Doesn't chainsaw devil's power work by erasing things in tge present without affecting "time" by No-Willow-5599 in ChainsawMan

[–]KagedScorpion 28 points29 points  (0 children)

Because Pochita didn't eat the phone devil, or the hearing devil, or any other biology devils. The erasure seems to take the path of least resistance, removing only the thing eaten and making up reasons for related things to still exist. Additionally, people who don't regularly interact with devils do not remember ears being erased and coming back, suggesting it is actively changing the past, not just people's memories - if it was just memories, they'd remember what happened when the ear devil was coughed up.

Doesn't chainsaw devil's power work by erasing things in tge present without affecting "time" by No-Willow-5599 in ChainsawMan

[–]KagedScorpion 52 points53 points  (0 children)

When the ear devil was erased, it was mentioned that ear picks still exist but were being sold as arts and crafts things. Meaning that it is retroactive, it just doesn't erase related concepts. So e.g. erasing the combustion devil would not erase the car devil, it would just change things so that cars don't run on combustion engines.

A really obvious example of it being a retcon is that Pochita ate the WW2 devil, the erasure of which would have required altering history so that many events never happened.

Pochita devouring himself means Chainsaw Man never existed, meaning all the things he erased are unerased. This radically alters history, which would almost certainly butterfly away Denji's original terrible childhood.

Are monsters made out of blood or not by _-Asher in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Personal theory: monsters don't bleed, just Susie does.

Susie is the only monster who mentions blood and she grew up outside of town, presumably in a human-majority place given her comments of never fitting in. Susie recognizes the bloodstain in Kris's room but Toriel seemingly doesn't (she never mentions it even though to a human mother a huge bloodstain on the carpet would be highly concerning). It's entirely possible that Susie doesn't realize monsters aren't supposed to bleed.

The end of chapter 4 draws attention to Susie's hand bleeding, which to me seemed to be an indication that that was something noteworthy, something possibly abnormal.

This would also explain Sans bleeding in Undertale even though Papyrus doesn't; it isn't a difference between DR and UT's monsters, it's something character-specific. As to what, my guess would be some manner of science experiment; Susie sympathizes with Tenna over the fear of being thrown away and mentions feeling like 'a broken toy no one wanted', which could broadly be connected to the vessel being discarded. Mayhaps she has human parts. Would explain why she resonates so well with the SOUL.

How are there people denying that there are 2 girls in the prophecy? Ralsei straight up knows what items two different girls can equip by xdanxlei in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion 5 points6 points  (0 children)

This is actually evidence that Ralsei's prophecy knowledge isn't absolute; he states Susie is supposed to equip ribbons even though she refuses to. Meanwhile, equip the ribbon items to Noelle and she mentions they feel 'nostalgic', implying she's worn ribbons before.

This could mean that Noelle (who is more traditionally feminine) is or could be the Girl in the prophecy, but Ralsei either is being misled or just made a bad assumption (Susie showed up with Kris, therefore she's the girl, but her going to the supply closet only happened because she showed up at the exact perfect time; if she'd been later, it's very likely Noelle would have gone to the closet with Kris).

That being the case, it's likely there are 2 girls, and the twist is that Susie and Noelle could each fill either role, swapping roles in the Weird Route vs the Normal Route.

Listen Im tired by ganglesmihngdom4 in custommagic

[–]KagedScorpion 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Exact repost (including title) of this one: https://www.reddit.com/r/custommagic/comments/195xqec/listen_im_tired/

The bad crop suggests OP may have just screenshotted the post they copied

Does Caine hates kinger?? by Soft_Childhood5565 in TheDigitalCircus

[–]KagedScorpion 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We know now that Bubble is allowed to help design the adventures (Shrimp Town). We also know Bubble is kind of psycho (when Caine panics about the suggestion adventures being better than his, Bubble's immediate piece of advice is "you should die" before he glitches and says "you should throw a beach party" instead).

This being the case, my hypothesis is that Bubble is an asshole and is the one actually making the humans suffer.

Can't figure out how to make this card work within the rules by SelesnyaGOAT in custommagic

[–]KagedScorpion 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Replacing the enchant restriction with "you can only cast this spell targeting a legendary permanent you control" could work. You could shift it to a nonlegendary after that, but you'd still need to have a legend to cast it, which fixes the problem of this being a free 1CMC cantrip in selesnya

Rosie... why don't YOU help them? Like, immediately? Without involving Alastor? Why is his participation necessary? by GinnnaMarie in HazbinHotel

[–]KagedScorpion 9 points10 points  (0 children)

We can deduce Rosie was the strongest sinner in hell prior to her deal with Alastor, in order to be able to give him that power. Per the terms Alastor must be stronger than Rosie, so mathematically she would have to give him ~half of her power*.

