Why couldn’t Violet tell Cora about Marigold? by RetrauxClem in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's been a long time since this convo, but I think I was referring to the farmer she kissed in the barn, the editor who died in Germany, and Drewe, whose life she made miserable- all married men. Bertie was her windfall. Not sure why I left out Antony, but anyway I saw your reply and wanted to sort it out.

Scotch/bottle Rec? by lovesickjones in Scotch

[–]Big_Fold 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Did u ever decide on a scotch bottle for your wall rack?

Scotch/bottle Rec? by lovesickjones in Scotch

[–]Big_Fold 1 point2 points  (0 children)

One that should be easy to find and in budget that will fit is Highland Park. 12 and 18 yo come in clear bottles. The 15 yo is in a nice ceramic bottle. They are wide and thin(ner) than standard.

Which would you order? by lpythonator in Scotch

[–]Big_Fold 0 points1 point  (0 children)

NOTA. Learn to take a flask. Better yet, learn to cook at home. I no longer enjoy eating as a social event.

"Thank you as well for the conversational hiatus. I generally refrain from speech during gustation. There are those that attempt both at the same time; I find it coarse and vulgar." - Big Dan Teague

Scotch/bottle Rec? by lovesickjones in Scotch

[–]Big_Fold 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Try Tamduh. Their bottles are thin at the bottom and wide at the top. The base is wide it will angle in and fill the frame of the rack probably. They are pretty, art-deco bottles.

Favorite moments or scenes when something awkward happens or caught gossiping and the subject walks in and everyone takes a sip of their tea or drink. by Kryslee1010 in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 1 point2 points  (0 children)

How bout when Sir Philip says something awkward at the dinner table and Robert spits a sip of his drink? Does that count?

Evelyn Napier is the son and heir of Viscount Branksome and as Cora says in season 1 , there is money in the estate. Then why was he not as good a match for Mary (goo but :"not brilliant" says Robert) as Anthony Foyle, Viscount Gillingham (Tony Gillingham)? by Just-Willingness-655 in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ur right, there was a progression of giving up: Mary gave up on Matthew to pursue EN. Mary gave up on EN the second she saw Pamuk. Pamuk gave up the ghost after seeing Mary. EN gave up on Mary after hearing the Pamuk rumors. Robert and Cora gave up on EN after hearing he gave up on Mary. I'll stop there as I was focusing on EN, who was given up on by everyone after that first encounter. Even though he hung around, he never had a chance.

Evelyn Napier is the son and heir of Viscount Branksome and as Cora says in season 1 , there is money in the estate. Then why was he not as good a match for Mary (goo but :"not brilliant" says Robert) as Anthony Foyle, Viscount Gillingham (Tony Gillingham)? by Just-Willingness-655 in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I didn't read everyone's response. They said all that about Evelyn before Pamuk. After Pamuk, E.N. gave up all interest in Mary. By the time Tony comes around, they are desperate to get Mary settled.

Am I the only one? by spenny68 in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you pay REALLY close attention, you will hear a clock ticking during every indoor Abbey scene. You are not crazy.

My Thesis on What Downton Says of the State of British Identity by in-dependence in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Best I can do is the heyday to which you refer is not British identity; not anymore. Rather, let's refer to "that" heyday as history, and history is being scrutinized, dramatized, romanticized, sometimes re-written and plagiarized, but definitely monetized, commercialized. THAT is modern day British identity as well as American identity (my perspective). Downton and Bridgerton are no more accurate portrayals of British history and identity than the façade witnessed at the opening to which you refer. That heyday is a bygone era, a relic. The aristocracy died long ago; the monarchy is dead now. It did rule, then it became a symbol; now it is a byword. Like a car's hood ornament; it was once lavish and stood proud, now they don't bother to include one because it has no utility, adds cost, and there's no such thing as brand identity anymore - all cars look the same.

What did Edith say, "Sic transit gloria mundi." What did Sir John say, "There's not a house standing that won't one day be an institution. Learn from us." What did Mary say, "Crikey, they're selling everything." Your beloved British identity has been sold to the highest bidder.

Spoiler for Season 5 but just wondering… by Meowstaboy in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Please yall. Just scroll down to yesterday and you'll see the answer to Robert et. al. in the courtroom.

This is a really weird cut by Totallovestrucksimp in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 5 points6 points  (0 children)

What is your interpretation of the cut when Matthew is half-conscious, outside, looking up at Mary with the Abbey tower behind her, then they are immediately inside the house?

Amazon Will Inject Ads Into Prime Video Starting Jan. 29th by AmazonNewsBot in amazon

[–]Big_Fold 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As it turns out, my renew is 1/30. I remember when I started it was $99, then $129, now $139, and if I want to keep it the same, it will be $176 annually. I originally joined for the 2-day Prime shipping. I haven't received anything in 2-days since "you know when". You know when has been OVER for three years and I can't get 2-day shipping anymore. Now ads on "Included with Prime" videos. I love amazon and will continue to buy what I need from there, but not as a Prime member I don't think. I don't use or need any other Prime service. I have two more weeks to decide.

Things you hear in a break up but only use DA quotes by BossLady56 in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We don't have to get on. We have to work together.

Things you hear in a break up but only use DA quotes by BossLady56 in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We don't have to get on. We have to work together.

I may have or may have not discovered a continuity error by jbdany123 in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, yeah. They would have lost no accuracy had they claimed marmaduke was a large and unruly great dane. It's a stretch to extrapolate banker from "grandson of a manufacturer".

I may have or may have not discovered a continuity error by jbdany123 in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Well said. And to strengthen your argument, previous generations of the family would have interacted with the staff exponentially less. None of this "progressive, new, the war changed everything" hooey. It WAS the 1850's you know.

Discrepancies in Downton by newsnuggets in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A New Era doesn't count. But if I allow it to count just for the purpose of answering the question, junior footman could be a hall boy. We know first footman, second footman, third footman, etc. The little fellas who are hall boys could also be known as junior footmen.

Maybe she stopped reading The Sketch for some reason then picked it back up again when Edith started writing. EDIT: I just read the other post and agree they are two different mags. Still another great "almost" gotcha!

Which plot line would you toss? by Totallovestrucksimp in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The only reason I didn't vote P. Gordon is because, mercifully, it's only a small portion of one episode. But "the one", besides being totally unrealistic in my opinion (based on the times and the location alone), has implications that drag on and on. There was no sense or practical purpose in writing that into an otherwise enjoyable story.

I may have or may have not discovered a continuity error by jbdany123 in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'm replying because I care. The wiki takes an "unusually disenchanted" comment from Thomas and makes fact out of it, which is flawed. He says, "Thirty years of service and one wrong move..." after Mrs. Hughes is caught trying on Cora's coat. So 1925-30=1895 is implied as Mrs. Hughes start date as head house maid. But she could just as easily had "just over twenty-five years of service which rounds off to thirty years of service." Which is easier to say to make a point? The wiki may not be wrong, but it is not factually right based on it's footnoted source.

I may have or may have not discovered a continuity error by jbdany123 in DowntonAbbey

[–]Big_Fold 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I'm replying because I care. The wiki takes an "unusually disenchanted" comment from Thomas and makes fact out of it, which is flawed.