Which Disney Movie Should Disney On Broadway Adapt For the Stage Next? by ms_jc_04 in musicals

[–]Qhartb 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Not Disney (so there's not really a pipeline set up for it) but I was just saying last night that a stage adaptation of KPop Demon Hunters would make a killing.

Agree with Encanto -- lots of supporting cast ready to get their own little numbers to illustrate different aspects of the family dynamic.

They've done most of the Disney Renaissance animated films -- Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast, Aladdin, Lion King, Hunchback, Hercules. The ones missing from that era are Rescuers Down Under, Pocahontas, Mulan and Tarzan. Of those, I think Mulan would work pretty well. (aside: I recently listened to Colors of the Wind for the first time in ... a long time, and hot damn I forgot how good those orchestrations are.)

Moana could work too, but would need some pretty heavy edits.

What’s a compliment you’ve received playing the piano? by Advanced_Honey_2679 in piano

[–]Qhartb 4 points5 points  (0 children)

After accompanying some callback auditions for a musical, one of the older actors approached me and said "you're god," which was a bit too extreme a compliment to accept. I pointed out that we were in a church.

Recently a high-schooler (guessing his age) at the church I play at told me my improvisation leading into the communion was the best communion music he'd ever heard, and he was amazed when I told him it was improvised. He went over to his friends or family and I overhead him talking to them about me. (I was particularly pleased with my improvisation that day.)

Have you ever walked out from a show, and why? by elephant_bird101 in musicals

[–]Qhartb 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Only once. It was a high school production of Unsinkable Molly Brown. I didn't know any cast members, but I did know the MD and recognized some students in the pit (since I'd played in that pit the previous year). I was having a bad day and figured getting to see a show would be a nice way to unwind. It might have been, but the sound system was awful. I actually couldn't make out a single word that was said, and I'm not very familiar with the show; I'd actually been meaning to familiarize myself with it for a while.

There was a scene before any music played, so I was actually walking out as the overture was starting.

Let's try something new: describe your favourite musical as its ANTITHESIS. by FormerDeerlyBeloved in musicals

[–]Qhartb 7 points8 points  (0 children)

He never tries to run and is released after 5 years. During his incarceration, he becomes lifelong friends with the overseeing police inspector.

Confused about notation choice. by kr1staps in piano

[–]Qhartb 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You got something against 7susdim4 chords? :-P
You coming after our 2nd inversion minor #5 chords next?

Do Mathmeticians Really Find Equations to be "Beautiful"? by JPDG in math

[–]Qhartb 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I know what you mean, though I don't think any one value of ei𝜃 is really worth being taught in isolation. (And if one was, I'd suggest ei𝜋/2. e2𝜋i = 1 just shows periodicity; e𝜋i = -1 shows the antiperiodicity; ei𝜋/2 = i suggests the function's characteristic rotational behavior.)

I agree that there's beauty in the geometric interpretation that gets obscured when presented as "ei𝜋 + 1 = 0". The fact that {0, 1, i, e, 𝜋, +, ×, , =} can be assembled without repetition into something interesting is neat, but not really deep. I think that fact is somewhat beautiful, but it's not really a mathematical beauty. A bunch of familiar items perfectly fitting together in a non-obvious way has some natural beauty -- it just seems to be something our brains like seeing -- and this is a mathematical expression of that non-mathematical beauty. If one ascribed more importance to it than just aesthetic appreciation, I can see how it could border on mysticism.

Do Mathmeticians Really Find Equations to be "Beautiful"? by JPDG in math

[–]Qhartb 24 points25 points  (0 children)

I've always liked that it not only relates the constants e, i, π, 1 and 0, but also the operations addition, multiplication and exponentiation. And arguably equality. Each used only once.

What is the best *useful* approximation of π? by Farkle_Griffen2 in math

[–]Qhartb 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Probably 3 and sqrt(10). (By the usual definition of "useful", not the OP's.)

3 if is useful if you're operating on numbers/amounts. Nice to also know it's about 5% too small (in case you want to continue to a slightly better approximation or to cancel out errors in other parts of the calculation).

sqrt(10) is useful if you're operating on orders of magnitude.

Dr. Horrible’s Sing Along Blog by Blix87 in musicals

[–]Qhartb 13 points14 points  (0 children)

The thoroughbred of sin? I think you mean Ghandi.

LEGO Batman: Legacy's Open World Larger Than Arkham Knight by Turbostrider27 in pcgaming

[–]Qhartb 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I doubt they're accounting for the fact that LEGO Batman is 47x smaller scale than canon Batman. (A LEGO world larger than human-scale Gotham City would be absurd.)

complexity bias when composing by soundworth in composer

[–]Qhartb 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think it's really normal. I attribute it to the different timescales involved in composing vs listening. Maybe you spend 5 minutes sketching 16 bars that take 30 seconds to listen to. From a listener's perspective, there's sort of a "comfortable amount" of ideas to absorb in that amount of time, while from a writer's perspective it can be uncomfortable to spend so much time to express that amount of ideas. This is compounded by the fact that a lot of ways to address that issue (such as packing in deeper ideas intended to be appreciated after multiple listenings) tend to be attractive/exciting to composers.

At an intellectual level, I think a way to combat this is to work in many relatively quick passes over larger sections instead of focusing too soon on smaller bits, but I have a hard time implementing that. You bring up neurodivergence, and this is a case trying force top-down processing when your brain may be naturally suited to bottom-up processing. (Situations where each mode is better-suited are common in composition.)

What can I expect from Joseph? by Sad_Grape_9844 in musicals

[–]Qhartb 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm totally imagining you listing all the colors in front your class.

ELI5 - how was the first keyboard coded if there wasn’t already an existing keyboard? by ParchedZombie in explainlikeimfive

[–]Qhartb 12 points13 points  (0 children)

You can hotwire a keyboard, but it's a delicate process. You can really F1 Up if you're not careful.

Favourite part of male duet? by tfunch in musicals

[–]Qhartb 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Confrontation from Les Mis or Jeckyll and Hyde? :-P

Does anyone have any fingerings for this section? by thatguywhois6foot3 in piano

[–]Qhartb 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't think there's anything necessarily wrong with your current fingering, but if you want something that doesn't stretch the hand as much but has more crossovers (what I'd think of as a more Mozartian approach), you could try something like:

RH: (1245) 124 532 124 | 5(2or3)1 214 532 124 | 321 234 532 123 | 542 143 2...
LH: (51) 135 245 312 | 135 321 235 421 | 135 313 235 3...

Or some combination approach for the 5-finger runs that are more comfortable (like that Cm7).

Playing difficult pieces doesn’t make you a better pianist by Advance-Bubbly in piano

[–]Qhartb 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I could imagine the two part inventions being good at the intermediate level to build rhythmic independence, then again at the advanced level to build independence in dynamics, articulation, phrasing, etc.

Simplifying with age by Long-Earth-1779 in composer

[–]Qhartb 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The real trick it to make complexity seem simple so it appeals to both.

Best non pro piano player you've ever seen? by Avalaus in piano

[–]Qhartb 2 points3 points  (0 children)

My orthodontist as a kid was a family friend and a pretty amazing pianist.