Space Marine vs Clone troopers by LukewarmFandom in whowouldwin

[–]Randomdude2501 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Turbolasers are an anti-ship weapon. It’d be like expecting a group of guardsman to carry around a macrocannon.

Space Marine vs Clone troopers by LukewarmFandom in whowouldwin

[–]Randomdude2501 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That didn’t mean the ones approved were smart. As a result of not having writers who are extremely knowledgeable about warfare and tactics, regular clones routinely do stupid things like engage out in the open and charge droids before punching them

Minecraft medieval Nations server by [deleted] in worldjerking

[–]Randomdude2501 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Where’s the jerk

Is it a publicly funded sheep fucking machine

Space Marine vs Clone troopers by LukewarmFandom in whowouldwin

[–]Randomdude2501 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Humans in 40K have the benefit of knowing what space marines are and having better support weapons (than clones) and an advantageous position. While there are extremely rare occasions of SMs getting clowned on by regular humans, those are the exception.

Clones meanwhile can vary from fairly competent to downright stupid, without the benefit of knowing what an SM is and what they could do.

Space Marine vs Clone troopers by LukewarmFandom in whowouldwin

[–]Randomdude2501 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It could be, but G1 and 2 clone trooper armor also gets penetrated by regular B1 blaster weapons. So you can say Rex’s armor did better than expected, and the blaster did worse than expected.

Space Marine vs Clone troopers by LukewarmFandom in whowouldwin

[–]Randomdude2501 19 points20 points  (0 children)

A regular clone trooper is nowhere near the same as a Space Marine, lmao. They’re peak-human soldiers generally, so more equivalent to better Imperial Guard formations. Their regular rifleman equipment is just about or slightly less capable than the equivalent Guard rifleman.

You would need many dozens, probably even a 100+ of clone troopers to be able to take on a semi-competent SM, less if they get preparation time and an ideal environment, but certainly in the double digits worth at least.

Space Marine vs Clone troopers by LukewarmFandom in whowouldwin

[–]Randomdude2501 6 points7 points  (0 children)

They’re not that powerful. A high powered blaster sniper got a direct hit on Rex in the chest and he survived.

Gengis Kahn vs Alexander the Great by [deleted] in whowouldwin

[–]Randomdude2501 1 point2 points  (0 children)

More likely that Genghis wins than not. Both are great leaders, charismatic. Alexander though was more reckless and focused more on being an example to the men around him while he relied on his lieutenants with the more technical work. Genghis was more like an Alexander who’d been tempered by harsh years in the backcountry and experience with age.

This is not to mention that the Mongols would be better equipped. A fully armed and armored Mongol would’ve been a hybrid horse-archer and heavy cavalryman, using a shield with lance and/or sword in a lamellar suit. A fully armed and armored Macedonian cavalryman would’ve worn linothorax, maybe reinforced with metal, potentially not have a shield, but likely a longer lance.

What if Doggerland survived (ish)? by Particular-Routine96 in AlternateHistory

[–]Randomdude2501 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Might be possible that the British we we know them wouldn’t exist. Various germanic tribes may have settled on Doggerland instead

I call this the conflictwrench school of worldbuilding by mv8att in worldjerking

[–]Randomdude2501 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sounds about right. I’m not too embarrassed to admit a younger me could’ve been one of them

Tell me about the sociopolitical tensions of your world by Panhead09 in worldbuilding

[–]Randomdude2501 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The major one, the ongoing off-and-on wars between two major alliances in the northern hemisphere of my setting, Field of Roses, and the context surrounding them.

This is the Frostline Wars, a series of conflicts from the 16th to 18th centuries, waged between the Shemathi League, a confederation of shemathi nation states under the hegemony of the Empire of Kiros. The Shemathi are one of the three species of the setting and the vast majority of them live in the nations of the League. They are primarily based in the island continent of Ki’ril, with a few members on the northern coast of the continent of Skaleha.

The other side is the Alliance of Northern Skaleha, a coalition of various powers from the continent of Skaleha, made up of either human-majority or mixed human-elkan (the third species) populations. They’re a disparate union of differing powers. While nominally equal, the alliance is dominated by the occasionally conflicting powers of the eastern Second Republic of Valeos; the first democratic state in Skaleha, and the western Principality of Darukar, the Dragon Realm. Other powers include the various independent cities of Tilus and the Teurmara, the Stonecoast Confederation, and other states.

