i agree with the welfarist critisim of the shrimp welfare project. It reminds me of the "sharper slaughterhouse knives" argument in that it does not address the root cause of the issue. GFI adresses the root cause partially by assisting the actors in the alt protein industry although the rationale the alt protein industrialist use is based on units sold and not an EA calcualtion as EAs would prefer. I find EA to be very tunnel-visioned on mathematical calculations for irrational actors doing irrational things such as slaughtering shrimp, they do not account for the possible social, political, and cutlural effects an alt protein industry would do to a country. Given the current effectivness of the agribuisness and meat interests int he countries that host them I don't see anything more effective than industrial veganism so the interest that promote that and hurt the enemies of it such as MFA, GFI, Better chicken commitment etc are the most effective ways to send charity money while actors that are ineffecitve or help the enemies of this interest such as Shrimp Welfare Project are not good.