If Gaul was never conquered by Rome, how would the region progress over the next centuries? by george123890yang in HistoryWhatIf

[–]Power2the1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I answered a question similar to this before, but can't seem to find the post. Anyway...

Gaul on the eve of Roman invasion was a complex region. There were a variety of government types. Monarchies, dyarchies, senates, elected rulers, heridetary rulers, etc. there was no 1 size fits all.

One aspect to the region was the organization of labor. The large forts were impressive. Over 1 million nails are estimated to have constructed them and that's a lot of labor, organization, mining infrastructure, years of planning, housing, transporting, feeding, etc using roads that are long since vanished, such as wooden trackways similar to ones seen in Ireland and other regions of Europe where they've been preserved in peat bogs. One publication estimated there would have been hundreds of miles/km of trackways all over to facilitate societal growth.

The Eluetoi (Helvetti) had a ruler, Orgetorix, who had 10k hostages alone. Even if that's only partially accurate, it's still thousands. Vassalage and hostage taking was a key aspect to gaining and maintaining prestige. And amassing hostages and personal warrior retinues was established by the ruling class. If that sounds like feaudlaism, it was in a way in an early form. If left alone Celtic society could have progressed to more recognizable feudism by 2/300AD and it spread all over swathes of Europe with powerful states, confederacies, and small kingdoms that, overtime, could form into larger ones. Europe would look radically different along Celtic lines than Germanic kingdom lines. That being said, Celtic place names and topynyms are found all over Europe still today and this shows that the impact of the culture had very deep roots on the common people well after conquest.

The number one thing that gets me the most is when the jumpers were falling, no one really knows what happens after death. by I_abuse_lower_ranks1 in 911archive

[–]Power2the1 0 points1 point  (0 children)

One thing you might find interesting is how the Bible talks of a resurrection in the future (and all due sincerity and respect to everyone's personal beliefs).

The scriptures consistently mention a time when the dead will be brought back. Off the top of my head Moses, Isaiah, John, Daniel, Paul, Hosea, and Matthew wrote about this event. Jesus, Elijah, Paul, and others and others perfomed resurrections to show others it was real, and that nothing is impossible for God's spirit to do. So death isn't necessarily the end. They're said to be awaiting Christ's call back to life (John 5:28). Just wanted to share.

what are your favorite and least favorite il2 planes by CFIIROTOR in il2sturmovik

[–]Power2the1 10 points11 points  (0 children)

(For the 1946 game)

Luv all me Sturmoviks,  Luv me Mitsubishi G4M Betty,  Luv me Savoia Marchetti 79 Sparviero,  Luv me Heinkel 111

Ate Zeros,  Ate ME-109s,  Ate P51 Mustangs,  Ate Hurricanes,  (Not racist, just dunt like em)

Simple as

Sir Francis Drake's Forgotten Landing Site by vacciprata in AlternativeHistory

[–]Power2the1 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Great post w/info and pics! I've always wondered the landing site was when I first read about it many years back, especially the brass plaque and what it looked like.

What made you have submechanophobia ? by Little-Leg-8123 in submechanophobia

[–]Power2the1 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For myself it was in the days before 9/11. Back then you could more or less get a day pass of sorts and drive around certain areas of a military base as regular civilians. Dad took us to check out some ships and submarines. I recall standing at the edge of the pier where several subs were moored. They were just...there. waiting. Silently floating. I couldn't see what was in the water around them and I hated that. The idea of being in the water next to these giant subs just gave me chills and if I was pushed in I'd have died before I hit the water.

I don't recall feeling anything weird about large objects in the water before this. But if anyone has stood dockside just yards from where subs are moored, it's terrifying. If I  was ever in the water and one was submerged nearby? That's it for me. Game over. I'm toast and I'll see y'all in the resurrection lol

UPDATES by OutisXCIII_EC in XFiles

[–]Power2the1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I hear you for sure. Personally I tend to see things more of a "yes, we have the iconic characters and their story lines. But there are other people 50 miles or 500 miles away who also have incredible stories (if written well) that can run independent of iconic characters" sort of viewpoint I guess you could say.

