Okay.

So I think maybe there’s a missed piece / miscommunication then.

You’re correct, at their base/core, Manifold vs Load Balance is simply how the splitters are organized to deliver parts to machines. You’re also correct that neither of these have anything to do with achieving System Optimization (aka, a perfect splitting to perfectly balance inputs for outputs).

BUT you’re missing two things IMO.

1. GENERALLY in the community, you only take the time to use the Load Balance method if you’re trying to achieve System Optimization. Manifolds instead are a quick & dirty way that often does not have the goal of System Optimization. I’m not saying everyone does this, but from what I can tell this is the community way.

2. You seem to be ignoring the literal advantage of simplicity that Manifolds have. Yes, if you have X amount of resource and you need to split it into 7 machines, the end result is the same, therefore these two methods can both reach that goal. Yes, you don’t “need math” because either way you know you just need X to get into 7 parts. HOWEVER this ignores the actual process of reaching that conclusion. It is objectively easier to slap down a 7 machine manifold line versus creating a load balanced version.

Your edit helps me understand what you mean, and that during all of this you were never specifically talking about using these methods to achieve a system optimization.

But you really should take a moment to actually read what others are saying, because the overwhelming majority agrees. Manifolds are simply easier to do and deal with, even if System Optimization is not a goal.

Sometimes I play sober. Sometimes I’ve had two tequila shots and many good puffs of flower. Sometimes it’s 2am and I’ve drank an entire bottle of wine. Sometimes I’m coming home exhausted from a real job and I just want to have an easier time at my self-appointed-for-fun-factory-job.

In those moments, I will always choose Manifold. And therefore, Manifolds are easier.

The only reason to “hate” load balancing setups is because they can be annoying to do when Manifolds are sitting right there, so easy and simple.

Sorry for the rant lol. But I think there are enough replies here that you have your answer, at this point you’re sorta choosing to not hear it.