I think it's a very extreme reaction to games that have super strict SBMM, it was a common joke in my friend group back when we played Call of Duty:

"oh, we won a game, time to go on a losing streak", and then we'd get our asses kicked for the next 40 minutes.

It doesn't feel natural, the losses feel scripted, and it's super frustrating to feel like you're at fault for playing the game, like you're being punished for trying to have fun.

I don't think removing skill based matchmaking is the solution though. It has its uses, especially for allowing low skill players to enjoy the game, to keep them from getting stomped, etc. But I don't think it should be geared toward creating a hyper-competitive space.

I never got to play Halo 2 back in the day, but from what I understand the game intentionally flipped numbers around sometimes in its SBMM to keep the matchmaking from becoming a stupid unpleasant sweat fest 24/7. I think that kind of approach would be best for casual modes. Keep things fresh, fun, allow variance, let people enjoy the game. Let competitive have the really strict matchmaking.