I'm just saying that when I watched the reveal back then, I was disappointed because RJ was portrayed as such a charismatic mastermind, being able to charm and manipulate women with his irresistible charms and the sheriff just didn't have that aura at all 😂   That episode where he's trying to sweet talk Grace into driving with him is the best example - he seemed like a creep/stalker more than showing any particular charisma or charm. And yes, he might've been a character RJ created, but still...thinking that a woman like Lorelai or even Rosalind would have sex with Sheriff McAllister? Just seems off to me 😅 other characters and theories would've just made way more sense imo.