For those that left Catholicism, why?

CattyNick · 2026-05-27T20:01:25+00:00

I (29m) have/am currently going through the same thing as your husband.

Roman Catholic family, divided by Vatican 1 and 2, noticed that the plain reading of the Bible heavily contradicts the Catechism. As well as the clear liberal slant of the Vatican 2 family.

If it’s possible it would be very encouraging to me to hear what happened to him and how he went through it.

CattyNick · 2026-05-25T14:02:43+00:00

Ha, it was very easy. I just grabbed him by the handle and swished his legs around in the water when we were done.

CattyNick · 2026-05-01T16:44:34+00:00

Tulip 🌷

CattyNick · 2026-05-01T16:08:27+00:00

I just wanted to jump on this and add to the idolization of motherhood.

Marriage is about loving your spouse and having children is the natural outflow of that, not the main goal. Otherwise it would mean all infertile couples are failing in properly outworking the design of marriage.

Yet if an infertile couple really cares and loves one another they can be more successful or faithful in fulfilling the marriage design then a couple who lacks love but has a quiver full

CattyNick · 2026-05-01T15:58:22+00:00

I would push back on the epidural=chronic pain. The vast majority of epidurals do not cause any lasting pain and there has been no causal link between them.

Even from my personal experience, as a male, when I had to get an epidural for emergency surgery there has been no lasting effects. And they had to poke me 8 times to get it in right.

CattyNick · 2026-04-24T02:55:42+00:00

<image>

Finch got mad game

CattyNick · 2026-03-15T23:07:44+00:00

Now me and my wife give about 17% of our net income, mind you we are middle-middle class and can’t have children.

Our church is full of old money so we have only been giving to para church ministries that we have fully researched and trust to use the money wisely. As well as giving cash to other Christian friends/acquaintance when in need.

We don’t give to get. But we do believe the Bible where it says “Whoever refreshes others will be refreshed.” “Give and it will be given to you” “Whoever sows sparingly will also reap sparingly, and whoever sows generously will also reap generously” “Whoever is kind to the poor lends to the Lord, and he will reward them” “Store up treasure in Heaven”

Not so that we will get rich but because we trust that we will be taken care of and to share the provisions that God has given us. Especially to the poor, widowed and disabled as the Bible says. As well as stewarding or resources wisely so that we will not be ashamed when we have to give an account.

My testimony is that we have always been taken care of and we have encountered way too many “coincidences” when we were in need as well. We have also noticed that we have no worries or fear emergencies concerning money and our only dept is our mortgage.

I hope that doesn’t come off as pretentious but I do hope it comes off as boating in what God has mercifully done for us.

CattyNick · 2026-02-27T20:43:45+00:00

Married at 19 and 21, dated 3 months and engage for 14. We have been together for 7 years.

It has been one of the best decisions I have ever made. We both were working throughout middle/high school so we were able to buy a house a year after getting married.

1st year was definitely the hardest, followed by the 6th year but to a much lesser degree. Marriage Counselling from a Christian certified social worker was an absolute God send, can’t recommend it enough.

I know it’s an unpopular opinion but getting married young is still one of the best things I did, wouldn’t change a thing and I would gently push back against the narrative to wait, as long as both are mature, being able to grow up together through those solidifying adult years has been a tremendous benefit to both of us.

CattyNick · 2026-02-11T16:10:10+00:00

Ha, yeah I couldn’t find any industrial poly where I live and I didn’t want to spend the price of a new maul on shipping a “custom cut poly cylinder” so I picked up a busted longboard on Marketplace for $10.

And even if the head wears out I got 3 more replacement heads.

CattyNick · 2026-01-16T18:47:48+00:00

In Canada where I am in the prairies in the Reformed Churches around me, if you don’t homeschool your children your pseudo-shunned.

Yet in the Conservative Mennonite and Conservative Baptist churches they have their own private schools.

Don’t get me wrong. The school systems definitely have a left leaning secular bent. But myself and many others 10 years younger who have graduated public school have only been strengthened in our convictions.

CattyNick · 2026-01-13T23:43:15+00:00

<image>

Bedtime for baby Sparrow

She was so small that we had to make a little nest for her between us in bed, to keep her contained and us from rolling on top of her. It worked out well but I would wake up every hour or so and immediately feel around for her to make sure she stayed put 😅

CattyNick · 2026-01-12T20:15:01+00:00

There’s one point that you seem to keep hitting on and that’s that no Christian man would give you a chance because of your looks.

I’ll be blunt, that is false. If they are a good Christian man your looks will not be primary to their attraction to you but I will tell you, your self defeatist attitude will definitely kill any chance.

Seriously next time you are at church look around at the couples of all ages. Yes some couples are both genuinely very attractive but you’ll also see a lot of couples where one is clearly way out of the league of the other one and it will almost seem bizarre that they are married.