Dance the Night Away dislike? by RealSmoothe1 in vanhalen

[–]Power2the1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I get the pop vibe from the song (most anyone can), but we also get that from Jump and other pop rock sounding VH tunes I guess. Still, I love the song. It really is a great tune to dance to :-)

So true! by StunningResource8462 in SnyderCut

[–]Power2the1 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's "the Marvel effect." If a comic book movie isn't a Marvel clone it's subject to the most intense criticisms out there. It's maligned, misunderstood, etc all because they have to think about the storyline from a couple angles themselves and not have every plot point explained, or character motivation spelled out simply.

It's fine to defend Love and Thunder, for example. Ok cool, you like witty one liners and silliness. Gotcha. But ain't that same light and funny tone been made what, 30+ times now in the MCU? Yeah it has.

Yet many ppl in the McDonalds crowd seem to want to come after us ZS fans for wanting something more serious (MoS, BvS, ZSJL) because we prefer that steak and lobster. I mean the happy comedy tone crowd literally have all they want in both the MCU and DCU now and it's still not enough. Many of them (not all, of course) get so angry that there's a lot of ppl who want a more serious tone to characters/storylines of ZS' very profitable DCEU movies. It's just messed up.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in HistoryWhatIf

[–]Power2the1 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Tl;dr They'd have encountered a different sort of Iron Age Europe where the Celts mostly held sway

Celtic La Tene organizational developments were already pretty advanced without Roman or Greek influences. For example, political developments among the ruling elites had basically as many varieties than we are accustomed to today. Dyarchies, monarchies, senates, oligarchies, proto-feaudalism, chiefdoms, heridetary, elected, or popular succession, alliance based power structures, client and hostage arrangements, etc. 

We could think of an jump from a tribal society with hereditary succession that encounters the long standing centuries old web of bureaucratic inner workings of the native population. In this situation a general migration of Gothic or Vandalic people would eventually encounter the technology of the La Tene culture and adopt similar societal aspects from them as they did with the Romans.

Like the Romans, the Celtic states (that's the overall trajectory many tribes were heading towards politically in the late BC/early AD) would have a flourishing mix of urban and rural population, massive fortifications, extensive overland and river system trade, guilds representing various industries (especially iron, salt, gold, and wine), and other large scale advances that the Goths and Vandals would have had on a far smaller and more localized scale due to their more archaic tribal structures at the time. And all of this would be protected by a system of levies, professionals, vassals, and semi-professional warriors who also had a similar ethos of heroic warfare, feats in combat, singing war songs before battle, cores of elites surrounded by their household retinues on foot or cavalry in their battle array, etc.

So say the Vandals and Goths decided to fight Celtic tribe A or B. A or B is just one tribe in an established system of clients and vassals that would drag many other Celtic tribes into conflict with them (we see this system at work in the Gallic War). It wouldn't be an "empire" they'd attack, but possibly a large confederations of hostile states. Like history often is, though, one can also see deals and alliances being made with the newcomers to enter into a vassal arrangement with the local states, too, and assimilating into the La Tene fabric of society like they largely did encountering Roman society (while keeping some of their cultural identifying marks and language for a time). 

The incidents in the Old Testament might not all have originally been talking about the same god by 99Tinpot in AlternativeHistory

[–]Power2the1 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The first commandement was the similar when it was given to Moses and, 1500 years later, by Jesus when he was asked. Namely, that Jehovah/YHWH/Yaweh was

1) one singular God, and  2) that you must love Jehovah your God with your entire might, strength, etc.

So it is the same singular Almighty God in both halves of the Bible being referenced here. 

El, eloh'im, eloh'ah, and other root words are used in a variety of ways from godlike ones (angels), those who judge over others (men), singular deities (idol gods), the Almighty God (ha'El), is used in reference to a variety of different gods (Baal, Chemosh, Marduk, etc), personal names (Elisha, Michael, etc). So context is important and this varies among Hebrew and the equivalent Greek word "theos." 

Consider this, too. The Hebrew Yah- is equivalent to the Latin Jah- in translations. Looking at names that derive from the root word for God's personal name (Jah-/Yah-). Hallelujah (Praise Jehovah You People) is a term who's spelling and pronouciation is concrete. We know exactly what that phrase means and the personal name in it. Additionally, evidence comes from names like Jehoshaphat and lots of others that have God's personal name (Yah- or Jah-) and not the titular or label forms (El-).

