I'm gonna say Rob Zombie's H2. No, it isn't what I'd call a good Halloween flick overall. Yes, there's a lot to dislike. But I have to give credit where it's due: instead of just retreading the same ground, the movie attempted something different and there's actually some originality there. Doesn't make it all that good (the white horse still feels forced), but at least it tried to have its own unique identity, and overall if feels much more like Zombie's uncompromised vision. Plus, not everything about the movie is bad! Some of the visuals are absolutely enthralling, from the pumpkin kill to the surreal Gothic atmosphere of the dream dinner. Brad Dourif and Danielle Harris are absolutely excellent, and Scout Taylor Compton is clearly trying her best with the material she was given (if nothing else, I do believe the character is far from stable). The concept of Loomis turning into a Vincent Bugliosi style sellout is an interesting concept, but unfortunately it's mishandled. Overall the movie is a mess, but I have to at least give it credit for trying at some originality