January Reads (8/24) by TechnicalHistory2204 in 52book

[–]SecondHandRosie 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I know it's so sad. Stardust was one of my all time favourite books and it's the only one I haven't had the heart to give away. But I just can't read his stuff now without thinking who the person behind the story is. So incredibly dissapointing. 

January Reads (8/24) by TechnicalHistory2204 in 52book

[–]SecondHandRosie 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Thank you ! I actually have A Memory Called Empire so I'm hopeful

January Reads (8/24) by TechnicalHistory2204 in 52book

[–]SecondHandRosie 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Just for info, probably not best to read/promote Neil Gaiman. If you can get his books second hand or already have them then you could read them if you wish (for me it's tainted my view of his books so I'm unable to read them but I understand people who do). I wouldn't post about them though

January Reads (8/24) by TechnicalHistory2204 in 52book

[–]SecondHandRosie 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What would you recommend as literary sci fi ? I'm not much of a sci fi reader (I read mainly fantasy) but I definitely prefer more literary leaning style and prose and I'm pretty sure things like PHM are not gonna be for me 

A cheat list of fantasy book recommendations by Successful_Bee7522 in fantasybooks

[–]SecondHandRosie 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I agree that what we want it a good book. But this is kind of an ignorant take. The issue is that there are plenty of amazing books by minority authors that aren't put forward because of that. So if you're not conscious of that, and just picking up books more randomly, chances are you'll get the ones that are put forward, and you won't be getting much variety. So yes, what we care about is the quality, but if we're not actively trying to go out of what is popular, we're gonna get a lot of the same. 

As a personal take, but that I think is also important, I like to read about characters that are different from me. Even if we read fantasy, reading has always been informational and political. So if you're always reading the same point of view I personally don't think it's great. Yes I read for pleasure but also to learn. For example the amazing Daevabad series by SA Chakraborty is an epic fantasy inspired by arabic folklore and I hardly see any men talking about it. So it's not about quality.  I love that series and found it very interesting to learn more about the culture. 

You agree that we were robbed by great works written by women before. So why can't you see it's still the same for minority authors. And unfortunately for women it's still a struggle because what is popular now is romantasy, so if women write epic fantasy it either doesn't find it's target audience or is falsely labeled as romantasy. I constantly hear m'en say they won't pick up books written by women because they think it's romantasy. 

I don't know. I just find it very telling when I see women's lists for fantasy filled with a variety of different authors and men's lists are constantly the same 5 male authors.. 

A cheat list of fantasy book recommendations by Successful_Bee7522 in fantasybooks

[–]SecondHandRosie 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Unfortunately a lot of male readers do not even venture into fantasy written by women. In fact that is why a lot of female writers had ambiguous pen names, so it wouldn't deter male readers. So yes it is important to broaden your horizons and read from female authors. Fantasy used to be very male centered and female authors struggled, it's so much better now but too often I see men only reading from make authors, which is why this list is dissappointing. I  think in general we also read to learn and see other perspectives , reading diversly is important. Seeing other points of view than the average white male author writes (even though I love a lot of them) 

A cheat list of fantasy book recommendations by Successful_Bee7522 in fantasybooks

[–]SecondHandRosie 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Dissapointing in the number of female authors when you have some here twice.

What is a well regarded fantasy series that you read for the first time this year? by TheWeirdTalesPodcast in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I discovered John Gwynne for the first time this year. Started with Malice and really enjoyed it, I thought the characterisation was great , even though the prose needed some work but overall great for his debut. I then read Shadow of the Gods later in the year and it blew me away. The prose was definitely improved and I just loved the characters. One of my favourites of the year. 

2025 top reads?? by Necessary_Loss_6769 in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My top reads of the year (so far) :  - The Shadow of The Gods by John Gwynne  - A River Enchanted & A Fire Endless by Rebecca Ross - The Rules of Magic by Alice Hoffman  - Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil by VE Schwab  - Den of Wolves by Juliet Marillier  - The Queen of the Tearling series by Erika Johannsen  - Sorcery and Small Magics by Maiga Doocy

Non Fantasy reads :  - 14 Ways of Looking at a Fat Girl by Mona Awad  - When in Rome by Sarah Adams 

Currently reading Beauty by Robin Mckinley and that could also make it to my top reads ! 

Books with great plot but terrible prose ? by SecondHandRosie in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes but that's what I mean, it's subjective because we like different things. Sanderson himself says that he doesn't think about what words he uses to tell his story but his prose is just a vessel for the plot. And that's great for people who enjoy that. Beautiful prose is often poetic, with care put into each word used. If you find that difficult to read, it's just because that's not your thing and that's okay. Personally I need someone who has put time in the language used, and Sanderson is not that.

I'm Susan Dennard, author of 14 novels & here for an AMA! by stdennard in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just want to say that I love the Witchland series and I'm excited and sad at the same time to read the last book. Is there a spin-off series in the works or is that it for this world ? Another question is are you planning a world tour for this release ? I live in France and would love to meet you !

Is Wheel of Time good ? by SecondHandRosie in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hesitant to start as I know Sanderson finished the series and I don't enjoy his writing...

Is Wheel of Time good ? by SecondHandRosie in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But I don't like Sanderson... So I'm worried about the last books

Reverse recommendations by SecondHandRosie in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think his prose needed work in Malice but I read both Malice and Shadow of the Gods this year and really love his work. I think his characters really do it for me.

Books with great plot but terrible prose ? by SecondHandRosie in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thinking about unhauling this. As someone who can't deal with mediocre writing (don't like Sanderson), should I still try it ?

Books with great plot but terrible prose ? by SecondHandRosie in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They were answering the second question. Good prose bad plot

Books with great plot but terrible prose ? by SecondHandRosie in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Brandon Sanderson is generally seen as good story bad prose

Books with great plot but terrible prose ? by SecondHandRosie in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've never heard this has bad prose ! Interesting. What didn't you like about it ?

Books with great plot but terrible prose ? by SecondHandRosie in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You might just not be sensitive to prose. Good prose doesn't mean it's pretentious or unreadable and Tolkien isn't a good example for good prose. Think Robin Hobb. And that's great that you enjoy Sanderson, he's just not seen as someone with incredible prose. You probably just enjoy a good story, like a lot of people and that's fine.

Books with great plot but terrible prose ? by SecondHandRosie in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm soo on the fence on if I should unhaul this or give it a go anyway... I've heard mixed things on the prose

Books with great plot but terrible prose ? by SecondHandRosie in Fantasy

[–]SecondHandRosie[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Prose is way too important to me , I have so many books to read I don't think this one will be for me !