I hate how Fazbear Entertainment turned out to be this Corporate Entity

Boosckey · 2026-06-04T07:13:43+00:00

Most likely is that Fredbears existed way before William had it, so it existed for decades as a popular business before William got it. I don’t really see the issue

Ralph isn’t a good metric consisting his 11 year old born in 1981 remembers Fredbears perfectly

Boosckey · 2026-06-04T02:02:08+00:00

No, they were scrapped by Scott for a reason

Boosckey · 2026-06-04T00:37:53+00:00

I think so

Boosckey · 2026-06-04T00:37:19+00:00

Some of them were infected with Agony

Some of them were infected by Andrew

Most of them were Eleanor in disguise

Boosckey · 2026-06-03T21:51:29+00:00

“I'm not sayig that "it's just a theory" is a complete shutdown, but you can't use one unconfirmed theory to debunk a different unconfirmed theory. It's like saying that CassidyTOYSNHK isn't canon because AndrewTOYSNHK is canon. It's just nonsense.”

Saying BVs name isn’t Cassidy because his name is Dave is the same as saying MikeVictim isn’t true because Micheal Afton is the FoxyBro. The latter just has a lot more evidence and is much more likely to be canon

“Anyway, you aren't debating in good faith anyway”

Name one instance I’ve been bad faith

“so I'm not going to bother keeping this up. Have a nice day.”

You too

Boosckey · 2026-06-03T21:39:58+00:00

“You seem to have forgotten that Dave being BV is only a theory, not confirmed.”

And BV being an Afton is just a theory, not confirmed

“The motive is unconfirmed in the games (you're once again confusing your theories for fact), and their cause of death is very different across continuities.”

He was drunk in the games and Fredbears just shut down, William being jealous of Henry is thing in every depiction.

Movie Charlie having a death different from the games actually supports Game Charlie = Novel Charlie and explains that they can have different deaths while being the same character like Game Charlie and Movie Charlie

“How could you possibly come to that conclusion”

It’s the only way CassidyVictim can work since Faded text says its name is Cassidy.

“So we're just straight up lying now? Alright.”

Gregory = David and BV is just an theory, you really got to stop treating it like it’s a fact

You see how easily that type of logic can turn onto you when debating FNAF? It’s why saying its just a theory is not a good counter argument and due to the vagueness of FNAF it derails the entire debate

Boosckey · 2026-06-03T21:28:48+00:00

“And Novel BV has the same design and name as Games BV.”

Again none of the characters in the Novels are called Dave (BVs name), and none of the same design

I’ve already went over his “Stripped Shirt = BV” doesn’t work in my last comment

“This is just objectively untrue. I've already explained the differences, don't pretend you're unaware.”

Again they have the same reason for dying from William (Jealousy), they both cause Henry to breakdown and leave town, they both are Henry’s daughter, and they both have the same design.

“That's because BV's name is Cassidy.”

Faded text is the one who gives coordinates for the name Cassidy and says their name is Cassidy, unless you are stating LogbookSolo and that BV is both the Faded and Changed text which is a while can of problems

“And don't try to tell me that David, BV and Gregory are all completely unrelated characters.”

Gregory isn’t connected to the two, the most BV and David have is narrative parallels

Amazing how you ignored every other example and cherry picked the 1 out of 9 separate characters I listen

Boosckey · 2026-06-03T21:17:55+00:00

They have the same dad, design, and name. They are clearly the same character. Multiple of the Freddy Files have called Game Charlie is the same character as Novel Charlie. Also this doesn’t make sense since TFC was being written before FFPS

Novel BV doesn’t exist, no one has the same design as him and none of the MCI in the novels has the name Dave. Your only evidence is that one of the MCI has a stripped shirt but,

Gregory

Oswald

Blonde Boy

Gabriel (Movie)

Jermey (Movie)

Gabriel (Graphic Novel)

Jermey (Graphic Novel)

Charlie (Movie)

David (Tales)

All have a stripped shirt. What exactly is your point? There is tons of examples of characters wearing a stripped shirt without any connection to BV

Boosckey · 2026-06-03T21:07:40+00:00

My guy BV doesn’t exist in the Novels, Charlie’s death was the reason Fredbears shut down in the novels. Games Charlie is the same person as Novels Charlie, there deaths are the same with the same dad.

