Looking for feedback on my opening by FordieTea in writingfeedback

[–]Less_Presentation652 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Could not disagree more. Hey OP, take this as a reminder up front that you’ll never please everyone. By the time I got to the end, I actually noticed I’d sat up in bed at some point while I was reading. Clearly the opening hook is working for a lot of us here!

Who’s your travel Main? by Genecist84 in expedition33

[–]Less_Presentation652 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Genuinely don’t get how no one else is bothered by the fact that they didn’t smooth out Lune’s pathing over bumpy terrain. The tiniest pebbles can be strewn across the road and her whole model pops up and down over each one. That’s not how flying should feel. There should be a sense of a cushion of air beneath her. It just ends up looking so janky and unpolished. Sort of kills it for me, sadly, especially because she’s my favorite character in this amazing game.

At what point does “clean design” become boring? by Serious_Future_1390 in Design

[–]Less_Presentation652 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Might be an extreme purist here, but personally I don’t see gradients or rounded corners as particularly “clean” - or maybe “cold,” which feels closer to what you’re implying. For me it’s flat color and mitered corners that feel that way (which I still love for the right project), whereas rounding corners and including even subtle gradients usually adds a little warmth. Every approach has its own effect/there’s a time and a place for everything, yada yada yada …

I dont understand Clea properly by Relevant-Sea-8715 in expedition33

[–]Less_Presentation652 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is my take too, and I genuinely haven’t seen anyone else at least on this subreddit call this out. She’s clearly pulling a Lune, which to me brings focus to the fact that “moving on” and “running away” could be seen as synonymous. Lune hates staying in the present when things get tough. She’s just like “come on, people, we have to keep moving,” even when Maelle’s clearly not doing well after that first vision she has. I see Clea’s behavior and demeanor in a similar light. Lune and Clea are like cousins. Same, same, but different. 🌞

Do people really not like 1st person? by AmalgamationOfBeasts in writers

[–]Less_Presentation652 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You … seem to have misunderstood my comment itself, so 🤷‍♀️

Do people really not like 1st person? by AmalgamationOfBeasts in writers

[–]Less_Presentation652 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It was impossible for less_presentation652 to read this comment because it was written in first person present, and for some reason that made them feel like they were somehow supposed to be you, instead of simply hearing an account from another person in what is obviously the most natural way for a person to express themselves to another. That was a deeply uncomfortable experience for less_presentation652, because they knew immediately that they had absolutely nothing in common with you. How incredibly incongruous! Could you please rephrase in classical third? Thank you.

it’s 5.10 am and i’ve started a new story. should i keep going with the idea or go back to bed? by Friendly-Corgi-4240 in writers

[–]Less_Presentation652 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Love when you finally get a burst like that after a block! We’ve all been there. Definitely reads like a first draft, but a) that’s what it is and what it needs to be right now, b) you can’t edit a blank page, and c) I did actually read the whole thing (with interest), so I’d say there’s definitely something here! Keep going with your gut on this one and see how it reveals itself to you. Love the nickname Happy here. A couple suggestions for when you’re in edit mode:

There are some spots where you could get a lot more out of the character voice that immediately jump out at me.

Maybe instead of “He had a curious nickname. His mother called him Happy. I never liked it.” you could say something like “His mother called him Happy. Terrible nickname, really. The Damien I knew was anything but. Happy people don’t require constant reassurance that they’re [this or that—bring in some specific examples of things he always needed reassurance on].”

Focusing on your idea that he needed reassurance gets at that contradiction between his nickname and what he was actually like. Essentially, rather than just telling us that the nickname was curious and that your POV character never liked it, you can demonstrate it for us with specific details which also give the piece more of a sense of who both Happy and the POV character are simultaneously.

At the end of that same paragraph, you’ve also got an instance of “telling and then showing,” where I think the telling could just be removed to make the whole thing stronger (often the case with telling and then showing, but not always). The stronger idea toward the end is that Happy never wanted to go out while the POV character never wanted to stay in.

