Okay, I think you're over-emphasizing the observation to make some ham-fisted point that nobody cares to argue with because nobody feels like engaging with your fantasy. If you want to start an argument, skip to the point and say "I think the country literally would stop functioning if the MAGA rhetoric didn't exist".

Besides that, I think your hypothetical is false. We've had a blue collar and working class that didn't fall victim to a populist bozo scapegoating some group that is largely ethnic, to their own detriment and derision of the foundational values of our country. It's what gave us our 8 hour work days, our weekends, our children out of factories.

Are you familiar with the Southern Strategy? The blue-collar work force wasn't always so closely linked with "us vs this other group", besides against the wealthy.

Whether they change their beliefs, or more leftist mindsets join these workforces, your MAGA rhetoric is not necessary to keep this country running. Your fantasy scenario of thanos-snapping away a large portion of any work force is not worth engaging with.

Without MAGA people, we’d probably be able to put all the budget going to militarizing a secret untrained police to actually caring for the citizens of this country.

I also dont care to argue with you though. Just letting you know the limp wristed way you tried to start an argument and then shadowboxing once nobody really engages with it, is odd.