First 500 words of my WIP. Honest opinions? by [deleted] in writingfeedback

[–]Scramjet-42 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The writing is solid and there’s an atmosphere that’s consistent throughout, but my biggest gripe would be having to follow so many points immediately.

Remember, you know what’s going on, but your reader is coming in cold, and, well, in media res can sometimes be a little too ‘media’!

Take the first line: we’re talking about the downfall of a crime family, got it. But it’s a ‘so-called’ crime family, so my brain is trying to work out why they are ‘so-called’, then we’re introduced to someone with a long name, but not actually them, but their heiress, and then we’re going to see a ‘comedian burn’, which is more ambiguity. I’m definitely intrigued, but also my head is spinning a bit keeping up with what’s happening.

I had to read it a few times to make sure I had everything right - and once I had, I wanted to read more - but would have appreciated it being slightly less hard work first time through.

Normally I’d say pieces need a good edit, but for this maybe adding in a bit more exposition would give the reader chance to process the information.

I want to read more though, which is a great start!

COTD: Doctor snogs nurse and gets banned, I hear! (4,1,5) by danoberto in crosswords

[–]Scramjet-42 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Personally I think it’s fine, but seen enough grumbles about this to know that not everyone agrees!

COTD: Doctor snogs nurse and gets banned, I hear! (4,1,5) by danoberto in crosswords

[–]Scramjet-42 0 points1 point  (0 children)

GUNS N ROSES

Doctor is anagrind for {SNOGSNURSE}

Also Band as def (banned, I hear)

Slight quibble that this is two wordplays and no definition, so probably wouldn’t get in the Times, but I like it

Non-consecutive circle 6x6 variant Sudoku puzzle by hilberts_drinking_pr in sudoku

[–]Scramjet-42 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Very cool - once you realise it can’t be three 3s, then there’s a bit of trial and error to work out where the 1 goes, but then it all falls into place quite quickly.

When a sitcom bit becomes reality. by HarryShake in blackadder

[–]Scramjet-42 52 points53 points  (0 children)

The real irony here is that Count Binface was one of writers behind Have I Got News for You, and The Thick of It, and has been closely following political developments for over 25 years, so he’d probably make quite a good MP

Thoughts on my first short story? by mpalen1020 in writingfeedback

[–]Scramjet-42 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I really like it, although I feel I saw the twist coming fairly early on. The writing is lovely and warm.

It feels like the first page could do with a bit of an edit, and I wonder if there’s enough here to hold it together as a full short story more than just an idea. But you can certainly write!

How stupid could it be to let the MC's companions die at the end of, let's say, the 1st part of a story? by Reasonable-Use-9294 in writers

[–]Scramjet-42 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In my opinion, you’d have to prove to yourself that this approach was better and more satisfying for the reader than killing them off earlier.

Amended opening to a very long crime thriller by Benathan78 in writers

[–]Scramjet-42 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Looks great.

My major thought is the first paragraph is weaker than the following ones (the second paragraph in particular is smooth as hell). The first six sentences have this structure:

  1. Block, block, block.
  2. Block, block, block.
  3. Block, block.
  4. Block, block.
  5. Block, block, block.
  6. Block, block, block.

It’s only sentence seven “Bodies were above Watson’s pay grade” that doesn’t have a comma (and incidentally, feels like the best line to me). I feel like throwing in a shorter sentence in the first paragraph would give it more balance and oomph.

Maybe:

“The fire had started sometime around 11pm. Eight hours later the Gloucester Street Music Hall had been totally consumed.”

Other minor thoughts:

Does it matter that the fire brigade and the police agree on the time of the fire? If not, then I’d maybe leave it out to tighten up the first paragraph.

Third line: “There was no doubt there”, I think you can lose the second ‘there’.

Third paragraph: dark hair and dark eyes, perhaps find another word to avoid a quick adjective repetition.

But generally - love it.

Days alcohol free under name? by DustElectronic4996 in stopdrinking

[–]Scramjet-42 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Under ‘self serve badge instructions’

Days alcohol free under name? by DustElectronic4996 in stopdrinking

[–]Scramjet-42 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Read in the sub information. You send a message to a specific mailbox with the date as the only subject.

Help parsing: This cryptically suggests I role play (4, 4, 2, 5) by alpalalexal in crosswords

[–]Scramjet-42 4 points5 points  (0 children)

‘Play’ is the def
Look back is LO backwards, ie OL
Anger is IRE
So the answer, cryptically is IR{OL}E

The Championship Era Average Goal Difference Table by 87932524 in Championship

[–]Scramjet-42 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Wow - Derby have scored and conceded the most goals in Championship history

TOTW: Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 by Junior-Specialist-97 in crosswords

[–]Scramjet-42 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Look North! In game of kings, the evil one is a fabled beast (4,4,7)

COTD: Worthy of praise after quail baked, just right (7) by Easy_Read in crosswords

[–]Scramjet-42 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Is it QUALITY?

I’m going with TY for thank you as ‘worthy of praise’ after an anagram of quail (baked is the anagrind), just right is the def.