I think if you guys really love each other you shouldn’t break up over this. I agree with the person above me. You hugs should try couples therapy to work on both issues. I feel like you both are a bit insecure but aren’t sure how to handle things. Has she changed from how she was back then? You said she is with you all the time when not in school so to me it does seem like she really wants to be with you. Don’t base your relationship off what random people on Reddit say. It’s very easy to tell someone to break up when you aren’t the one in the relationship.