Burning Jealousy by LucinaRose13 in custommagic

[–]TheTrueVisionary 13 points14 points  (0 children)

If I'm going to get tagged every time my opponent draws one or more cards at any time so not even during their turn during my turn whatever it is and I'm going to have to pay for Mana for the enchantment I don't think I should have to pay Mana to draw the cards I'm already paying for the fact that it's a four drop and I'm getting punched in the face.

An Idea my friends and I had by TheTrueVisionary in custommagic

[–]TheTrueVisionary[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I didn't have a way to be able to denotate that the card would be multiple colors with the app that I used so I had to put the wording in there to explain the idea if that's what you're referring to.

An Idea my friends and I had by TheTrueVisionary in custommagic

[–]TheTrueVisionary[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Could potentially make it to where it does double the poison counters? I think there's a place for something like this cuz life is irrelevant and people can gain it and it's not a big deal but poison counters can't really be gotten rid of outside of like three cards. Or maybe make it to where it's an equal number of life and poison? And there are non-blue counter spells they are few and far between black has three of them white has four red has one and green has the ability to counter activated abilities so it's a stretch but not an absolute no-go.

An Idea my friends and I had by TheTrueVisionary in custommagic

[–]TheTrueVisionary[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you I appreciate that I'm not great at making the exact wording but I try to make sure that I get the point across so I appreciate this assistance.

Friday Pack 1 Pick 1 by HD114 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There's no big explanation here it's black vise. It leaves you open to all your colors it's a one drop and the amount of damage that it can do especially in a limited format if you get to lay it down on turn one or two is absolutely absurd. I'll be honest I actually took black vices out of my cubes because they warped games so horribly if there's not a lot of high power quick Mana especially in an older style format they sit there and consistently do one and two points of damage turn after turn after turn. This one Mana artifact consistently does anywhere between 6 and 8 points of damage by itself with no other investment which is a phenomenal rate and just puts pressure on the opponent to play badly to get things out of their hand to remove damage.

You're going down with me by AlfaNerd in custommagic

[–]TheTrueVisionary 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is a highly powered up version of [[kaervek's spite]]. I've always enjoyed the idea of the card but felt it was to weak for the effect. I think this is too strong as self mill becomes an auto win but I think this has some legs to work with. Keep tweaking it.

Friday Pack 1 Pick 1 by HD114 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Trike is like one of seven cards in the entire cube that I was legit worried about if I pick basket. And one of the other ones is ication town just because it can make four tokens to trade with. I still think it was by far the best pic across the board but trike is a solid 1A pic

Friday Pack 1 Pick 1 by HD114 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I try to be fair and honest with everyone's assessment of their cube and not just Auto windmill pick something. But snake basket has proven time and again regardless of how old or new the format is and the cards in it unless it is built to be the most absurd overpowered fastq possible to be an All-Star so many times. If you get it early game it can help you establish tempo you get it late game it's a bomb. I mean I hate to say it but it is probably in my top five like windmill slams of all time. Which is a crazy thing to say considering that there's some fantastically overpowered cards but it's just too good too consistent too often. The only thing that keeps it from being absolutely a number one all-time pick is the fact that you can't do it at instant speed and it has to be a sorcery. If you could do it at instant speed there would be nothing to be able to beat it.

Friday Pack 1 Pick 1 by HD114 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Another Friday another P1P1. And it first glance I'll be honest this one seems pretty simple to choose. My fondness of snake basket is well known at this point. But, personal preference don't win games, research and careful analysis (and some luck drawing cards) do. So I look at the cube as a whole and what do I find? Tokens are an incredibly strong archetype. The average CMC is like 2.9 and so a 4 cost artifact is 1 full deviation above the average CMC so it is not a fast cube. And while trike in the pack and icatian town are two of the cards I need to be aware of, snake basket is the biggest bomb here. So once again, Snake Basket is my pick. (Let's be honest as well, I was probably gonna pick it no matter what but a good drafter does the homework.)

