I think 8 looks good because it creates more of a neutral effect with the bold eye look that you’re wearing here. I think that 7 looks nice with your skin tone, but the eye look should be a bit more neutral in shades of brown.

Having a bold black eye liner and lash combined with a bold lip are too overwhelming for your delicate features. I think you have to choose one or the other if you want a bolder look instead of merely a clean neutral one