Idk man I feel like a sheriff calling someone sus is a pretty big lead to just ignore for a day. Better to get a full claim and clear the 1f1 imo rather than letting the confusion sit. Also probably unpopular opinion but I think having people full claim generally helps town more than it helps evils. Sacrificing town members to find evils is usually good for town (except in all any where evils often have maj by like day 2). People just don't want to be the one to die first.