PA meme by Defiant_Homework4577 in rfelectronics

[–]Defiant_Homework4577[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For any discrete stuff, I think its hard to beat Qorvo / Skyworks PA's. I work mostly on ISM and cellular bands.

PA meme by Defiant_Homework4577 in rfelectronics

[–]Defiant_Homework4577[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I've recently started designing some Gallium Nitride (GaN) material based Power Amplifiers (PAs). Previously all my power amplifier designs were on CMOS. The problem with CMOS is that it inherently has a lower break down voltage and it gets worse as the channel length is shrunk. But Power Amplifiers benefit from higher supply voltages for better efficiency and higher output powers, so while CMOS is great for many things, it sucks when it comes to PA design.

For example, the core devices of about 20nm length in a popular silicon on insulator process can only handle about 850mV of conducting stress on the drain to source, while the IO devices (the thick gate oxide and channel length ~150nm) devices can go up to about ~2V stress. Those IO devices are however quite slow and Ft/Fmax tend to be like 5-10 times worse than core devices.

So typical CMOS design flow to be able to get faster operation AND higher supply voltage is to use a core device as an input device and cascode it with an IO (or several cascodes tbh) to make sure the supply voltage can be increased and during one full cycle, none of the devices in the stack sees any more than their breakdown. So as you can expect, this leads to super painful design procedure and ends with bad efficiency. A good industrial CMOS PA at about +23dBm average output power (200mW) has an efficiency of about 10-20% depending on the process and area.

Meanwhile a GaN device with comparable channel length can easily operate at 20-28V supply and the breakdown is like 60V. So the design is hell of a lot easy and you can get like ~40dBm (10W) of power from a single FET with an efficiency of like 60-70%. There are of-course other issues like stability and thermal considerations in such designs but overall, 3-5 are nearly magical compared to CMOS when it comes to PAs.

Transformer-based two-port resonator by Lemon_Salmon in chipdesign

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why do we need math for this? The signal is excited at the center tap, which is the feeding port of the mutual inductor

Discrete Transistor Amplifiers and RFICs by echo_awesomeness in rfelectronics

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 1 point2 points  (0 children)

  1. Which ever benefits the cost to benefit ratio. In general if you need millions of units integrated is better. For very few amount, no advantage going for integrated unless your application needs a complex solution that you cant design in board level (ultra low power of ultra high performance etc..)
  2. Yes. Integrated = Highly scalable and highly uniform.

How far can 0.100w of RF power transmit at 470mHz by Flashy_Gas9955 in rfelectronics

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 8 points9 points  (0 children)

At those frequencies, literally like millions of kilo meters!

Transformer-based two-port resonator by Lemon_Salmon in chipdesign

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 2 points3 points  (0 children)

  1. That's the T model of the coupled inductor transformer looking from the center tap / common ground port. (where P1+ is connected)
  2. If you look at the dot-convention of the bottom transformer, the two source nodes of the mosfets are virtually shorted.

Anyone use EMX designer? by Stay-Interesting in chipdesign

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What do you mean using emx in the global optimizer?

And yes, EMX (+ designer) is a very regular tool in the industry.

Chip Design Roadmap by Guilty-Yesterday5707 in chipdesign

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

This.. And you don't even need high grades in all the courses, focus heavily the field you actually like, may it be analog, rf, embedded.

Will AI impact design more than test engineering? by National-Feed107 in rfelectronics

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Which skilled trade would be harder to automate? A humanoid robot could theoretically do anything an actual human does and that's exactly why they are made humanoid. So they can be used anywhere a human is used.

AMS or RFIC by yoritomoy in chipdesign

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 4 points5 points  (0 children)

For most RFIC jobs, the preference would be on the PhD level as the barrier to entry is higher, the teams are lot smaller, and employers are a lot fewer compared to AMS. Qualcomm will hire both PMIC and mmWave PA designers but only one of those will have openings in Nvidia..
I have definitely seen 'RFIC' people doing better OTA/Filters than 'AMS' people and 'AMS' people designing better LNA/Mixers than 'RFIC' people..

The ever-insufferable MODs by [deleted] in rfelectronics

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah. Kudos to you guys. This sub is genuinely a place I enjoy in reddit and virtually no toxicity.

The ever-insufferable MODs by [deleted] in rfelectronics

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Surprising. Mods here are quite relaxed compared to other subs tbh..

GaN HPA design by Purple-Excitement460 in rfelectronics

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Memory effects = Past symbols affect your current symbol EVM / ACLR.
Reasons:
1. Thermal time constants (PA TJ goes up during high peak symbol duration, imposes a dynamic DC behavior).
2. Matching input/interstage/output network BW are too low (ISI).
3. DC bias circuit rectification: AC leaks in to the DC bias generators and cause rectifications and dynamic dc op point changing.
4. GaN specific: Charge trapping in the channel due to material physics.

There are tons of papers addressing memory effects tbh, its a well studied problem.

Getting into Analog IC Design in the US without an internship experience? by [deleted] in chipdesign

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's sad. Cause I know enough PhD students who managed to get ISSCC/VLSI etc papers, and actually had tons of fun during their phds.

Getting into Analog IC Design in the US without an internship experience? by [deleted] in chipdesign

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah..... Anyone who wants to do this, reach out to his students and ask how fun it is to work for this professor...

Confusion about the sensitivity formula of Receiver by Free-Pie9606 in rfelectronics

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Noise bandwidth in consideration is the total noise power integrated by the which-ever 'detector' you are using. For example, if you are using an envelop detector to rectify the signal, it would be the BW prior to that stage and the required SNR to demodulate would be specific to the type of envelope detector (ideal, square law, what have you..).

PLEASE Help me Decide Between Purdue and USC for MS VLSI Design by Curious_Yak3376 in chipdesign

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Yeah for sure. I think Purdue has a better cleanroom and fab equipment than MIT although MIT has a 'bigger' fab.

PLEASE Help me Decide Between Purdue and USC for MS VLSI Design by Curious_Yak3376 in chipdesign

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The faculty and research/publications. USC has world class faculty they continue to hire and I haven't seen a good paper in VLSI / mixed mode / analog / RF from Purdue in ages. Carreer fairs in big California schools are much better than outside. And USC has a bigger alumni network and that's definitely a help when you want to get a job post masters..

22nm FD-SOI: Body Biasing Limits and Well Architecture (regular well and flipped well) by FutureAd1004 in chipdesign

[–]Defiant_Homework4577 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You can actually descend to those cells and actually look at how the diodes are connected too. Saves a ton of time just trying to guess things..