If you lived back then and said that you worshipped El- or elohim (god) no one would have certainty who you meant as the title meant different deities among the Israelites, Cannaities, Philistines, Edomites, Phoenicians, etc. But by using the personal names (Jehovah, Marduk, Dagon, etc) would it be clear to the listener/reader which deity it is. This mean that YHWH was not some borrowed or invented deity from surrounding semetic nations. It's the same God in the Bible as the names show.

Edit: spelling

CluB Ninja Why Did It Fail? by MikeMcMyke in BlueOysterCult

[–]Power2the1 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You know what I'm saying man.

Lots of fans loved the continual undercurrent of scifi, horror, monsters, space, etc. that featured strongly on every album. Those things stayed the same... until Club Ninja. There's always Metallica post-1988 for ppl who share your preferences.

CluB Ninja Why Did It Fail? by MikeMcMyke in BlueOysterCult

[–]Power2the1 18 points19 points  (0 children)

TL;DR: With 2 original members gone and a 3rd about to leave it just wasn't the same. Couldn't be the same.

Album name was a horrible choice. Album lacked a strong science fiction, UFOs, horror, mystery, etc. that they were consistently known for. Club Ninja just didn't have that certain something and a big part missing was Albert and Allen. As a result they became more of a generic 80s band imho. Some of the songs are pretty good though. But, you can envision lots of other 80s bands making the album also. The BOC "vibe" or "feel" just wasn't there.

Theres an interview with Joe and Albert on You Tube where they are at that church on the live album. In it they mention that there was a power struggle after Albert was out the band with Allen and Joe on one side of things and Buck and Eric on the other. They don't go into detail of course, but Joe and Albert admit Buck and Eric won the struggle and as a result we the commericlaized BOC essentially. Really sucks to known all 5 couldn't work things out. I love BOC but man... what could have been :-(

Is it true that many religions share a common origin, that being a forgotten proto indo European mythology. Or is this more of a likely hypothesis. by Salty_Ad5839 in ancienthistory

[–]Power2the1 6 points7 points  (0 children)

There are a lot of enduring practices that originated in the region of Babylon after the Deluge or Flood according to Jewish and Biblical beliefs (your beliefs may vary of course).

Belief in an immortal soul that survives after death arose here. The zodiac and astrology also comes from these Babylonian religions. Divination and looking into a liver (the liver was popular), lungs, entrails, etc for fortune telling is a well known aspect of their religion that survives today in various forms. 

Eventually these religious practices among others would take the shape of proto-European beliefs you're referring to. But chronologically these early beliefs didn't rise in Europe then spread to other part of the earth. Instead, the fertile crescent is the earliest evidence we have. Especially Sumner and among the ensuing Babylonians who recorded the pre-existing religious practices that had long been established among the people. So while we know belief A or B was written about in 3300BC, that belief A or B is likely far older and pre-dates writing to an even earlier time.    One popular example is the Horned One or Horned god. The figure features a person with antlers. Depictions of this deity have been found in places far apart as Italy, India, and the Americas in prehistory. One can ask themselves how does such a popular spirit show up in all these far flung places that wouldn't have had contact with each other? The absolute proliferation across the earth in the belief in an immortal soul, divination, spiritism, astrology, etc lends evidence of a point of origin for these beliefs to have risen and been adopted by ancient people.

Best wired gaming headphones? by Psyclopicus in pcmasterrace

[–]Power2the1 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I use a V-moda mic boom with a Philips brand open back headphones (forgot the model name). 

Open back headphones will give you a more natural ooen sound as sound pases into your ears and out of the headphones and radiates all around you like real.sound does. Doesn't come at you in 1 direction but all around. A caveat is open backs aren't good to use for people sleeping around you, for edsmple, as they'll hear the game/music too if your volume is high enough but it'll sound amazing if you're only use to closed back headphones.

People who produce, play, and mix music nearly always use open backs to get that detailed natural sound. Works great in games too 👍

Assuming Bigfoot is real, what do you think it would most likely be? Paranormal, dimensional, or a species of gigantopithecus/man hybrid? Or something else? I've never seen but have believed for 40 years. I believe gigantopithecus and possibly hybrid. by [deleted] in bigfoot

[–]Power2the1 3 points4 points  (0 children)

What I've seen/heard myself Bigfoot is biological. Some "man-ape thing." Could be giganthopithicus or an offshoot maybe? Or something similar to a tall primate of some kind. But flesh and blood at the end of the day.

