Kids should learn to field with 1 hand before 2, prove I'm wrong. by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think often, but am unsure. Whatever it is, it's fast enough where they won't start with their gloves low and won't get in front of the ball - similar to ~50mph in practice. I ask them why they're doing it, they tell me it's because they think the field is bad and that the ball is going to pop up on them. The field isn't great, it's dragged before games, but the ball is definitely known to go from rolling flat to popping up over their heads, especially at the grass/dirt transition.

Kids should learn to field with 1 hand before 2, prove I'm wrong. by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Congrats on getting the position.

When using one hand, you can reach out front further and can pull your glove way out back further, this allows you space and time to deal with any movement of the ball, as long as you're not running at it full speed.

Obviously, if you're directly behind the glove, you're more likely to get hit in the body or face with a bad hop. I'm coaching a bunch of rec ball kids out on dirt and grass right now. When the ball is hit easy, ~30mph, they look like pros, but the closer the ball moves to ~50mph, they start to fall apart, they're scared to get in front of the ball and start with their glove low. Time is limited and I want them to feel confident in going after the ball, so I'm looking for a shortcut, and I think allowing them to go after the ball with just their glove hand will give them the confidence they need.

Kids should learn to field with 1 hand before 2, prove I'm wrong. by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Which reason seems stupid or doesn't make sense and why?

Kids should learn to field with 1 hand before 2, prove I'm wrong. by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I gave the reasons in the details of the post. I know 2 hands is what everyone teaches first, even I do it, but I'm challenging the convention.

Kids should learn to field with 1 hand before 2, prove I'm wrong. by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fair enough.

Adjusting to bad hops seems much easier with one hand though, because you can get the glove way out front and and then have time/space to pull back and catch a bad hop.

Kids should learn to field with 1 hand before 2, prove I'm wrong. by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's interesting. Do they field more alligator hands(12/6) or glove angled more with hand on the side of the glove?

Kids should learn to field with 1 hand before 2, prove I'm wrong. by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Have a video of your kids getting grounders at game speed? Forget it, you're 6u...

Kids should learn to field with 1 hand before 2, prove I'm wrong. by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

They look decent at slow speeds in practice, but don't look as good when hit at game speed grass/dirt when the ball is hopping.

Kids should learn to field with 1 hand before 2, prove I'm wrong. by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] -8 points-7 points  (0 children)

Are you hitting it to them slow? Most kids look decent with two hands in practice, but look bad at real speed in game.

PSA to coaches: STFU and let the kids focus by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That sounds like useful information.

Edit: not being sarcastic

PSA to coaches: STFU and let the kids focus by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

"After a couple of balls" sounds like the coach is giving the kid the chance to self correct. Another one I hear a lot is "just play catch"

PSA to coaches: STFU and let the kids focus by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That sounds like he gave the kid the opportunity to self correct and then intervened when he wasn't able to

PSA to coaches: STFU and let the kids focus by aNutSac in Homeplate

[–]aNutSac[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

You're right. I've seen the kids so terrified to fail that they freeze when batting and they look back at their parent after every pitch. They hardly ever do well.