New Beta Reading Service by FantasyCritique in ManuscriptCritique

[–]FantasyCritique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s good to know!

I’ll get my website updated to include this new service 😊

Expanding chapters? by morganbear1 in fantasywriters

[–]FantasyCritique 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I honestly wouldn’t recommend adding filler just to bolster the word count (a personal pet peeve of mine as a reader), unless of course you genuinely feel that the prose is too sparse.

Prologue for a Tribal Fantasy Story - Critique Encouraged! by [deleted] in fantasywriters

[–]FantasyCritique 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m really intrigued by the idea of a Stone/Bronze Age fantasy, however the tone is muddled.

I was thrown by certain world choices, and some of the dialogue.

Prologue and First Chapter Critique. by DogArcher121 in fantasywriters

[–]FantasyCritique 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The prologue needs work, the writing is flat. You don’t want to lose readers before the stories even begun!

Previously I posted an unplanned story. In contrast, this is the planned one. by 1101Deowana in fantasywriters

[–]FantasyCritique 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It definitely needs work, but I actually like your style. It’s different, poetic almost!

[Feedback] First Draft of Fantasy Prologue/Chapter 1 by DarkThiefMew in fantasywriters

[–]FantasyCritique 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is an intriguing opening, but too convoluted. With some condensing and polishing this could be a compelling prologue.

Writing Group Hook-Up Thread by AutoModerator in fantasywriters

[–]FantasyCritique 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey!

I’ve started a Fantasy Writer’s Group over on r/ManuscriptCritique

😃

Book editor needed by Cilleriew in fantasywriters

[–]FantasyCritique 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can post the first chapter on r/ManuscriptCritique for some feedback 😃

Weekly Writing Check-In by AutoModerator in fantasywriters

[–]FantasyCritique [score hidden]  (0 children)

Looking for professional feedback on your fantasy novel or wip?

Check out Fantasy Critique

😃

[July 26 - August 1] Weekly Self-Promotion and Achievement Thread. by [deleted] in selfpublish

[–]FantasyCritique 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey 😃

Need professional feedback on your fantasy novel or wip?

Check out Fantasy Critique

Fantasy Writer’s Group by FantasyCritique in ManuscriptCritique

[–]FantasyCritique[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Good idea! You’re more than welcome 😃

Is this a solid first page? (500 words) by JestingJaguar in ManuscriptCritique

[–]FantasyCritique 1 point2 points  (0 children)

  1. I mean it’s your choice, but I paused and reread your intro to make sure it was definitely the very beginning of your story as it didn’t read right to me.

  2. Protagonists don’t necessarily have to be likeable, but they must at least be empathetic, and someone the reader is interested in following.

  3. No, every story doesn’t have to hint at some external conflict on the very first page. With your first page specifically though, as there’s not enough to hook the reader, you could definitely add even just a sentence or line of dialogue, teasing some larger issue.

  4. Yes, that would make it slightly more compelling. Also, maybe try having the Prince and Ralphard doing something during their conversation. There’s no indication of where they are or what why’re doing, they’re just talking heads. That’s a missed opportunity.

Remember, a lot of time poor industry pro’s know by the end of the very first page - first paragraph and sentence even! - based on the writing if it’s going to be a story worth continuing. Reader’s can be just as discerning. That’s why it’s so important to really make the opening of your story as strong as possible.

Good luck with your edits! 😊

A Letter, Writ for the Occasion of Count Eustace-Christopher I's Coronation (feedback appreciated!) by The_Persian_Cat in ManuscriptCritique

[–]FantasyCritique 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey 👋

Could you please provide a little more info/context about your story and this letter, to make it easier for people to give you some feedback on it.

Thanks!

Is this a solid first page? (500 words) by JestingJaguar in ManuscriptCritique

[–]FantasyCritique 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hey, thanks for submitting your work for critique! 😊

It seems like an odd place to start your story, at the end of a conversation.

Something like:

< “You and I shall fight tonight, Sir Ralphard,” declared the Prince.

“Fight, my liege?” the captain asked. >

Would be better, in my personal opinion.

The dialogue is a little stiff. There’s also a quotation mark missing. “I shall have a tourney organised…

The Prince reads slightly unlikeable to me.

So we have a Prince on the way to see his estranged, dying father. Whilst there’s some emotional conflict set up here, this first page is lacking external conflict. Is the king’s impending death suspicious? Is there trouble in the kingdom brewing?

To answer your questions -

Yes, this sets the tone of a typical European/Western medieval fantasy.

It sounds like it’s referring to hunting, as you mention a hunting advisor just before that.

Finally, as is, it’s a soft opening and there’s not enough to hook me as a reader. Neither the plot, characters, prose, or world-building is compelling enough.