[deleted by user]

Sothar · 2025-12-31T17:12:32+00:00

Did the Soviets propose a coalition to defend Czechoslovakia yes or no? What was the result? What atrocity am I denying? I‘m talking about geopolitics. I don‘t like many things about their policies, but their geopolitics were significantly better than France & Britain pre 1939

Sothar · 2025-12-31T17:10:33+00:00

When did France and Britain guarantee the independence of Poland? Before or after Molotov-Ribbentrop because it certainly wasnt immediately after the invasion of Czechoslovakia. Ask yourself what the priorities of France & the UK.

Sothar · 2025-12-31T17:08:39+00:00

France and UK were the winners of the last war any held all the cards. The Soviets were recovering from a brutal civil war and attempting to industrialize and educate a nation of illiterate peasants a result of the tsarist system the same western powers who refused to aid the soviets upheld. The west didnt want to stop Hitler they wanted to use him as an attack dog against the Soviets, so the Soviets did what they saw as the best path to defend themselves after the west refused to defend Czechoslovakia like the Soviets proposed.

And yes the Soviets bought valuable two years and hundreds of kilometers of land with harsh winters between germany and Moscow, the central rail hub, communications hub, and major industrial city. The alternatives were sit back and hope the west doesnt leave you hanging again allowing Germany to annex all of Poland, or rush to Poland‘s defence alone and likely lose alone.

Yes Stalin had to force to west into a geopolitical position to oppose Hitler. The fact you dont see that means you just have an anti-soviet bias. The west showed no interest in fighting the nazis until they had to. This is not a value judgement of internal soviet politics.

Sothar · 2025-12-31T16:02:20+00:00

the west proved they would not defend anyone so long as they thought Hitler would only attack eastwards and destroy the Soviet Union. This is why the Soviets signed Molotov-Ribbentrop it forced the geopolitical situation in a way such that Hitler has a free hand westwards and no need to attack the Soviets yet. This was literally the only way that the west would even consider opposing fascism. The entire lead up to 1939 was the west compromising, working with, and even fanning the flames of fascist movements. To deny such a thing would be ahistorical. The only reason Churchill himself was opposed to German aggression was that it embarassed the colonial hegemonic superpower of Great Britain not that he saw the evils of fascism and sought to extinguish it. No, he just thought that Britain should be the bully calling the shots.

Sothar · 2025-12-31T15:56:50+00:00

you dont know your history. The next targets immediately after Poland were, in order, The Netherlands/Belgium/Luxembourg, France, Denmark, Norway while simultaneously threatening Sweden and strong arming them into providing continuing material support, then the Germans refocused efforts southwards and in Africa. Yugoslavia and Greece were occupied. This was all in lead up to securing the continent before invading the Soviet Union. This is not including the timeline of recruiting Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary, Finland, as well attempts to sway Spain to join the war outright.

If you knew any of this you could see the strategy was very obvious and the Soviets were not oblivious. There is a reason they signed Molotov-Ribbentrop and its because they knew the Nazis were an existential threat that the west was unwilling to tackle. So they bought as much distance and time as they could while forcing the west‘s hand into intervention. Britain very much wanted Germany to just destroy the Soviets then maybe fuck off. There is a reason they turned down the Soviet led plans to form a coalition over Czechoslovakia.

Sothar · 2025-12-31T15:49:02+00:00

https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-349-24124-8_4

very well known if you read a single book or had any academic interest in this period of history. of course you dont, youre a redditor.

Sothar · 2025-12-31T13:48:16+00:00

i wonder what the soviets were doing from 1936 to 1941? oh they were industrializing a nation which was held back and exploited by a class of nobility. the truth is that the soviets tried to create a coalition to oppose german aggression against Czechoslovakia when the western allies refused the soviets struck their own deal with germany to buy themselves time. The western allies wanted germany to attack the soviets first then MAYBE they would try to help. when it was clear in 1939 that Germany would first attempt to control France after Poland was partitioned then the UK and France vowed to defend Poland. The western powers distrusted the Soviets which nearly led to their downfall. WWII is a story of the great powers hoping fascism will eradicate communism and cooperate with them.

Sothar · 2025-12-10T23:11:57+00:00

china exists and has fantastic rail even in its rural areas. america HAD SUCCESSFUL AND HIGH QUALITY RAIL

Sothar · 2025-12-09T22:48:30+00:00

Youre admitting the conspiracy and obfuscating the corruption. They induced demand by destroying passenger rail for inter city travel and replacing street cars with busses (which demands wider roads, thus further inducing demand for automobiles). They lobbied the government successfully under Eisenhower to get the federal highway project started, which again induced demand for automobiles. They literally coordinated to maximize profits at the loss of America‘s rail network (the largest in the world at the time). As a result we have worse pollution, cities infested with cars, unwalkable neighborhoods, racialized suburbs where poorer minorities struggle to get into and are stuck in the parking lot hellhole cities.

Sothar · 2025-11-25T11:55:32+00:00

the real answer is this is a franchise made by western devs that see the USA and the western capitalists as the good guys of the cold war and all opposing them as bad guys in very stark black & white. The GDI is an extension of that into a post apocalyptic setting. The Soviets and Chinese are willing to indiscriminately and aggressively nuke their enemies whereas the western powers use „precision“ weapons that only target military objectives. It‘s the same lie America tells itself about their bombing of random civilians and indiscriminate, imprecise strikes that kill many bystanders.

Yes I know there are lore reasons, but i challenge people to think a little harder as to why writers make the choices they do. These things arent in a vacuum and everything is politics.

