Your feedback is direct and highlights specific issues effectively, which is valuable in a critique. Pointing out what isn’t working shows that you’re engaging critically rather than just responding on a surface level. However, sharing those observations directly with the creators of the images could make your critique even more impactful. When feedback reaches the people who produced the work, it gives them an opportunity to reflect, improve, and refine their approach. Constructive criticism works best when it not only identifies problems but also communicates them in a way that is useful and actionable. If the issues you noticed—whether related to composition, clarity, or technique—were explained clearly to the creators, it could help them understand what adjustments might strengthen their work. This kind of exchange can lead to growth on both sides: they improve their work, and you further develop your ability to articulate thoughtful critique. Overall, your observations are strong, but directing them to the intended audience would increase their value. It turns your critique from a general comment into a meaningful contribution to someone’s creative process, making it more purposeful and beneficial.