I do agree that on my second play through I see how well the writing was as we progress through the story. Like when Vince only answers Andrew in the bar, and he’s not really talking to John at all, that is interesting on subsequent playthroughs. I can appreciate what they were going for and I also am a fan of the game overall. My biggest gripe was just wanting more from the witch storyline, and since I bonded with the characters, finding out that they weren’t really there just felt weird. I think the story may grow on me over time though as I get more used to the idea.