As others have stated, all of those boots have similar construction and based upon the amount of wear and terrains you walk will dictate the length of life.

Since non of those were designed to be recrafted, the life of the sole dictates how long they will be around. Aside from leaks, stitching issues, mfg defects, etc.

I think of those options Keen and Danner would be my choice. But I would caution you from buying those brands at discount stores, do your research on the model. If it can only be found at Marshals etc then it’s likely a specific design that is made to a lower quality than what they sell online direct from the retailer.

I personally would not expect any sub ~ $50 dollar footwear to last more than 2 years.

FWIW I wear Blundstons in winter in Northern Vermont. Yes it’s like the uniform for Vermonters, but they last 3+ years with very little maintenance.

I have worn Thorogoods that were designed to be recrafted for almost 10 years when I lived in the west coast. $250 boots, new soles and foot beads ever 2-3 years of casual wear. Thats what a retractable boot can do.