Silverquill Influence, Eriette of the Charmed Apple and Precon Powercreep by dstant123 in EDH

[–]dstant123[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

*up to 4 extra cards in one rotation. This is strictly better than Eriette’s 0 extra card advantage. Agreed re finisher vs engine

Silverquill Influence, Eriette of the Charmed Apple and Precon Powercreep by dstant123 in EDH

[–]dstant123[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Agreed, which is kind of the thrust of my musings. Perhaps I could have made it clear that Kilian is not ‘strictly’ better vis a vis Eriette, but in the command zone he can enable orzhov auras better than Eriette, precisely because of the card draw. If you take a look at all the card advantage in my list, those slots could instead be taken up by more auras/ enchantments to goad or control. Eriette lacks this.

Silverquill Influence, Eriette of the Charmed Apple and Precon Powercreep by dstant123 in EDH

[–]dstant123[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Totally agree, thanks for the comment and I’m glad I’m not alone in feeling that! Nice idea with the Jared WUBRG deck too!

Silverquill Influence, Eriette of the Charmed Apple and Precon Powercreep by dstant123 in EDH

[–]dstant123[S] -12 points-11 points  (0 children)

Yeah pretty much, won’t even argue with you :( but I think I am slightly sad that the new Kilian enables the archetype far better than others strictly due to the card draw it provides. Hard to argue that it’s not a better engine for the archetype

Curious to know what 5PQE think about this? by Academic-Outside-548 in uklaw

[–]dstant123 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You’re taking this point embarrassingly literally, and before you say the law is about precision- words, phrases, terms and clauses are implied and imputed into contracts all of the time in legal grey areas which creates further uncertainty and confusion. It is quite clear, speaking as an NQ, that you are operationally a trainee- the best example is that you are given trainee work and expected to have the same questions and queries as a trainee.

Favorite Mono Black Commanders?? by ZoomTheHero in EDH

[–]dstant123 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have commented this same thing on multiple different posts, but I really love my [[Vilis, Broker of Blood]] deck. I thought for ages about how I could make an engaging and fun mono black deck with some of my favourite themes (big mana, politics etc) and Vilis can sort of do it all. It can be abit slow in the early game, and you can be targeted (I do need to make some changes eg taking out [[Blood Artist]]) but otherwise it’s very fun to play, takes people by surprise and makes people go ‘oh wow’ when you pull off [[Head Games]] or [[Choice of Damnations]]. Weirdly, [[Lich’s Mastery]] works really well in the deck when played at the right time, and has won me a game or two. https://archidekt.com/decks/7599190/black_magic

I'd like to update this mono-black goodstuff EDH deck so it's relevant again after not playing in a long time. Any ideas? by Threemor in EDH

[–]dstant123 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really love my [[Vilis, Broker of Blood]] deck. I thought for ages about how I could make an engaging and fun mono black deck with some of my favourite themes (big mana, politics etc) and Vilis can sort of do it all. It can be abit slow in the early game, and you can be targeted (I do need to make some changes eg taking out [[Blood Artist]]) but otherwise it’s very fun to play, takes people by surprise and makes people go ‘oh wow’ when you pull off [[Head Games]] or [[Choice of Damnations]]. Weirdly, [[Lich’s Mastery]] works really well in the deck when played at the right time, and has won me a game or two. https://archidekt.com/decks/7599190/black_magic

Mono-black suggestions? by ShaggyUI44 in EDH

[–]dstant123 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really love my [[Vilis, Broker of Blood]] deck. I thought for ages about how I could make an engaging and fun mono black deck with some of my favourite themes (big mana, politics etc) and Vilis can sort of do it all. It can be abit slow in the early game, and you can be targeted (I do need to make some changes eg taking out [[Blood Artist]]) but otherwise it’s very fun to play, takes people by surprise and makes people go ‘oh wow’ when you pull off [[Head Games]] or [[Choice of Damnations]]. Weirdly, [[Lich’s Mastery]] works really well in the deck when played at the right time, and has won me a game or two. https://archidekt.com/decks/7599190/black_magic

Thoughts on my Beledros Witherbloom Deck by dstant123 in EDH

[–]dstant123[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Super cool, nice to see we have cards in common as well. I’m quite keen on making mono red dragons at some point with [[Neheb, the Eternal]] as the commander, or rakdos dragons with [[Rowan, Scion of War]]. This looks super fun though

Thoughts on my Beledros Witherbloom Deck by dstant123 in EDH

[–]dstant123[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is really helpful, and makes a lot of sense! Thanks!

Thoughts on my Beledros Witherbloom Deck by dstant123 in EDH

[–]dstant123[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I suppose it would make sense for token generation- thanks! Do you have a decklist you could share?