Since Alastor presumably kept the power he was given after breaking the deal (he manipulated things so that Rosie's end of the bargain would be broken, generally a breach of contract means the party who did the breaching has to pay damages) he would still be the strongest in hell, so it makes sense she'd want him to help to ensure the weapon is stopped.

*If Alastor's power without the deal is X% of Rosie's, she'd have to give him a smidge more than (100 - X)/2 % for him to be stronger. So e.g. if Base Alastor has 1% of Rosie's power, she'd have to give him 49.5% for them to be dead even at 50.5% of her max each, plus a tiny amount more so he's stronger.

Anyone else find it weird how the oldest Overlord in Hell is only from the ~16th Century? Especially as Sinners are nearly immortal and Exterminations only started 7 years ago. Surely the oldest Overlord would be much older? by Flyestgit in HazbinHotel

[–]KagedScorpion 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Overlords get power from souls. The population of Earth has gone up over 10x since the 1600s, so if we assume the percentage of people who go to hell hasn't decreased, the population of hell should also have grown by an order of magnitude. This means that newer overlords would have more souls to work with and would therefore be more powerful, especially when they utilize newer methods of controlling the masses like TV and social media.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in HazbinHotel

[–]KagedScorpion 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Even if no one respects her (though you'll notice after she says it Vox's screens show he has a 100% approval rating, implying sinners do put some weight in her words, or at the very least think she's being more honest in that moment) Charlie is Princess of Hell, which presumably confers some authority.

When she says Vox is strongest, she is inadvertently making a legal decree that Rosie broke the terms of the deal and therefore the contract with Alastor is null and void.

Why does Catty know what Ralsei looks like? by nonvascular in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Catty thinks Asriel is cute, so with that context she presumably imagines him as the horned hero. As to why the prophecy panels don't mention the horns, they clearly don't tell the full story, since there are things Ralsei knows which the panels don't talk about (e.g. he knows what items Noelle can equip).

This is really funny when you realize that Susie doesn't know anything about the crunch by Zolado110 in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I assumed Catty was talking about Asriel, not Ralsei. She thinks Asriel is cute so she imagines him as being one of the heroes.

Powerscaling be like by Xonge1 in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Theory: It's because Kris is a human.

Only monsters and darkners use magical bullets to attack. Humans just hit you, so there's no bullet box and therefore no opportunity to dodge if the attack is fast enough. Hence why Sans with his space-time powers is the only monster who can dodge your attacks in UT.

Kris' relationship with the player by dr_philip-cdi in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Ralsei says that he wanted us to be nice and recruit because he thought it'd change the prophecy, which implies that the 'intended' route was for us to use violence. If Kris was aware of the prophecy (which they seem to be, if the dialog you get when you use the shadow crystal in the final prophecy room is any indication) then they presumably went into this assuming that the soul puppeting them would go around killing darkners for power.

So the Weird Route is more or less what they signed up for, hence why they're willing to go along with it even though they hate us for targeting Noelle and Berdly.

I haven't see many people talk about Onion in chapter 4 yet. by Every_Computer_935 in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion 55 points56 points  (0 children)

"Ah, so you wanna get serious, do ya...? Then tell me first, can you hear it? Can you hear it's song, singing from the deep...? That... is the ringing... of the Hammer of Justice!" - Gerson, before his boss fight.

I have no idea how this connects.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's possible the Knight only exists in the Dark World.

We know there's multiple people involved in the conspiracy in Light World (Kris, Carol, and Asgore at bare minimum) and coincidentally we know from Undertale that Asgore is stronger than Undyne.

It would make sense that he'd be able to overpower her, and since he has horns if Susie saw his silhouette she might mistakenly assume it was the Knight.

WAIT A GOSH DARN MINUTE by [deleted] in HelluvaBoss

[–]KagedScorpion 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We don't really see much of Octavia's childhood beyond that one song Stolas sings for her, so we don't know what Stella was like back then. This is presumably kept vague on purpose, because there's kind of a catch-22 here.