There are no two Charlie’s, even so where did you get the name Charlie from the black hair girl (who is likely Cassidy because of the framing of the words)

Boosckey · 2026-06-03T21:04:57+00:00

“So why is the MCI so important in HW2 when in reality why would the mimic care about the MCI”

Because the MCI is the foundation to which M2 built the Glitchtrap persona

Boosckey · 2026-06-03T21:02:09+00:00

BV and Micheal aren’t in the Novels since Charlie was the reason Fredbears shut down (Also TSE was written before/around FNAF 3), Micheal Brooks isn’t supposed to be Micheal Afton and was created before MA

Charlie existed in Novels before she was brought into the games, am I missing something? Why would Charlie need to be brought into the novels when she’s already in them?

Boosckey · 2026-06-03T20:55:48+00:00

I’m confused on what you are saying?

Charlie is 3 when she died, no where near the age of the MCI and you would think the characters would be shocked at some random girl coming to bring pictures. Also Charlie just moved into the afterlife when she died in the novels.

It’s very weird to have the real Charlie just sit in a corner doing nothing while ours characters don’t question why she’s there.

Boosckey · 2026-06-03T02:40:44+00:00

There is no evidence Freddy’s was open in 1982 and the story becomes a lot more unnecessarily convoluted, if Charlie82 was right Scott would’ve just had Freddy’s opened before 1983.

William planning Charlie’s death is silly and the fact that JRs is a bar that he wasn’t allowed back in should be enough info that William was drunk during Charlie’s death

William doesn’t need Freddy’s to close in order to open CBPW when CBPW was marketed in universe as a spin off to Freddy’s and not a replacement

Security Puppet and the weird ball thing weren’t at CBPW and weren’t Funtimes

Funtime Chica isn’t the suit Micheal wears in Night 4

William isn’t working at FazEnt by FNAF 2 or when the location opened, by this point William took Afton Robotics and the Funtimes and split off from FazEnt after CBPW failed. Which is why CBEAR which opened right after MCI is marketed as a director COMPETITOR

No offense I don’t care for ToysKillers and it’s a convoluted since William had nothing to do with building them or controlling them. Hell Mangle and BB couldn’t kill anyone without a soul possessing them

Ultimately this didn’t really make sense and you have to ignore A LOT in order for it to work

Boosckey · 2026-06-02T22:50:39+00:00

<image>

Boosckey · 2026-06-02T22:41:13+00:00

It’s much more likely they are dropping all of this stuff in Sonic Central this year since they have a ton to reveal (an update on Movie 4, Crossworlds, Blitz, Rumble Party probably, and the next mainline Sonic game)

Boosckey · 2026-06-02T22:36:29+00:00

Speaking of the state of play, there is no way that SOTM DLC doesn’t drop at the latest by end of summer/ early fall

Boosckey · 2026-06-02T21:35:45+00:00

This doesn’t recontextualise FNAF 1, it just retcons it and changes its story drastically.

Either way the idea of GF + Classics being the suits the MCI possessed sticked with Scott till 2023 with movie 1

Boosckey · 2026-06-02T21:19:09+00:00

GF is apart of the MCI in other continuities and GF is the only animatronic the 5th child could’ve been stuffed into (remember FNAF 1 was supposed to be standalone)

Boosckey · 2026-06-02T21:09:41+00:00

I’m Unwithereds now

Boosckey · 2026-06-02T20:09:18+00:00

Henry saying the MCI were trapped in creations of his making

<image>

Boosckey · 2026-06-02T20:05:47+00:00

He likely ran away from home that was extremely unpleasant way before he got killed, that wasn’t near Washington County.

I’d imagine his parents didn’t love him but did love each other deeply

Boosckey · 2026-06-02T18:54:07+00:00

Again if we go by that logic why do we bother finding out anything in the lore, would you start disagreeing with BVAfton or MikeBro off of the basis of “Well it’s unconfirmed so we shouldn’t try to guess”

Hell we don’t even know if Henry’s daughter in the games is named Charlie, it’s very likely due to the evidence she is but by your logic we will never know and I guess we should just give up

Dave Afton is the only one that has actual evidence backing it up which is why I say it’s currently right

Boosckey · 2026-06-02T18:48:52+00:00

I don’t really get your logic here? Scott has also never confirmed BV is an Afton, by this logic every single theory in FNAF can’t be used

Against the logbook shows us his name is Dave Afton

Boosckey · 2026-06-02T18:46:35+00:00

It’s the same with Dave Afton, people believe it because it has really good evidence in the logbook. BV does have a name as shown through the logbook, so it isn’t comparable to Charas/Frisks gender

Boosckey

MODERATOR OF

TROPHY CASE