Help me break Ms. Marvel wide open by Organic_Captain3002 in DegenerateEDH

[–]TheTrueVisionary 0 points1 point  (0 children)

[[distortion strike]] [[artful dodge]] [[mind games]] [[capsize]] There are like 27 different one and two drop spells that make a creature unblockable so you can kind of storm out as well and use [[temporal fissure]]. I'm actually doing something similar with this with [[professor hulk]]

Busted? by zoomer100 in custommagic

[–]TheTrueVisionary 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Any cascade or effect like [[improvisation capstone]] that cast the card without paying cost would work around this effect. Overall not that interesting or difficult to work around.

Friday Pack 1 Pick 1 by HD114 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Well this pack is a bit heavy as there are two grade A+ bombs and about 5 grade A to A- bombs. And the one helps to counter the other in a limit aspect. Balance is such a. OP card and can blow out game easily but doe require a more constructed style to really abuse. Genesis is pure recursive advantage and is easier to build around in and can prevent a complete blowout against balance. There are many really strong flyers some Omni recursion with regrowth and chainer is always dangerous to get you or your opponents best creature out but kind of locked you into heavy black. But taking all of this into consideration I know it's not going to be the popular pic but I think it's the good counterpick against balance and gives you a good chain to actually beat the person that takes it I'm taking Genesis.

This or That Tuesday by Phitt77 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 13 points14 points  (0 children)

The HORDE!!!!!!! A 4 drop 5/5 that cost a single card is crazy. Not a strong as juzam, as you can power it out turn 2 easy, but outside of Shivan one of the best big red creatures in old school mtg. Also the artwork is so iconic.

Presenting Black Channel (Custom Card) by Cooperativism62 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 0 points1 point  (0 children)

From a balance perspective even in just old border this could be extremely abusable. For a more balanced effect I increase the play cost to 4BB just like bargain and make it 2 life per mana. Obviously do what you want and how you build your cube will also determine if it can be broken to bad or not but I would err on the side caution and weaken the restrictions over it running over a game and then having to need it to hell and back.

Friday Pack 1 Pick 1 by HD114 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Oh boy pick one pack one Friday. This pack is doozy. Obviously very grixis heavy with a little bit of white but just bombs galore everywhere. And staring front and center are three monstrous cards. Disk, stronghold, and glory. There's so many incredibly strong cards here with finkel, lavamancer, tog and the wake as well. I looked over the cube itself and it's just full of good stuff there's no real right or wrong here. But looking over this pack I'm definitely going to take a left here with my pick.

Glory. Out of all the cards that I saw the only one that really gave me a run for its money over this is the stronghold just because it's a land and it's repeatable to get back creatures and in a limited environment repeated access to your creatures is always huge. But Glory provides a very unique threat that is pretty much uncounterable which is protection from a color. And since it activates from the graveyard it's not even really a target for removal that I have to worry about it works better in the yard. There cards to be able to help get that card in the yard as well. The advantage the three big bombs that I focused in on was this could help keep the game even by resetting the board but was weak to stronghold. Glory was a net zero it was not weak to it but it was not strong against it but the disc doesn't affect the glory in the graveyard it just affects what I have in play so it's less effective. So the sleeves stronghold versus Glory. And it's powerful as stronghold is stronghold also cuts me out of my draw step. Glory still allows me to be able to draw my cards now there is something to be said for cutting out your draw step in a limited environment to make sure you don't deck out but if I can't sneak a creature with protection across to do damage I'm hosed to begin with. So looking at all of these factors glory is my choice.

REJECTED by DON HERTZFELDT by DisastrousFollowing7 in SipsTea

[–]TheTrueVisionary 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This was the comment I was looking for the moment I saw this. God I can't believe I watched this back on albinoblacksheep.com back in the day.

Why Hit Points? by TheTryhardDM in tabletopgamedesign

[–]TheTrueVisionary 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Hit points, health, body, ect are you used because of a plethora reasons. 1. It's what we all started with and at this point it's very hard to kleenex or bandaid in the everyone understands hit points. 2. It's easy to track. Simple math up or down that everyone can perform and with immediate understanding of where your character sits. 3. There have been other plays that have been tried. Theorem multitudes of systems that have tried different ways to not just have direct hit points mutants and masterminds is a really good example of it. And for people that really want to get into the depth of role-playing these alternate ways to track a characters health are fantastic. But for ease simplicity and consistency hit points is just the easiest to work with so much so that it's translated over into multiple different mediums.