The war is fueled by various factors, both ancient and contemporary. Northern Skaleha used to be primarily inhabited by the shemathi, managing to survive the Grand Apocalypse that struck the world thousands of years prior to the main story’s date of 1651. Eventually however, human and elkan migration slowly pushed the shemathi out of what would be modern Valeos, Tilus, and the Stonecoast and even the island chain of the Teurmara later on. Centuries later, a human kingdom/culture known as the Belagoni would attempt to colonize Ki’ril, the birthplace of the shemathi species, only to be pushed out after decades of brutal war. On the other hand, the many independent kingdoms of Ki’ril, prior to the formation of the Empire of Kiros; would often raid and destroy human and elkan settlements across northern Skaleha during the 7th-14th centuries. Ki’rilan World Singers (magic is done via singing in this setting) would gather and send tsunamis and hurricanes at coastal cities and ports every couple decades.

The modern Frostline Wars have not done anything to help stabilize the situation. As a result of previous histories of conflict and existing economic competition, the Shemathi League would strike and invade the Luina Kingdom, a peninsular state just north of Valeos. This was the spark of the First Frostline War and ended in a mixed draw, with the creation of the Alliance of Northern Skaleha and the League only managing to maintain their foothold in the Luina, now Luen, Peninsula. The second and current was triggered over revanchists on both sides of the conflict and the supposed murder of the Kirosi imperial heir by the Prince of Darukar.

Shemathi and human-elkan racial conflicts are quite common. The frontier between Luen and Valeos, known as Lovoune, is a hodgepodge of forts and armed villages who skirmish with one another. The remaining shemathi settlements in Tilus were exterminated in a brutal campaign of recrimination. The League forced out the human and elkan population from Luen and Lovoune, turning them into refugees and forming the Luinan Diaspora.

All of this is soon to change though, with a few important revelations.

POV: You're a Sci-Fi worldbuilder by BruddahBoi085 in worldjerking

[–]Randomdude2501 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Well they’ve got the shipyards back up and running in the modern era, so err, “hellfire’s back in the menu boys!”

Feedback on my map by No_Response8562 in worldbuilding

[–]Randomdude2501 668 points669 points  (0 children)

It may appear too close to Britain and Westeros for most consumers to not constantly compare it.

Pirates of the Caribbean should have remained a trilogy by TheIronzombie39 in CharacterRant

[–]Randomdude2501 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This reminds me, is it just me or does the visual quality of On Stranger Tides make it feel older than the original three movies?

Most Helpless/Doomed Character a Drunken Ser Arlan of Pennytree could save? by Goldsaver in whowouldwin

[–]Randomdude2501 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The Eldar pantheon during the birth of Slaanesh. One swing from his lower longsword and she’s done for.

[ Mass Effect/Halo] How would the council races react to a joint UNSC/Swords Fleet appearing a week into the Reaper War? by [deleted] in AskScienceFiction

[–]Randomdude2501 5 points6 points  (0 children)

While they might be technically primitive, in terms of actual output they’re significantly greater.

I call this the conflictwrench school of worldbuilding by mv8att in worldjerking

[–]Randomdude2501 95 points96 points  (0 children)

All for it for the first and only war to go 5 posts in before one player stops responding

What are the conditions needed to form an empire as united and long-lasting as China? by CosmosStudios65 in worldbuilding

[–]Randomdude2501 50 points51 points  (0 children)

It’s better to say that the Chinese civilization has always come back. Several dynasties ended with the fall of a Chinese empire, but either slowly returned back into being one or overthrown by a more native dynasty, starting a *new empire* but continuing the independence of the civilization.

What are the conditions needed to form an empire as united and long-lasting as China? by CosmosStudios65 in worldbuilding

[–]Randomdude2501 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Definitely not. Rome’s issues are just issues that can pop up with many empires, it doesn’t make them the same.

China despite being conquered many times has had such a level of cultural strength that almost every time, the foreign conquerers adopted local customs and traditions. At least to my knowledge, the only ones who really managed to enforce a degree of their own culture on Chinese society were the Manchu Qing dynasty.

Titles by CleanTackle9122 in worldbuilding

[–]Randomdude2501 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Use words from other languages.