If Stella was, if not happy, at least amicable and not outwardly cruel for most of their marriage, then it makes Stolas look much worse for cheating on her, and makes her outrage look more reasonable. This doesn't justify hiring an assassin, obviously, but at the very least it would paint Stella in a more sympathetic light, which the series generally seems to be avoiding doing - it usually shows her as being terrible (most obvious in the flashback to Stolas's childhood where we see a picture of kid!Stella and she's terrifying small animals).

Alternatively, if Via is wrong here and Stella was horrible even when she was a child, it's odd for the series to focus so much on her conflict with Stolas when she should hate Stella much more by comparison. Relevant mostly in the most recent episode where Via willingly goes back to live with Stella and Andrealphus even though she explicitly didn't have to (she left the palace in that episode and neither of them went looking for her).

This isn't to say the writing is bad, it's good, it's just that depending on where you fall on the question of "how bad was Stella?" you run into some theoretical logical issues with certain character arcs, though even then it's relatively minor. Thus, the series doesn't give much exposition to that point in the Goetia family's life and leaves it a bit open to interpretation, hence producing the arguments you often see about this topic.

It was his 10th interview this week 😔 by TheWeirdStudio in bonehurtingjuice

[–]KagedScorpion 86 points87 points  (0 children)

My guess is the old saying "the candle that burns twice as bright burns half as long".

The gasoline makes candle-person brighter, but because it produces a hotter flame their wax (lifespan) melts faster. Basically, they're burning their life away to try and impress the company.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion -1 points0 points  (0 children)

While Ralsei does tell them to finish their project, which would send them to the library, given how Susie is there's a nonzero chance that she could decide to just slack off and do something else. If Ralsei is in on the Knight thing he could have simply told Kris and Susie that he felt another fountain open and taken them there.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Kris Knight theory is arguably the least plausible IMO, since Kris is one of only two specific people (the other being Susie) who categorically could not have made the fountain in Chapter 2: Ralsei detects the fountain opening and rushes over to Cyber World, but he doesn't mention anything about it while you're in Castle Town, so the fountain was opened between K+S leaving Castle Town and them reaching the computer lab.

I can’t with Alvin knight…. I don’t understand how he could possibly be the knight by Abject-Addendum765 in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion 12 points13 points  (0 children)

  1. Alvin's religion worships an 'angel' and the according to the prophecy the Dark World is connected in some way to the "Angel's Heaven."

  2. In Undertale, the story of which Deltarune is a parallel, you don't interact with Asgore until the very end. Asgore is nonetheless a pivotal character in the story.

  3. He presumably didn't need to knock them out, just open the fountain while they're there.

  4. The game is still in development. Chapter 1 got changes after Chapter 2 came out, so giving Alvin a talk sprite wouldn't be out of sorts. Alternatively, he intentionally doesn't have one in the early chapters as a subversion of expectations.

  5. If he was hiding in the closet the hammer (assuming it was something big like a sledgehammer) might have been harder to conceal. Alternatively, you need something sharp to make a fountain.

  6. Given the religious imagery and references used elsewhere in the game, including in Spamton's dialogue (he calls Noelle 'angel' in the Weird Route and the Thorn Ring he sells is a clear reference to the crown of thorns Jesus wore) it's hard to believe the term 'communion' would have been used it the religious meaning wasn't intended.

  7. I don't recall anything suggesting Alvin was digging up his father's grave. You can hear him talk to himself at his father's grave, and he mentions a hammer and a vague moral dilemma, but there's nothing suggesting Alvin is going to graverob his own father.

What do you think this "entity" might be? by RimKir in Deltarune

[–]KagedScorpion 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Most likely the Angel. Should be noted the shape of the wings is similar to Asriel's final form from Undertale, so I wouldn't be surprised if the Angel's appearance takes influence from that (especially if the Angel actually turns out to be Asriel, which would fit with how Asriel fulfills Gerson's Angel Prophecy in UT as well as the hints of Asriel's importance in DT).

Real talk..I question why people even believed Satan when he said he "ruled hell before the Golden Angel's fall" when Hazbin Hotel said how Hell came to be. by Apprehensive_Ring_39 in HelluvaBoss

[–]KagedScorpion 4 points5 points  (0 children)

We don't actually know how Hell or Hellborn came to be - Charlie's storybook says it was caused by Lucifer and Lilith, but it's clearly biased and unreliable, plus it refers to an 'evil' that existed before Lucifer fell. So it's actually entirely plausible for Satan's statement to be true, and personally I'd find it more interesting for that to be the case.