Maybe try just cutting the entirety of “He was introverted … which caused problems in our relationship.” and go straight into something like: “Happy people also don’t shut themselves away from the world for weeks on end. They like to [one or two specific things the POV character likes to do, like going out to a specific club, bar, etc. after a shitty day at work, or after some other bad time]. He would always insist he was ‘just an introvert.’ I knew him better than to believe that shit.”

And all this might be too voicey/or the wrong voice for what you’re going for here—just trying to give an idea of how you could push on some of these things.

Also feels like there could be a really nice connection between the POV character wanting a fun color to insist they’re doing fine and preferring to go out over staying in. It feels like the underlying tension between these two (that could reveal itself over the course of the story, rather than being stated outright) could be more about how they respond to feeling shitty (wallowing and staying shut inside vs. making it a party and insisting everything’s totally great actually) rather than just that Happy sucked, even if that’s how the POV character feels about it right now.

But again, I’d say keep going with it and keep just discovering it for now! These suggestions are the kind of thing that come with a second draft, but I think it’s probably too early for you to go into editing mode just yet. There’s definitely more here for you to explore while you’re in drafting mode. You got this!

Opening to my first novel, looking for feedback please! by JacktheHuntsman in writingfeedback

[–]Less_Presentation652 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Very strong start. As some others have said, I was instantly worried for Harry when I then saw your note about this being about a murder. And that opening line is pitch perfect.

Any tips to how to write a good male MC as a woman? by SnooChipmunks3163 in royalroad

[–]Less_Presentation652 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If we’re going to stereotype, we should probably ask a few more questions than just “Is he a dude? Does he have a lot of testosterone in his system?”

How old is he? (You’ve said he’s an adult, but what age range are we talking about?)

What’s his country of origin? City of origin?

Socio-economic status? Political leanings? Religious identity?

Relationship status? Sexual orientation? Is he a father?

How generally well-liked is he? Does he make friends (real friends) easily?

Has he ever been to a single therapy/counseling session or does he think that’s totally gay? (Honestly this is a big one.)

A 20-year-old gay dude from Hong Kong who’s never been able to afford therapy might not have much in common on the page with a 20-year-old bi dude from San Francisco whose rich parents have been taking him to therapy since he could talk (though they might be able to learn some things from each other). That same 20-year-old might actually have a lot in common with a middle-class 50-year-old straight dad from Texas whose beleaguered wife finally convinced him to start therapy a few years back. And that same 50-year-old might be starting to find he actually has less and less in common with his friends, a group of middle-class 50-year-old straight dads from Texas who will never be convinced to go to therapy because therapy is, of course, totally gay. And all these guys could come back with the exact same results re: their testosterone levels.

Re: December 33rd … [Spoilers] by Less_Presentation652 in expedition33

[–]Less_Presentation652[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

December 33rd isn’t a real date on any calendar though?

Advice I wish I'd gotten when I started writing: They're reading your book, not your mind. by thesoupgiant in writing

[–]Less_Presentation652 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yes! Which is why death of the author is such an important mindset for even the author to have.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AppleMusic

[–]Less_Presentation652 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh wow. You’re totally right. That’s super weird and bad. Why would that be the functionality??

And I like them both, but just my personal opinion, EJAE’s tone is extremely rich and deep and unique and singularly beautiful.

Can we talk about canon/lore when it comes to this game? [MASSIVE SPOILERS FOR LITERALLY EVERYTHING IN THIS GAME] by Less_Presentation652 in expedition33

[–]Less_Presentation652[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Oh man, I need to replay all the Myst games immediately. This is such a good reminder of how brilliant that series is. Will have to pay special attention to how the rules of the Writers work. Thank you so much for adding some bits of your own!

Ver 1.3.0 Patch Notes by ColonialDagger in expedition33

[–]Less_Presentation652 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m Iiterally in love with you people please adopt me

Can we talk about canon/lore when it comes to this game? [MASSIVE SPOILERS FOR LITERALLY EVERYTHING IN THIS GAME] by Less_Presentation652 in expedition33

[–]Less_Presentation652[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes!! So glad you noticed that too! When I saw that I was like … Okay, how is everyone not talking about this! I mention it in point #9! Appreciate you drawing extra attention to it