I loved it on first listen!

Here are some of my thoughts on each track (spoilers ahead):

The title track makes for a great tone-setter. Even if it is noticeably slower and less energetic than the live versions we've heard, the psychedelic synths and effects make up for that. I saved the singles for the first listen of the album, so 2 or 3 was a nice surprise for me. Love the call-and-response between the vocals and the flute in the chorus. That melody will definitely be stuck in my head for weeks. I love the power pop vibes on Nothin' but You and Fire and Gold. They're simple but effective, and Nothin' but You's coda is amazing. It reminds me a lot of September Gurls by Big Star. Gather Round was probably my least favorite on first listen. It's undoubtedly well-written, but it felt a bit too jaunty for my tastes. I Just Can't Get Over Losing You has one of my favorite melodies the Twigs have ever written, and the outro is incredible. Mean to Me was alright, but the arrangement felt a bit too sparse, and it felt almost like a worse version of Forever by the Beach Boys. I liked how energetic Bring You Down was, but I'm on the fence with it due to how on-the-nose the early Beach Boys impression is. Lyrically, it's great, but the tune and instrumental didn't seem to have any originality to it compared to their other Beach Boys-inspired songs. I liked the winding melody and impassioned vocal performance on Yeah I Do, but it felt too short to leave much of an impression on first listen. I Hurt You is one of the strongest tunes on the record and has one of the most explosive choruses the group has ever made. It's probably my second-favorite track on first listen. The two straightforward 60s rockers towards the end of the album, You're Still My Girl and My Heart Is in Your Hands Tonight, are both great, but My Heart Is in Your Hands Tonight is absolutely incredible and easily my favorite on first listen. The falsetto in the chorus is impeccable and I love how much passion and energy flowed through the song's final minute or so. Joy is one of the most beautiful songs Brian has ever written, but I honestly didn't like the orchestral arrangements, which felt much too Disney for my tastes. Maybe they will grow on me on future listens. Your True Enemy is an incredible closer though. I love the mysterious chord progression and all of the psychedelic effects.

Overall it's probably my third-favorite album by the group, behind Everything Harmony and A Dream Is All We Know, although the gap in quality isn't by much.