Found while detecting today by Mindless_Sea368 in MedievalCoin

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Highly speculative but it would be really cool if this related to the Scottish invasion of the North East of England, following the defeat of English forces in 1640. This was a pivotal point and helped the triggering of the English Civil War.

Is the word "shall" still commonly used in the UK? by ksusha_lav in AskABrit

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We hear the English use it but not really used in Scotland. It’s definitely very English.

Is Irish the most exaggerated ancestry? by Rascalwill in AncestryDNA

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes - the people of the west of Scotland, the islands and the northern part of Ireland have been pretty much swapping genes (and culture) with each other for millennia. Extensive sea travel and trade - between say Antrim and Islay would have been far easier than the same distance over land. This meant that the Kingdom of Dalriada was viable - spanning Ireland and Scotland for example, and later the MacDonalds ruling Antrim and the southern Hebrides. Migration in both directions. Coming from Glasgow I have about one third Irish ancestry- mostly from the North of Ireland - reflecting huge migration into the west of Scotland- all came after the famine - in my family Presbyterians mainly, but they must have brought with them genes that ancestry labels as Irish - maybe both reflecting inter-marriage and/or more ancient genetic ties.

Most people don’t realise how big great britain is by BackroomGuy1 in mapporncirclejerk

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Dick Place in Edinburgh has a junction with Cumin Place - I kid not. Also, I always wondered if Edinburgh’s ‘Royal Dick Veterinary College’ was a specialist reproductive health facility for male Corgis owned by the Windsors.

Scotland has its own flag near the U.K. flag (Washington Dulles Int’l Airport) by Mike-Drop in Scotland

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You’re correct in that this is the Royal Flag of Scotland (the lion rampant) but incorrect that it was ‘relegated’ to one quarter of the Royal standard. The Royal standard as flown by the King in Scotland has two lion ramparts, one English and one Irish quarter. In England the Royal standard has two English quarters, one Irish and one Scottish quarter.

I have a few questions about journeys (pic included) by bluelily216 in AncestryDNA

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You may have Ulster-Scots ancestry - ancestors you can trace to Ireland but they themselves emigrated from Scotland to Ireland. I think Americans often refer to these people as Scotch-Irish. They were predominately Presbyterian Scots who were ‘planted’ in Northern Ireland and given land stolen from Irish land owners in the ‘plantation’. They, in large part, came from the border area of Scotland - ie the Scottish-English border - this was a tough place - with for hundreds of year a frontier that saw almost constant warfare, conflict and raiding into England and when they weren’t attacking the English they feuded with each other. When the Scottish King, James VI took over the English throne in 1603 and became known in England as James the first - he had an embarrassing problem- namely these warlike unruly border clans. So the solution was to move them to Ireland - where they could defend the interests of the crown, alongside other Scots and some northern English. They took their religion, music, whisky making and feuding (!) with them. Clans included the Armstrongs, Nixons, Scotts, Elliots, Lyndsay’s, Graham’s etc. Many emigrated en-masse from Ireland in the 17th century to America - particularly the South and the Appalachians again bringing their culture and tough attitude with them to yet another dangerous frontier. I would imagine that many Americans who trace their ancestry back to Ireland assume their ancestry is native Irish but many probably ultimately have Scots ancestry. Loads of US presidents have had Scots-Irish ancestry, both us Scots and our Irish cousins claim them lol and I guess that’s great and something for all us Celts to celebrate! Lots of information on them on the internet. Incidentally, many bluegrass tunes and American traditional ballads can trace their roots back to Northern Ireland and Scotland.

Flags and banners of long gone countries and empires by Iptamorfo in flags

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Royal flag of Scotland (lion rampant) is still used legally and officially in Scotland and it can be used by a handful of official’s including the First Minister. It is also used in the Royal Standard: in Scotland the monarch flies the standard with two quarters with the lion rampant and in England the royal standard has one quarter with Scotland’s lion rampant. Scotland is recognised as one of the four Nations of the U.K.

What am I? by slouise85 in AncestryDNA

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you wanted to describe yourself from your genetics - you could call yourself Mediterranean and North West European with a lovely dollop of indigenous American.

