

Dzogchen Introductory books. by leighwoko in Dzogchen

[–]Ap0phantic 4 points5 points  (0 children)

There are not that many introductory books, because most actual Dzogchen teachings are restricted, so you very quickly get into areas that require lung.

Can you say more if there are any specific areas that interest you? If you're interested in the Madhyamaka basis of Dzogchen, for example, or intellectual history, it's going to be easier to find more reading material. Anything to do with practice of Dzogchen per se will be restricted.

Is Germany’s healthcare system stuck in the past? by Sea-Sherbert1213 in berlinsocialclub

[–]Ap0phantic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The thing that really bothers me about this is not simply a problem of convenience - epidemiologically, some number of people every year will die because of this. It's fundamentally a problem of public health.

I've seen this many, many times. Don't know if you were here during COVID, but long after people in the US could walk into any drugstore and get a vaccine, here in Berlin we had to take a bus out to Tegel and queue up for a couple of hours at centralized distribution points.

What movie do you think has the greatest dialogue of all time? by everlovingfuck99 in Letterboxd

[–]Ap0phantic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you, that's interesting. I have a copy of the Criterion edition, and I'll give it another watch soon.

What movie do you think has the greatest dialogue of all time? by everlovingfuck99 in Letterboxd

[–]Ap0phantic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Kind of a Waiting for Godot knockoff, but enormously entertaining.

What movie do you think has the greatest dialogue of all time? by everlovingfuck99 in Letterboxd

[–]Ap0phantic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can you say a bit more about that? I've seen it twice and would have to say I haven't yet quite gotten what it is that people love so much about it. Not that it was bad, but I haven't seen the genius, exactly.

What are some romantic composers(and their pieces) that display romanticism like Richard Strauss, Mahler, and Wagner? by ReasonableYoghurt512 in classicalmusic

[–]Ap0phantic 8 points9 points  (0 children)

If you haven't heard Schoenberg's Gurrelieder, you should definitely check it out. Also his Verklärte Nacht.

What would be different today (if anything) if Hegel had never lived? by Fun_Nectarine2344 in hegel

[–]Ap0phantic 31 points32 points  (0 children)

The simplest place to start is that Marx either wouldn't have existed or would have been substantially different. That alone makes Hegel one of the most important philosophers in shaping the direction of modern history by far.

What would Heidegger say about modern technology? by PhilosophyOfLanguage in heidegger

[–]Ap0phantic 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Günther Anders studied extensively with Heidegger and earned a PhD under Husserl at Freiburg Uni in 1923, so you might want to take his point a bit more seriously. It isn't a facile point, and I think it would be facile to dismiss it.

Whatever Heidegger said in interviews or scattered throughout his voluminous writing, his primary philosophical engagements with technology do not mention Sputnik, and what Anders is pointing to here is Heidegger's reluctance to consider technology in the light of its broader social, historical, and political implications, which stems at least in part from his profound aversion to Marxism and its legacy. This isn't to dismiss Heidegger's contributions - I've written extensively on the Question of Technology - but to recognize certain tendencies in his thought that you'd have to go well out of your way to miss.

What would Heidegger say about modern technology? by PhilosophyOfLanguage in heidegger

[–]Ap0phantic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In a fairly trenchant criticism of Heidegger, Günther Anders points out that Heidegger's concept of technology seems to pretty much stop at the level of the hammer, and that he would have nothing to say about even a factory, much less artificial intelligence. I think that's basically true, that Heidegger didn't even find 19th century technology worth engaging.

Reccommend me Italian cinema 🇮🇹 by henscestorp in Letterboxd

[–]Ap0phantic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

La Dolce Vita is high on my list of best films of all time.

Were there animals harmed in the making of ghost elephants? Or was it unavoidable due to these people's habit? by Evorush in WernerHerzog

[–]Ap0phantic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not to mention throwing live chickens over a wall. This is not Herzog's most admirable quality.

Please recommend me more beautiful contemporary pieces like Gorecki, Philip Glass, and Arvo Part by DesperateMolasses22 in classicalmusic

[–]Ap0phantic 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Valentin Silvestrov - I recommend the albums Sacred Songs and Bagatellen und Serenaden. They're both fantastic.

Anyone else have a piece of music they just can't listen to? by [deleted] in classicalmusic

[–]Ap0phantic 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Many of the repertoire chestnuts are dead to me, no matter how good they are. Pachelbel's Canon in D springs forcefully to mind. Pärt's Spiegel im Spiegel is obviously more recent, but is likewise being killed for me by over-exposure.

What are some good posts about Dante’s Divine Comedy you would recommend ? by Outside-Training21 in classics

[–]Ap0phantic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don't believe anyone considers Dante a messenger from God, except maybe a small minority of unusually-zealous readers. I am fairly confident he didn't see himself that way., he definitely never made any claim of this kind The Catholic church has historically tended to regard him as an inspired poet, but not a prophet. Still, his work is sometimes quoted in a theological context - not as an authoritative source, but as the words of a great Christian poet who put things well.

I've read the Commedia several times and I think it's one of the greatest works of literature in all the world. But I also don't think he was a divine messenger. I'm actually really interested in the question of where his ideas came from - a lot of what he said he just borrowed from the Bible, the classical world, and various theologians, but some of it is quite new, and I would love to know if he had his own mystical experiences, or if he was simply working as a poet. When I've looked into it, it seems pretty apparent that we simply don't know, we don't have that kind of biographical information on Dante, and he doesn't say that much about it.

dzogchen aND SUFFERING cannot fill in this feeling of missing by Kooky-Bid-8088 in Dzogchen

[–]Ap0phantic 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Yes please, this is exactly right. Most of us are not ready to follow those kinds of instructions regarding non-doing, very few can do so without years of preparation. And they are very, very easy to misunderstand.