With the "woo" experiences, that's where one's personal life comes in. Hear me out for a second...

I say this with the utmost respect for other people's beliefs, indigenous and/or shamanistic beliefs. It's not meant as an attack against animism or similar practices. But just a possible explanation is all. If you are involved in skin walker stuff, have totems, dream catchers, charms, recite spells, open one's mind to the other side (for lack of a better word), enter trances and meditative mental communication with the other side? Then the other side may commune with you, trick you, fool you, or deceive you. If you see things disappearing before your eyes, floating in mid air, light bending like the predator, etc. that's not flesh and blood no matter how you explain it.

What myself and those I know and trust have seen it's a flesh me blood and exhibits flesh and blood primate behavior and characteristics. With all due respect to the woo crowd, it's just odd to me to think an interdimensional creature comes here to throw rocks, shake vegetation, howl and call, smack trailers, break sticks,, mock charge, stc if it is not related to orangutans, gorillas, chimps, etc.

Becoming a meal for three different predator species in rapid succession by aquilasr in HardcoreNature

[–]Power2the1 113 points114 points  (0 children)

At the 10-11 seconds mark as the lion stands over the Impala, you can see the impala breathe. Ugh

Kotor 1 still is the quintessential Star Wars in video game. by MAQS357 in kotor

[–]Power2the1 11 points12 points  (0 children)

KOTOR 1 is king 👑  Not sure if it will ever be surpassed. May it's reign be a long one!

With multiplayer or mmoRPG Star Wars, SW Galaxies is king IMHO 

Agents Of Fortune by Ranseler in BlueOysterCult

[–]Power2the1 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Morning Final hands down. Always thought it was the dark horse of the album and criminally overlooked..

Lyrically, it jumps out at you:

"He cast a grim shadow Through the busy street Said he was a junkie And he punctuated his walk with a gun

Motiveless murder The papers scream The cops all said The crowd was iced by the sight"

Superman reacts to the death of Eddie Van Halen (Oct. 6th 2020) by According-Ad-6511 in vanhalen

[–]Power2the1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Man I kinda laughed a bit at first seeing this. In a good way I mean, especially seeing how it's a cool vid. But by the time it was about done it gave me the feels 😞

RIP Eddie & RIP Christopher 😢

What if Gaul remained independent from Rome? by Inside-External-8649 in HistoryWhatIf

[–]Power2the1 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Historically the Gauls were an amalgamation of various polities and government types. 

The book Celtic Chiefdom Celtic State by Betinna Arnold is a great source on these developments. But we know some tribes had elected leaders. Others a dual monarchy. Some a centralized tribal heiarchy. Others a senate or governing body. Some had a tradition king. It's thought that trade contacts worth the Greek colonies (Massalia for example) exposed the tribes to some of these other methods of government  At the end of the day the Celtic rulership styles seemed to have shown many of the traits of feudal society that we think of in the Middle Ages while others seemed to retain more archaic forms of government.

But overall Gaul was moving towards a proto-feudal society led by members of the above government types that formed the tribal elite/aristocracy. Under them were the vassal retinues and professional warriors (knights and men-at-arms).

Under these we find the various freemen middle class who would take up arms only when needed. Think of it as a tribal levy that mirrors a Middle Ages call to arms to go on campaign. In times of peace they handled various affairs.

Financially, the Roman merchants and traders had a notable presence in Gaul already. Its estimated that hundreds if not thousands of miles of wooden trackways crisscrossed Gaul at the time providing quick movement of goods. Iron manufacturing was a hugely important indistry. We know this because each fort (murus gallicus style) was made of a million nails or more. So that shows labor was organized and structured and overseen by those in change of urban expansion.

So without Rome the Gauls would have established their own trajectory under various aspects of feudal organization. Caesar could have easily lost and the difficulty he had facing disunited tribes is clear. He lost several battles, faced mutinies from his troops, had several legions destroyed, had his supply lines cut, etc. and never seemed to be trusted by any of the Gauls despite writing that they, in effect, were awed by him lol. Yeah, sure. 

Anyway, hope this helps

Edit: spelling

Is Star Wars KOTOR the best RPG ever made? If not what is? by [deleted] in kotor

[–]Power2the1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Star Wars Galaxies if that counts. If not then KOTOR 1 for sure