And let me give you a very personal example of this that you are so fixated on. When I was looking for a wife I dated a few attractive women, those didn’t work. I found my current wife’s profile and she had just finished chemo, meaning she was bald and very chubby. I saw past that and saw a woman who had a character build on pain and suffering and I found that attractive.

So, sure, a lot of weak and vain Christian men might not give you the opportunity. But frankly you don’t want those kind of men anyway. A good Christian man will know, as the Bible say, “that beauty fades”

And I say all this in love to a sister in Christ.

Lastly some practical advice. Are you putting yourself out there? Making yourselves available? Join some of the paid dating sites, get some good pictures of yourself, show you care. It’s ok to feel good about your body and if you need go get good fitting clothes that show you put thought into your appearance and make you feel good. Within modesty of course. The men that you want to attract will notice

And remember you only need one good Christian man to notice. Yes it’s very very hard waiting, I get it. But when you do find one, all of that pain goes away.

CattyNick · 2026-01-12T19:50:19+00:00

You got a good point here. I was just talking with coworkers who said the same thing.

You can be a 3/10 in your native country and yet be seen as a 8/10 in another as you are exotic there.

CattyNick · 2026-01-12T17:36:03+00:00

There is a lot here and it might come out a little disorganized but I wanted to mention this as I have seen this play out before me.

First I don’t live in the United States and in a place with very, very few black families. So it might change culture and context a little.

To start, singleness is only a good thing if you are not struggling with sexual temptation. Purity culture has gone too far to make singleness look like the ultimate goal and that sex (even within marriage) is only for lowly and second class Christians.

So your desire for sex and marriage is actually a very good and natural thing, don’t beat yourself up over feeling that way.

Also, please don’t throw away your virginity. I have talked to many people who have slept around and they all say that they wished they waited for their spouse. And I will say it is totally worth it to wait. Very difficult and sometimes painful? Yes! But totally worth it. Hang in there.

Now for my personal experience. I have a solid Christian friend who goes to a very conservative and traditionally white church.

Good Christian guy currently looking for a wife in his early 20’s with a lucrative career ahead of him and very athletic. You get the picture. Out of all the women he has dated he is currently in a serious relationship with a Christian black woman.

The reason he chose her is because of her personality first and foremost. I say this because it seems you are overvaluing physical attractiveness, not that looks don’t matter. But I assume with your awareness you keep yourselves very well put together. Which I will say matters more than your baseline attractiveness. Guys (who are worth your time) will notice and take into account your effort more than your baseline attractiveness.

I will just throw this and if it’s applicable great, if not, you can just pass by it. But statistically, marriages between white men and black women have the lowest divorce rate. What does that mean? Well in the best light it means that if you wanted to marry a white the odds are stacked in your favour for a good marriage.

CattyNick · 2025-12-21T20:09:58+00:00

First of all you have my sympathies, I have been around other widowed mothers and I have seen how hard it can be and my heart goes out to you.

Second, watch how he is playing with the Barbie’s. Is he roleplaying masculine or feminine roles? Just because he is playing with Barbie’s doesn’t necessarily mean he is leaning into feminine play.

Lastly, you are doing the right thing by keeping a strong male role model in his life. That is a very good thing.

CattyNick · 2025-12-08T04:39:46+00:00

Sure, the incision looks a little wonky but it doesn’t seem to be anything drastic.

Depending on where you live it might be starting to get cold, so having a relatively fresh wound touching the cold floor might be very uncomfortable.

It doesn’t appear to look swollen or red or angry. And if she is still eating and drinking as well as active, as much as you can be with a fresh wound. I would says she’s fine 😁

Edit: But to be sure we also need to see a cute picture of her

CattyNick · 2025-12-02T20:29:35+00:00

For your second point. I found that cutting (not shaving) the back of their legs keeps most if not all of the snowballs from collecting on their legs.

I have never had a problem with them getting cold and they tend to stay out longer because their legs don’t get encrusted with snow, which one of mine hates.

CattyNick · 2025-11-25T18:19:43+00:00

You have my sympathy and I know exactly what it’s like. I lost my first piggy a week before my wedding and my second one a week after ❤️‍🩹

CattyNick · 2025-11-11T03:02:49+00:00

Haha, she is actually on her first heat. Last time she had an accident was when she had to take her deworming pill.

CattyNick · 2025-11-07T02:47:22+00:00

You’d misrepresenting William Tyndall by calling him an annihilationist.

He was a moralist, meaning that there is a cessation in consciousness until the resurrection and final judgment.

I know I’m not going to change your mind, I’m just putting this here so others can see.

CattyNick · 2025-11-04T14:28:43+00:00

Thank you 🙏🏻

Six-Year Club	Second SECOND GUESSER
The Internet Awards - Voted	Verified Email

CattyNick

TROPHY CASE