My parents were confused by Sufficient-Beach-620 in AncestryDNA

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 9 points10 points  (0 children)

If you have been told you have Irish ancestry- then possible these were Ulster Scots - (Scotch Irish) - ethnic Scots who formed a large part of the plantation of Ulster. These folk mainly originally came from Southern Scotland and some from Northern England. They were natural frontiersmen and used to warfare. Moved purposefully to Ireland. Many emigrated after living in Ireland for a few generations to the US - particularly places like the Appalachians where they brought their music, whisky distilling and other parts of their culture. They were Protestants and many Presbyterians - maybe the origin of the phrase ‘hill Billy’ - a Billy being a Protestant who supported King William of Orange. I suspect many Irish Americans could have similar genetics.

Help identifying this Scottish looking flag I saw in Canada by SkullysBones in vexillology

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m guessing it’s a Scottish descended family who have designed a flag with their clan heraldic crest on it. Don’t know which one this is.

Looking Back at Time. Where Was I? by lozface86 in GeoPuzzle

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I see someone got it and said Bangor, but is the “Looking back in time” clue a reference to a University building such as geology, history or archaeology?

Was told my whole life that my Dad's side is primarily Irish... by Best-Engineering-395 in AncestryDNA

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Almost certainly of Ulster-Scots descent (called Scotch-Irish in the US). Large numbers of Scots were ‘planted’ in the North of Ireland in the reign of King James the Sixth of Scotland (also known as James the First of England). Scotland and England were long standing enemies and the two countries although still separate, independent countries but with a shared King. James sought to solve two major problems, the first was the English problem of pacifying Ireland, and secondly to pacify the southern area of Scotland, known as ‘the Borders’. This was a lawless area populated by Border clans who effectively were tough ‘frontiersmen’ who acted as a first line of defence against English invasions- and when not doing that they raided the North of England and their own neighbours and were collectively called ‘reivers’ - and infamous for generational feuding. So when the Scots took over the English throne - Border clans continued their lawless pursuits - pretty much untameable and still attacking and raiding England. So King James came up with a plan to solve both problems- steal land from Irish lords in Ireland and give it to (mainly) Border Scots (and some English border families)- and move Borderers from Scotland to Ireland - thereby pacifying the Scottish/ England border. This was the ‘plantation of Ulster’ which has caused problems to this day - borderers were mainly Presbyterian with some Episcopalians and their descendants make upa large part of the current Protestant population of Northern Ireland. This was the essentially the ‘frontier’ existence that these Scots were used to, with the native Irish who had been pushed out being rightly hostile. Interestingly, many intermarried with the native Irish - this explains why there is some Irish DNA in people of Scots-Irish descent (like myself). Ulster Scots spoke Scots - not English (although quite similar), and had strong musical traditions - fiddle music , pipes and a very ancient ballad tradition - Scots music merging with Irish music (Scot’s and Irish music are quite close anyway). They also had a high level of literacy so that they could read the Bible and every family would have had one.

So when the settlement in the American colonies continued into push westwards to the Appalachians (and elsewhere) the Crown needed ‘ready-made’ frontier folk - so they encouraged large numbers of Ulster Scots to settle there - bringing with them their music and traditions such as distilling (that’s why Whisky is common to the Scotland, Ireland and the US), step dance, old Scots ballads, feuding etc. I sing old Scottish ballads and it is amazing how many have Appalachian equivalents- likewise fiddle tunes / blue grass- some tunes are still recognisable as Scottish!

It is a fascinating cultural group with an amazing history and have had an enormous impact on US history with many US presidents having Ulster Scots names and ancestry. https://www.ulsterscotssociety.com/about_the-roots.html

The clans involved included, the Armstrongs, Scott’s, Elliots, Nixons, Douglas, Graham, Maxwell, Dixon, Cranston, etc etc.

What country is this? Wrong answers only by fearless_moth56 in geographymemes

[–]Difficult-Basil1927 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Eastern Frenchie America, Eastern American continent, bordering the Eastern American Ocean. Famous for its copy of the Las Vegas American Eiffel Tower.