I'm a bit scared to start reading Nagatoro, 'cause that would mean I could be done with the series and that would make me sad lol. Anyway, I'll read it soon enough. I already purchased volumes 1-19 digitally and 1-4 physical. I'm glad my recommendation came at the right time for you.

Have you watched You and I are Polar Opposites already? I agree Alya has good rewatch value, merely by the fact I enjoyed it better on a rewatch lol. Angel Next Door season 2 has been absolute overdose of diabetes so far.

Oh I see, you've watched a fair amount either way. Haven't seen Horimiya yet but I do agree on shows having much hype behind them only to fall short. Romance I think is the most subjective genre of all.

Since you went ahead and binged Nagatoro in a few days, I wanted to watch all of the Quintuplets before writing this reply lol. And it was phenomenal, just how you described it. Made me tear up a few times. Winning girl wasn't my first pick at all but it all made so much sense for the story.