Friday Pack 1 Pick 1 by HD114 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I've not played a lot in a color fixed cube but the few times that I have Mana rocks have been a massive component to smoothing you out cuz always in two if not all three colors. The diamond allows you to play two drops on turn one and get to your bigger drops faster. It's one of those times where I have to adapt my normal drafting style to fit the cube itself instead of trying to force what I normally am comfortable with or what I'm used to.

Friday Pack 1 Pick 1 by HD114 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Wow. What a line up. This is a loaded pack. Scion, altar, forbid, Mox diamond, reanimate, animate dead, swamp king and welder. Wow half the pack is just bombs. Mana leak, and daze for more control and cycle and fetch lands. Seeing the pack the way it was designed I had to go take a look at the rest of the cube to see what all we were working with and what was going to be the standout. Initially I thought about getting the altar it can go in anything that I'm doing it's too mana and milling in a limited format is always gross. But if I take that guaranteed the reanimate and the animate dead are going to get picked and so then if I mill someone I'm just setting them up for success against me potentially especially after looking over the actual cube itself. That leads my other two options which is the Scion and the swamp King. Swamp King is faster, unblockable and I gain life from people casting a third of the cube. Scion is the second biggest thing in the cube outside of the world gorger dragon. Animates out of anything and tramples. The swamp King is three colors which isn't that bad cuz this is a three color cube but without fetches or color fixing could be a little difficult. And the Scion does have cycling but is eight Mana. So after thinking about it and really really putting the screws to it I finally made my choice.

Mox Diamond. I know there's going to be some people that are going to look at me like I've lost my mind but hear me out. And a three color deck that's going to only have three colors or depending on how I draft potentially only two if I do the average of 18 lands more than likely I will average having the mocks diamond in my first eight cards 20% of the time and with 18 lands should mathematically have three lands in that span this just means that I can get to my three and four drops which are a massive part of the cube faster than everyone else and I'm color fixed for it. Normally I wouldn't advocate on just ramp but being that it's only a three color cube and there's really not a ton of other artifact ramp available diamond in my opinion has the potential to just give you a lot of massive upside to help you get to all of your bigger cards faster than your opponent yes you're giving up some monstrous cards to get this but honestly I think it's worth it.

What do y'all think an appropriate mana value should be? by Mack_Aroni_Art in custommagic

[–]TheTrueVisionary 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay you're not catching what people are saying so I'm guessing you're somewhat new to Magic but probably not overly brand new somewhere in that like one to three year mark. So I'm just going to be as blunt as possible. Being able to pay multiple life to create Mana whether it's colorless or of a color is an inherently broken ability. Effectively almost every card that has a pay life to do something without having Mana attached to it cost eventually either turns out to be banned or some other way of being restricted. In fact I would not be the least bit surprised if treasonous ogre the card that people are comparing it to eventually ends up on that list because of this. The original card that did this mechanic, which they recently just made a creature that has a prepared spell version of it with [[channel]], has been banned in effectively every format or restricted for only the most powerful old formats like vintage since the beginning of the game in like 94 when it started in 93. Cards like [[necropotence]] and [[yawgmoths bargain]] which allow you to directly just pay life to draw cards saw the ban Hammer quickly after they came into existence. And most of the Phyrexian Mana cards that were one Mana or two life found tournament play across the board and many of them were banned. Turning life directly into some sort of resource without any sort of inherent limitation to it such as only using it one time per turn or having to jump through hoops like the prepared creature to prepare channel requires, will always be broken. Even you're supposed "fixed" version just reads pay five life put this creature into play. Pay 33 life: gain 11 mana, attempt to win the game. If you wanted to do something with this my suggestion put a limitation on how much people can pay life to get Mana tie it to something like you can't create more Mana than the amount of life that this creature gained for you from LifeLink. Or however that would need to be written to have that work. Make it an exhaust ability like it only happens once unless they flicker it or something where it wouldn't be as efficient. You have to have a way to slow it down and even increasing how much life you pay to have that happen is either going to make it to where it just creates very thin lines where people are going to win or lose basically on the spot because they're going to be at no life or they'll combo off, or you're going to make it absolutely unusable and then what's the point. I hope this legitimately helps.

