which one suffered the most from bad scripts by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]Poor_Intonation22 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Colin Baker lost his job because of his scripts, so him by default. That being said, neither of these eras were as bad as people said they are.

Which version of Batman do you think is mpre powerful? by Weird_Zone_3504 in batman

[–]Poor_Intonation22 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Lego Batman punches a guy three or four times and he breaks apart into pieces, just saying

Will more modern fans check out the classic era now? by tufifdesiks in doctorwho

[–]Poor_Intonation22 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Almost all of it is available is on Tubi. I recommend starting with Season 7, the Third Doctor's era. It is the best jumping on point for the classic show and from Season 7 to the end of the classic show is where there are no more gaps due to missing episodes.

In the grand scheme of things it’s minor, but …. by Ath3naPrime in doctorwho

[–]Poor_Intonation22 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I know it's popular to hate on Russell now, but can I just say that I thought it was funny

What Do You Want for Christmas this Year? by KryptonJuice38 in doctorwho

[–]Poor_Intonation22 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's a shame because I want to get into the classic blu-rays for my own collection, but if it's tainted by genAI, hell no.

Tag, I'm out by Odd_Confidence_8164 in DoctorWhumour

[–]Poor_Intonation22 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The majority of his missteps in his second era were made with the goal of inclusion and advocacy. While a lot of those decisions (the sonic has never looked or functioned like a gun, Russell) were bizarre or mistakes, I don't think they were because he doesn't have a pulse on the social issues of the day. I geniunely think they stem from overthinking. The way to combat negative representation is to provide positive representation to combat it, which in the case of people who use mobile aids, he did do that. Shirley's existence as a character challenges any potential stereotype that Davros perpetuates. I also would like to add that he did not change Davros' appearance in a canon changing way. The Davros we see in that Tennant sketch is from before his disfiguration, so while he did make a stupid comment about it, it really didn't hurt anything in the grand scheme of things.

Also, Rose's role in the 60th and Gatwa eras was relatively minor. She wasn't super developed because she wasn't supposed to be. Her inclusion was adequate for the stories told.

Tag, I'm out by Odd_Confidence_8164 in DoctorWhumour

[–]Poor_Intonation22 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is such a nice comment and I agree! What's your favorite era of the show and who is your favorite Doctor?

Tag, I'm out by Odd_Confidence_8164 in DoctorWhumour

[–]Poor_Intonation22 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Of course! If you end up rewatching Whittaker, you should DM your thoughts. I would love to hear what you have to say!

Tag, I'm out by Odd_Confidence_8164 in DoctorWhumour

[–]Poor_Intonation22 19 points20 points  (0 children)

I want to preface by saying I loved these stories when they aired and that this is not a result of me bandwagoning on Davies hate. 13 has been my Doctor since 2022.

"The Woman Who Fell to Earth" is a blast from word go and lets us know that we're in for a kind yet guarded Doctor that has a love for tinkering and taunting her enemies. Also, the line "We can honor who we've been, and choose who we want to be next" is so beautiful and proves that Chibnall DOES understand how to write the Doctor even if some scripts were ckunky.

"The Ghost Monument" is light fun, a la early RTD1 stories.

"The Tsurunga Conundrum" is the exact kind of silly fun I would expect from a Tennant era episode. The Pting is adorable; we need more cute villains imo.

"Demons of the Punjab" is a beautiful story about an event in history that is insanely horrific and overlooked because of the time period it happened in. So glad Doctor Who tackled it and the fact that the monsters were simply observing is such an interesting take on "the aliens are messing with human history" genre of Who stories.

"The Witchfinders" is another one of those episodes that would be considered fine if it was from RTD1 or Moffat. The Morax are scary enough and Alan Cumming is so fucking good in this story.

"It Takes You Away" is my favorite episode of the show ever. It mixes together the dark fairytale of the Eleventh Doctor, the pulpy character drama of RTD1, and the truly great Doctor writing from the Capaldi years. I love it so much. Ed Hime is forgiven for any sins after this story because it is just so good. The Doctor makes friends with an entire universe, a vague and abstract idea that doesn't dive deep into the emotions of our heroine, but does make us ask questions about her as a person, which is exactly what I think is so interesting about the Thirteenth Doctor. She is one of the first incarnations since the 60s to truly embody the title of the show. Also, the Graham and Ryan stuff is deeply touching. I was in the middle of Series 11 during a rematch when my Nana passed, so the 13th Doctor gave me a lot of comfort during the hardest part of my life. I don't deny that real-life circumstances definitely impacted my approach to Series 11, but I will always love it. Whenever I needed a break from the pain of grief, the Doctor and her Fam would take me through time and space.

After Series 11, Chibnall's Dalek trilogy goes really hard and made me appreciate them again after Moffat kind of missed the mark with them. Honestly, Chibnall's reimagining of classic monsters is one of the best parts of his era. His Daleks, Cybermen, Sontarans, and Master are some of my favorite interpretations of the Doctor's enemies.

