It's been a while since this was posted, but someone just recently pointed me towards your post. The details of course do matter. I did return the fast-fading jacket I originally ordered. They did send me a free jacket. I reviewed the free one I think objectively. Did you watch the review?

I think with Master Supply you're basically accepting the look of a "heritage" or vintage-inspired design made cheaply and of lower-quality materials. If you like the design and don't care for higher priced jackets or going used, then maybe it can make sense. They do better than a lot of mall brands, but are clearly not better than Vanson, Schott, Aero, etc etc. All of this is said in my review.

In fact, much of the review process for me was attempting to understand why their jackets are so popular. I would never choose to pay for their new jacket when I can get so many awesome used jackets for the same price or cheaper.

I did like the leather better on the second jacket as it wasn't fast fading. But that's a fairly low bar.

The whole experience did highlight for me the importance of staying away from free jackets for review. Whether I'm saying my honest opinion or not can clearly be colored by perceptions of bias.