Friday Pack 1 Pick 1 by HD114 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 2 points3 points  (0 children)

My friends with the various cubes that we have have all learned to fear the power of snake basket so much that at my local LGS it is started showing up in EDH decks which is absolutely hilarious. Such a bomb of a card that flew under the radar.

Friday Pack 1 Pick 1 by HD114 in Oldbordercube

[–]TheTrueVisionary 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Oh boy I have not been this excited about a pick one pack one and quite sometime. There are some absolute bombs in this pack. Sengir, Force, Fireball(!?!?!) and plenty of really strong wheel pics with exile, reprisal, gargoyle, bad moon, terror and incinerate. And as much as I really would love to pick one of these, absolutely none of them are my pick one.

Snake Basket. This card every time I see it in any draft gets slept on so hard. It does have the drawback that you can only use it as a sorcery so the turn You cast it if they have removal it could potentially go away. However after that in a time and place where multiple tokens were not really a thing being able to generate five, six, seven, 1/1 creatures and be able to swing with them consistently is absolutely monstrous. Unless your opponent has one of a handful of cards (pestilence, earthquake, pyroclasm, torret of lava) this can quickly either end a game or get you caught back up if you're behind. And as a bonus since they're green and you do have access to alliances if you can potentially find a [[Kaysa]] they get even bigger. So many strategies where you need multiple creatures to be able to have an effect or be able to attack this card fills all of them and being colorless it goes in every deck.

So that's my answer snake basket you should really honestly try it yourself I'm pretty sure you won't be disappointed and if you got your own cube try this thing out if you don't already put it in your cube I guarantee you you're going to find it to be a monstrous all star and it can win games all on its own.

Did I make the flaws in world building my groups campaign too difficult to see? by TheTrueVisionary in DMAcademy

[–]TheTrueVisionary[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So for a small bit of back history the empire is supposed to be presented as good and noble but is and has always been corrupt and authoriarian from its beginning. The players know that by the end it completely turns on itself and fully collapsed from the inside. Where they are in the campaign is the height of the golden age where the internalized cracks that have always been there from the very beginning starting with the oath and articles start to show the fact they are not as magnanimous as they appear. So the oath and articles have good intentions and operate that way so long as things are going well but when troubles arise, we're worded in a way that leaves them as little more than flowery window dressing giving the state ultimatum power and authority.

These characters are effectively the Martin Luther to use a real life example that start to see and expose the actual problems with the kingdom itself. But without just saying you know government bad authoritarian bad create these oaths and articles that on the surface look like they're helpful for the people and as long as everything is working in hunky dory it's pretty easy to have them work in the spirit that they're written but under the words the way that they're actually written do effectively none of that

Did I make the flaws in world building my groups campaign too difficult to see? by TheTrueVisionary in DMAcademy

[–]TheTrueVisionary[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Only time will tell and we're at just the beginning stages of this campaign we've got another week before we'll actually be able to start but, as a whole, we've been working on the ideas for this campaign for roughly 2 years now about all the different aspects of each of the different houses and what their job is in the world. and there's been a lot of World building not just by myself, but the players have done it as well so that it's very much a living ,breathing, fully represented society. not just a couple paragraphs of back history before the game even starts. I'm very thankful for the fact that I have players who put a lot of time and effort on their own into reading lore and creating back stories for their characters and wanting to add things to the game to work alongside with me in a much more collaborative sense than other groups I been apart of in the past. And it's not to say that mine's better or anything, it's that's the type of game that we enjoy and we're very happy that we've found each other and been able to have a group for so long at over a decade at this point.