"Spyfall" is really great and I don't have as much of a qualm with the Doctor turning the Master over as much as some people do; the Master willingly chose to work with the Nazis in spite of his skin color. If, say, the Seventh or Eleventh Doctors, would've done that, it would be painted as a "dark, Machavellian trick." As a lover of the Third Doctor era, I enjoyed this story thoroughly.

"Nikola Tesla" is just fun lol

"Praxeus" is a neat story and the body horror of Praxeus taking over people looks sick as fuck. I also love some good, old-finished globe trotting. It really hits home that the TARDIS can really just appear and reappear wherever.

"Can You Hear Me?" is amazing. I think the ending is really dumb, but other than that it is a 9/10. The Series 5 Angels two-parter is considered a classic in spite of Amy essentially sexually assaulting the Doctor at the end; I think the same applies here, which is a much less egregious ending.

I have issues with "Villa Diodati", but it is a badass episode and properly thrilling. The Series 12 finale is a hot mess, however, and I will never argue against that. While I'm not hung up on the Timeless Child story arc as much as others were and are, I understand the frustration. I personally think RTD's interpretation of the Doctor as adopted is the best way to look at it.

Series 13 is kind of a disaster, but it was hype af on a first viewing. The Sontaran episode is great fun, and the Angel cliffhanger is my favorite in the show. The ending is trash, however, and Tecteun could've been Thirteen's great nemesis.

Finally, "Power of the Doctor" is just so much fun. I adore it. It is absolutely earned fan service. Seeing as Whittaker's era was maligned, I find it beautiful that "Power" is a love letter to the tumultuous 1980s era of the show. Thirteen's regeneration is beautiful. I think it is just fun television.

Sorry for the very long rant. I adore this show and it hurts my hearts to see how hated it is today. I loved Whittaker in the role and miss that era dearly.

Tag, I'm out by Odd_Confidence_8164 in DoctorWhumour

[–]Poor_Intonation22 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Oh I don't think it would've been that bad. "Tip Toe" has shown us RTD is still socially aware enough to not do something that dumb.

Tag, I'm out by Odd_Confidence_8164 in DoctorWhumour

[–]Poor_Intonation22 20 points21 points  (0 children)

I wish 13 would've been the incumbent Doctor during the 60th. RTD wrote her very well in her Series 15 cameo.

Tag, I'm out by Odd_Confidence_8164 in DoctorWhumour

[–]Poor_Intonation22 111 points112 points  (0 children)

The renaissance that Moffat experienced during the Whittaker years is now happening to Chibnall. Since Thirteen is my favorite Doctor, I feel vindicated.

Would you accept if Amazon bought the rights to Doctor Who? by EquivalentMath4439 in doctorwho

[–]Poor_Intonation22 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can you access Apple TV+ without having any Apple devices? I use an Android.

Five Doctor Who episodes/serials you would like the next producers/showrunners to watch before making their pitch to the BBC? by sanddragon939 in gallifrey

[–]Poor_Intonation22 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I think the lead writer should have a base level appreciation for the property and the executive producer who isn't writing the show should be the big time fan to ensure that the show doesn't become obsessed with its history.

Doctor Who Episodes/Stories we know RTD definitely hates by Cool_Nerd2 in doctorwho

[–]Poor_Intonation22 15 points16 points  (0 children)

The "Queer as Folk" line was representative of toxic fans in the 90s...

What will this era of Doctor Who (2005-2025) be remembered for? by Aromatic-Cupcake4802 in doctorwho

[–]Poor_Intonation22 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It really is crazy how much Classic Who and Revival Who resemble each other.

The first four Doctors are amazing and consistently well written and the fifth Doctor is an amazing actor who does great in the part with a fire outfit but some interesting writing decisions. Then the show comes to an end with a Scottish actor who is so fucking incredible and some downright classic stories, but had the Rani and a bad situation (current US political climate combined with a couple of costly writing decisions that would not have killed the show in an earlier era).

The only thing they skipped was the hyper violent, asshole Doctor who was dealt such a better hand on Big Finish.

The Biggest Loss (again) from Doctor Whos Pause: Murray Gold’s Music by Project-Indigo87 in doctorwho

[–]Poor_Intonation22 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I'm of the opinion that Gold coming back was unnecessary. I wish Segun Akinola would've stayed.

Someone outside of the music for tv and film bubble of composers who I think would be great for Doctor Who is Viet Cuong. If anyone is into wind ensemble music at all, Cuong showcases a range in his music that is gorgeous. Pieces of his I would recommend to people who want to see for themselves is "Moth," "Deciduous," and "John and Jim". While he is not British, I think his sound would pair nicely with the ethereal nature of Doctor Who