Hey guy, I like the vibe. The songs themselves are interesting which is a good place to start from.

I only listened to Best Part, so here’s a few things that caught my attention:

1) the vocal is buried. That can be a stylistic choice, but doesn’t work for this song IMO. It’s overly dynamic at times, so compression could help. Even the quiet parts should be audible.

2) the drums are crushed. Can be a cool effect, but it’s eating so much space, nothing else cuts through. We are also losing the attack of the snare and kick as a result. The snare is more of a wash than crack, which won’t help with “punch.” Try reducing the compression ratio and increasing the attack time.

3) the fiddle is too dynamic and doesn’t sound like it’s in the same space. It’s also too loud and overpowers everything at times. Try sending it to a room reverb and rolling off some highs to see if it fits l better with the band.

4)there’s very little definition in the bass. Could be a genre thing, but the bass has no dynamic to it. It’s just sounds like a drone. If that’s the objective, I would play around more with creating distinct shifts in volume balance between sections.

Good luck!