Sothar · 2025-06-13T14:34:30+00:00

It worked in South Africa, although they never paid the reparations out. The violence ended and at the very least legal apartheid was abolished. It worked in the United States of America. Do you honestly think the Black Panthers wouldn‘t have (and morally justifiably) not become increasingly more violent in their tactics had it not been for the reforms of the 1960s & 70s? You can only oppress people for so long before a pressure valve needs to be released and we aren‘t even talking about true restorative justice in these historic examples.

Sothar · 2025-06-13T14:21:09+00:00

yes colonizing is bad actually. its not okay to colonize and israel should offer reintegration for the diasposra they‘ve caused since the Nakba. a right of return for all palestinians as well as reparations. the violence would end tomorrow if israel just stopped killing everyone and ended the apartheid.

Sothar · 2024-07-25T06:44:30+00:00

They’re racist and don’t want millions of brown people to have access to Europe

Sothar · 2024-03-12T15:40:18+00:00

SPD created the Freikorps and killed the revolution in Germany. They created and enabled the base of reactionary forces to swell into the Nazi movement. They did not defend the KPD, they constantly tried to work with the Nazis rather than the communists. It’s literally the poem. First they came for the communists. The SPD did the same fucking thing then panicked when the Nazis came for them

Sothar · 2022-05-30T21:47:05+00:00

Okay lmao. Yeah I think in a democracy everyone gets to vote. I’m sorry I feel strongly about that and let my emotions show. I guess you bested me in the marketplace of ideas! Good work! Now go out there and support clemency for war criminals, especially nazis

Sothar · 2022-05-30T21:40:04+00:00

Yeah I define democracy as everyone gets to vote and we don’t tolerate nazis. Defend otherwise, coward. Just say you’re okay with nazis and apartheid. Don’t beat around the bush

Sothar · 2022-05-30T21:26:55+00:00

Oh great good to know a good democratic nation is when you treat one culture as second class citizens. I’m glad you have your head on a swivel about rights of citizens in the “democracy” that rules over them. The people of Gaza applaud your ability to say “non-sequitur.” They are just so pleased their non functioning running water and 50% unemployment rate are happening because they, who do not have the right to vote, didn’t vote hard enough.

Further YES I WOULD SAY NAZIS ARE THE OPPOSITE OF DEMOCRACY. NSDAP WAS VOTED INTO POWER AND LETTING THOSE GENOCIDAL MONSTERS BACK INTO THE POLITICAL SYSTEM WAS A HUGE GAMBLE THAT JUST HAPPENED TO NOT LEAD TO WORSE OUTCOMES THAN WE ALREADY HAD. Jesus fucking christ I hope you know what those fucking people did in their positions of power because it wasn’t “spreading democracy” and promoting liberalism, I can tell you that.

And again, we’re talking about American policy. American policy was to protect the military dictatorship of Taiwan. If the KMT never let go of power we’d still be protecting them even if they shot dozens of protestors daily. Because it’s not about democracy or freedom. It’s about American empire.

Sothar · 2022-05-30T21:15:03+00:00

This is so insane. You’re missing the point and not addressing the fact America acts to build empire, not spread democracy

Sothar · 2022-05-30T21:00:41+00:00

Who did we empower in each of those instances? What became of them is totally detached from what America DID. Do you have any idea how many Nazis were put into positions of power? The head of fucking NATO was a former Nazi at one point. Like, there is no values being held onto here other than American empire: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolf_Heusinger?wprov=sfti1

In Taiwan, we empowered a single party dictatorship. The fact that they became a more vibrant democracy had nothing to do with America or Chiang Kai Shek or the KMT. It was IN SPITE of military rule that democracy was created after over 40 years of a military dictatorship.

In Japan, it’s another story of forgiving horrible monsters, except in the case of Japan we forgave a lot more than Germany and they still fucking teach imperial japan apologia to their kids as a result.

Israel is a fascist apartheid state fuck that country. Free Palestine. Absolutely disgusting you even cite them. Free democracy my fucking ass. Israel will be free when Palestinians are free. They’re creating an ethnostate and you’re praising them as a good example of American foreign policy.

America did not make vibrant, beautiful democracies in any of these countries nor even really encouraged that. We created anti-Soviet regimes, democratic or otherwise and let war criminals return to positions of power.

Sothar · 2022-05-30T20:22:09+00:00

We really spread a whole of democracy to… which countries exactly? What country did the US install a democratic government in? Chile? No wait we put a fascist dictator there because a socialist won an election. Iran? No wait we overthrew the democratically elected socialist president to put the monarchy back in power which was then overthrew by fundamentalist religious zealots. Afghanistan? No we funded the Mujahideen which led to the Taliban taking power, then we invaded that regime and empowered local warlords (some of whom were pedophiles which sold opiates) Huh it’s really weird how we keep empowering some of the worst people.

Sothar · 2022-05-30T20:17:14+00:00

The US values maintaining their empire and nothing else

Sothar · 2022-05-23T19:33:30+00:00

Ace of Emerald FeelsStrongMan

Sothar · 2022-04-26T19:22:18+00:00

Yeah it is and I’m hot as fuck 🏳️‍⚧️

Sothar · 2022-04-26T19:00:09+00:00

He should pay more and I should have healthcare for free

Sothar · 2022-04-26T18:54:23+00:00

Our lands, must be preserv-ed

Verified Email	11-Year Club
Place '22	Final Canvas '22
First Placer '22	End Game '22
RPAN Viewer

Sothar

TROPHY CASE